Grumblefish - Paisley has it quite right.
I was the one he narrowly beat - it was of course the fact I was laughing so much at how quickly the Gauls (most suitable emoticon =

) ran off that I was somewhat distracted.
I think the scenario is well balanced and has the added benefit of being large enough to allow a player to snatch victory from what may look like an awfully bad position - the potential to be a real roller coaster.
You might criticise the distance apart at which the forces start (which gives you time to get to know your opponents grandchildren even if he doesn't have any yet) but IMHO and on reflection it gives the latitude to try out several different approaches to the different problems each side faces. I for one will be playing this one again.