Who won this battle?

[Oige1be]

Hey, last we had this situation during a melee.


The hits are in the same color as the unit
Who won who lost and who needed to take a deathroll?
Hope the drawing is clear
As you can see, Gallic1 Gave 3hits and received 3 in total, but Roman 1 gave 3 and received only 2
Roman 3 definitely lost their battle.

Thanks a lot

Christophe "the poor Roman"

[pbrandon]

Each BG asks the question "did I lose?".

Gallic 1 gave 3 hits and received 3. It didn't lose so no cohesion test (CT). It will make a death roll on a +2, so only a base loss if it rolls a 1.

Gallic 2 received 2 hits but gave 5, so no CT and no death roll.

Roman 1 gave 3 hits and recieved 2. No CT no death roll.

Roman 2 gave 1 and received 2. It lost. Death roll and CT.

Roman 3 gave 1 but took 4 hits. It lost. Death roll and CT.

Paul

[ars_belli]

Point of clarification: does the red "3" behind Gallic 1, for example, indicate that it inflicted 3 hits on Roman 1, or received 3 hits from Roman 1?

Cheers,

[marioslaz]

I would say so:

Roman 1 won
Roman 2 and 3 lost

Gallic 1 tied
Gallic 2 won

Roman 2 and 3 need CT

Roman 1 and Gallic 2 doesn't need death roll (they both have +2 because win/tie melee and they need just a modified "3" or better)
Gallic 1 need DR but they loss a base only with "1" (same reason above, but they need "4" or more to don't loose)
Roman 2 loose a base with "1" or "2"
Roman 3 needs a "5" or better to doesn't loose a base.

Mario

[Oige1be]

Point of clarification: does the red "3" behind Gallic 1, for example, indicate that it inflicted 3 hits on Roman 1, or received 3 hits from Roman 1?

Cheers,

Roman 1 gave 3 and received only 2 so Gallic 1 received 3 hits from Roman 1

Thanks all.

Christophe