I have an ideea for how to make battlships more usefull...
If they are near a land unit (not air) it will give an substantial bonus to defense abd atack to similate the big cannons support for hat unit.
In this way we can use more offen the british battleship in the atlantic ocean.
naval combat
Moderators: Slitherine Core, The Lordz
-
- Senior Corporal - Destroyer
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Thu Jun 03, 2010 5:01 pm
- Location: Bucharest (Romania)
Re: naval combat
its already in the game pretty much, battleships can attack coastal units with a barrage option. i do agree that the option should be more viable because right now it costs too much ammo i think. 2 ammo cost for it should be fine imo
Check out Project: IMBA, the balance mod for the multiplayer section of Commander: the Great War. Your input is appreciated! viewtopic.php?f=218&t=39677
-
- Senior Corporal - Destroyer
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Thu Jun 03, 2010 5:01 pm
- Location: Bucharest (Romania)
Re: naval combat
I know about this....and yes 2 insetead of 6 should be more usefull.
But what i was trying to say its that a battleship being near a friendly unit, will give that friendly unit a bonus to defense and a bonus to attack.
I think that the nval combat its ok how it is today...however we should think how to make battleships more usefull, mentaining in the same time the actual costs. and from this perspective ive made this suggestion.
By the way i am still waiting for the event list and their effect to the game and also the morale loss events, like losing a unit, city, etc.
Its so hard to provide me with that,this is a strategy game and i must know....thi is not a card game to say...play and see what is happening.
I ve made this request 10 days ago and nobody give me any response, i think ideserve an answer no matter what it is.
Also can you make something to see on the server, a status for player, like the numeber of maches played, the wins and the loss, hours spent, it should not be so hard.
And maybe in the future to make a tournament for exemple only those who have 10 wins...and it will begin from ,,x" date and the games should finish in ,,y date"
Thanks...but the way the game is awesome, unfortunatly i dindt find the right players, for me 1-2 turns per days its very little...but i am optimistic
But what i was trying to say its that a battleship being near a friendly unit, will give that friendly unit a bonus to defense and a bonus to attack.
I think that the nval combat its ok how it is today...however we should think how to make battleships more usefull, mentaining in the same time the actual costs. and from this perspective ive made this suggestion.
By the way i am still waiting for the event list and their effect to the game and also the morale loss events, like losing a unit, city, etc.
Its so hard to provide me with that,this is a strategy game and i must know....thi is not a card game to say...play and see what is happening.
I ve made this request 10 days ago and nobody give me any response, i think ideserve an answer no matter what it is.
Also can you make something to see on the server, a status for player, like the numeber of maches played, the wins and the loss, hours spent, it should not be so hard.
And maybe in the future to make a tournament for exemple only those who have 10 wins...and it will begin from ,,x" date and the games should finish in ,,y date"
Thanks...but the way the game is awesome, unfortunatly i dindt find the right players, for me 1-2 turns per days its very little...but i am optimistic

Re: naval combat
Hi DukeOfLight,
It's not trivial to get you a list of all events and their effects. They are encoded in the game files, and not in a easily readable table. I would recommend having a look at the contents of the events scripts in Data/Scripts. All the effects are there.
It's not trivial to get you a list of all events and their effects. They are encoded in the game files, and not in a easily readable table. I would recommend having a look at the contents of the events scripts in Data/Scripts. All the effects are there.
Re: naval combat
im willing to play with you, i can usually manage 2+ turns a day and more in the weekend.
Check out Project: IMBA, the balance mod for the multiplayer section of Commander: the Great War. Your input is appreciated! viewtopic.php?f=218&t=39677
-
- Lance Corporal - SdKfz 222
- Posts: 26
- Joined: Sun Feb 05, 2012 4:05 pm
Re: naval combat
I understand the OP's proposal, and agree in theory that BB's need more usefulness to counter their heavy upkeep, cost, and ammo but I do not believe allowing them to add power to adjacent ground units works... Reason is that our hexes are much too large for this to be simulated correctly.
For example, if a BB is in the Adriatic, supporting an ajacent friendly ground unit in Italy, if that friendly unit is attacking an enemy adjacent, then the bonus applied would be implying that the BB can fire it's guns from the Adriatic to the West coast of Italy - Much too far. It currently works that BB's can attack enemy units adjacent to sea hexes, and that would kind of be the only way they could affect anything on the ground - and even that is a stretch in many circumstances.
Reducing the Ammo cost of BB's attack is a good change IMO... 2 ammo per bombardment is probably about right.
fyi my RL job is Naval Gunfire Support Systems, so I kind of have opinions on the matter! In this case, I think gameplay will not suffer...
For example, if a BB is in the Adriatic, supporting an ajacent friendly ground unit in Italy, if that friendly unit is attacking an enemy adjacent, then the bonus applied would be implying that the BB can fire it's guns from the Adriatic to the West coast of Italy - Much too far. It currently works that BB's can attack enemy units adjacent to sea hexes, and that would kind of be the only way they could affect anything on the ground - and even that is a stretch in many circumstances.
Reducing the Ammo cost of BB's attack is a good change IMO... 2 ammo per bombardment is probably about right.
fyi my RL job is Naval Gunfire Support Systems, so I kind of have opinions on the matter! In this case, I think gameplay will not suffer...

-
- Senior Corporal - Destroyer
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Thu Jun 03, 2010 5:01 pm
- Location: Bucharest (Romania)
Re: naval combat
whith what i can view the lua extension?
-
- Sergeant Major - Armoured Train
- Posts: 589
- Joined: Wed Feb 02, 2011 1:45 pm
- Location: Veliki Novgorod
Re: naval combat
If you mean 'how can I open a .lua file', you can open them with Notepad or any basic text readerDukeOfLight wrote:whith what i can view the lua extension?
CEAW Grand Strategy fan
Commander: The Great War beta tester
Commander: The Great War beta tester
-
- Senior Corporal - Destroyer
- Posts: 122
- Joined: Thu Jun 03, 2010 5:01 pm
- Location: Bucharest (Romania)
Re: naval combat
thanks