AAR: OzHawkeye V MarkClark (no MarkClark allowed)

After action reports for Commander Europe at War.

Moderators: Happycat, rkr1958, Slitherine Core

OzHawkeye2
Administrative Corporal - SdKfz 251/1
Administrative Corporal - SdKfz  251/1
Posts: 126
Joined: Sat Jan 24, 2009 7:39 am

Post by OzHawkeye2 »

October 5, 1940

Atlantic


With the southern convoy now eliminated, the Germans turned their attention north, reducing the large convoy from 78 to 65 ships. There still remain just three U-boat squadrons in action, leading the Admiralty to ponder where the other squadrons are as at least 5 are known to have been formed. Two smaller convoys have now entered the Southern Atlantic, 18 and 13 ships each, and the last Battleship from the former Med Fleet, now designated Task Force 15 has arrived. This task force will set sail for the Home Isles shortly, and its arrival will designate the second challenge to U-boat supremacy.

Western Front

French garrison units move westwards around Paris to repair a hole in the now single-file defense line. A new German Panzer division has shown up on the Front, confirming French suspicions that they cannot have seen the whole of the German Army yet. No counter-attacks were made at this time, as the French repaired some forces and awaited the next German move in the hopes of finding more over-extended or worn-out units to fight against.

In the South-East the war of encirclement continues against the invading Italians with French hopes of cutting off both Infantry divisions in the next few weeks.

The British repaired the withdrawn RAF and will consider re-committing it to battle depending on how the French fare on the continent, however with obvious German reinforcements arriving it may well be held back.

Image

Africa

The Eight Army has repaired and withdrawn to its preferred defensive line, no doubt to be harried by Italian Naval and Aerial units as the Italian Army makes its slow advance towards them.

Image

Casualties (Infantry / Tank / Aerial / Naval)

German: 462,312 (^ 24,180) / 1508 (^ 0) / 884 (^ 26) / 265 (^ 0)
Italian: 100,720 (^ 5,036) / 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0) / 5 (^ 0)
British: 1,092,812 (^ 10,072) / 104 (^ 0) / 1326 (^ 0) / 245 (^ 0)
French: 629,500 (^ 95,684) / 572 (^ 0) / 208 (^ 0) / 105 (^ 0)
US: 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0)
USSR: 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0)

Stored Production

UK: 4 (^ 4) -- FR: -3 (^ 26) -- US: 52 (^ 10) -- USSR: 251 (^ 32)

Summary

Well, as expected the French production point deficit prevented me from reinforcing all the units I would have liked to. In particular it leaves the south-eastern garrisons a little understrength. I'm still hoping to isolate and destroy at least one Italian Infantry division before France falls if I can. The Axis has gotten decidedly more cautious in their attacks in the north of France now, which will make it harder to kill more units though hopefully it'll also slow down their advance. If I find more over-extended or weakened units I intend absolutely to sacrifice French production points for German ones - anything I can do to further weaken or delay Barbarossa.

With the correlation of forces as they now stand, and the already late date, I don't think Sealion is on the cards at all. This means that the Royal Navy's Atlantic Fleet (it's only one) will soon number 2 CV's, 2 BB's, 3 Destroyers and a Sub, enough I think to begin paring down his Subs. Strangely only 3 of them are out and about, despite the fact that I know the Germans have at least 5. With one convoy getting very close to docking in the UK, I had expected to see a more all out effort to stop it.

Still all in all, despite some success in the North of France, the initiative remains very firmly with the Axis. Africa has been greatly weakened by the departure of the British Med Fleet, the Royal Navy isn't yet able to come out and play safely in the Atlantic, and the RAF is just a single Fighter squadron. I need to be careful here to make sure that I i) slow down the Italians in Africa for as long as possible, ii) make the Hun pay an ever higher price in France and iii) preserve the Royal Navy until both the threat of Sealion is completely gone and it's strong enough to start getting the convoys through.

Any comments, suggestions, critiques are of course welcome.
Last edited by OzHawkeye2 on Mon May 18, 2009 12:49 pm, edited 1 time in total.
rkr1958
General - Elite King Tiger
General - Elite King Tiger
Posts: 4264
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 2:20 am

Post by rkr1958 »

OzHawkeye wrote: Casualties (Infantry / Tank / Aerial / Naval)

German: 462,312 (^ 24,180) / 1508 (^ 0) / 884 (^ 26) / 265 (^ 0)
Italian: 100,720 (^ 5,036) / 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0) / 5 (^ 0)
British: 1,092,812 (^ 10,072) / 104 (^ 0) / 1326 (^ 0) / 245 (^ 0)
French: 629,500 (^ 95,684) / 572 (^ 0) / 208 (^ 0) / 105 (^ 0)
US: 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0)
USSR: 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0)

Stored Production

UK: 4 (^ 4) -- FR: -3 (^ 26) -- US: 52 (^ 10) -- USSR: 251 (^ 32)
What does "(^xx)" mean in your casualties and stored production numbers?
OzHawkeye2
Administrative Corporal - SdKfz 251/1
Administrative Corporal - SdKfz  251/1
Posts: 126
Joined: Sat Jan 24, 2009 7:39 am

Post by OzHawkeye2 »

rkr1958 wrote:
OzHawkeye wrote: Casualties (Infantry / Tank / Aerial / Naval)

German: 462,312 (^ 24,180) / 1508 (^ 0) / 884 (^ 26) / 265 (^ 0)
Italian: 100,720 (^ 5,036) / 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0) / 5 (^ 0)
British: 1,092,812 (^ 10,072) / 104 (^ 0) / 1326 (^ 0) / 245 (^ 0)
French: 629,500 (^ 95,684) / 572 (^ 0) / 208 (^ 0) / 105 (^ 0)
US: 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0)
USSR: 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0)

Stored Production

UK: 4 (^ 4) -- FR: -3 (^ 26) -- US: 52 (^ 10) -- USSR: 251 (^ 32)
What does "(^xx)" mean in your casualties and stored production numbers?
It's the change. So "German: 462,312 (^ 24,180)" means that German infantry casualties stand at 462,312 an increase of 24,180 over the previous turn.
OzHawkeye2
Administrative Corporal - SdKfz 251/1
Administrative Corporal - SdKfz  251/1
Posts: 126
Joined: Sat Jan 24, 2009 7:39 am

Post by OzHawkeye2 »

October 25, 1940

Atlantic


The German Navy comes out in full force now against the large 65 ship convoy west of Scotland surrounding it completely and sinking 40 of its ships. The Admiralty takes note that the attacking force consisted of 5 squadrons of U-boats and the German High Seas Battleship squadron. British intelligence hypothesizes that this may in fact be the entire German Naval forces.

British Intelligence confirms that the German Naval forces consisted of 2 U-boat squadrons and a Battleship at the start of the war. The Royal Navy claims to have destroyed 3 squadrons of U-boats. With 5 currently active squadrons now confirmed this would indicate a German shipbuilding program of 6 U-boats, a figure the Admiralty concludes is quite possible. With Task Force 15 having reached Casablanca now, the Admiralty grows confident that the projected Royal Navy Atlantic Fleet will be sufficient to challenge U-boat operations in the North Atlantic within the next 90 days.

However, given their currently inadequate strength the surrounded convoy is left to its fate.

Image

Western Front

In the north the Germans continue to slowly advance under their much more cautious battle plans. While this buys the French more time, it does prevent them from isolating any further units for destruction. Redeployment of garrison units plug the hole in the French MLR, while a tactical retreat north of Paris shortens the battle lines somewhat.

In the south, the opportunist Italians are sent scrambling eastwards to avoid being cut off from supply. A French garrison defiantly occupies Milan while the other units repair and prepare to continue trying to outflank the rapidly retreating vultures. The French mobilise another Garrison unit south-west of Paris.

Image
Image

Africa

The 8th Army suffers a major blow with the complete destruction of one of its two Infantry Corps. The Army commander resolves to hit back at the Italian armour in order to try and reduce the Italians offensive potential. These attacks result in 70% casualties to the Italian tanks with only minor British casualties.

If it becomes possible, the 8th Army will consider a strategic withdrawl to Cairo as the combination of Italian land, sea and air units is proving quite costly.

Image

Casualties (Infantry / Tank / Aerial / Naval)

German: 468,348 (^ 6,036) / 1508 (^ 0) / 910 (^ 26) / 265 (^ 0)
Italian: 100,720 (^ 0) / 416 (^ 416) / 26 (^ 26) / 5 (^ 0)
British: 1,153,244 (^ 60,432) / 104 (^ 0) / 1326 (^ 0) / 245 (^ 0)
French: 694,968 (^ 65,468) / 572 (^ 0) / 208 (^ 0) / 105 (^ 0)
US: 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0)
USSR: 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0) / 0 (^ 0)

Stored Production

UK: 32 (^ 28) -- FR: 1 (^ 4) -- US: 63 (^ 11) -- USSR: 284 (^ 33)

Summary

Well, I believe MarkClark has given me a very accurate view of the German Navy with his use of the Battleship to fully contain the large approaching convoy. 5 Subs + 1 BB will I think be more than matched in 4 turns time by 2 CV's, 2 BB's 3 Destroyers and 1 Sub. With his losses in France so high and so late, I don't think he can pull off Operation Sealion (though I will probably make a few Garrison units just in case soon), so it leaves the Navy free to go after those bloody Subs!

The continuous French line of defense isn't going to last much longer unfortunately, probably not more than another turn or two. MarkClark is being a lot more cautious now in making sure he doesn't leave any greatly exposed units, and while it slows him up, it means I'll be hard pressed to add a 6th unit to the French "revenge list". 2 Tanks, 2 Mech and 1 Infantry is still a nice total though....hehe.

In the south, he's withdrawing the Italians to prevent me from encircling them, meaning I'm unlikely to carve any Italian notches into my belt just yet, but I'll settle for robbing him of 5 PP's a turn from Milan for a while and see if the remaining 4 Garrison units can somehow get behind the two Italian infantry divisions still.

Africa blew - losing that whole infantry corp really reduces the 8th Army to effectively the Tank + Infantry Corp as the only remaining mobile units. I blew his Tank unit down from 9 to 2, so if he stops to repair, the 8th is gonna bug out for Cairo while the Garrison unit trips up the Italians advance. In particular I don't like the idea of taking free hits from his 2 BB's for too much longer.

On the whole, I'm pretty optimistic. He's running late and expensive in France, Sealion is almost certainly out, the Royal Navy will soon be able to chase down the German U-boats and Africa while probably a lost cause ultimately will still take a long time for the Italians to finish off.

Ultimately though, I would be real surprised if MarkClark can put together a strong, on-time Barbarossa from here, and really that's where the main action is going to be.
OzHawkeye2
Administrative Corporal - SdKfz 251/1
Administrative Corporal - SdKfz  251/1
Posts: 126
Joined: Sat Jan 24, 2009 7:39 am

Post by OzHawkeye2 »

It would appear that my opponent has gone AWOL. I'll wait a few more days for a response to the Emails I've sent before officially accepting Germany's surrender.
OzHawkeye2
Administrative Corporal - SdKfz 251/1
Administrative Corporal - SdKfz  251/1
Posts: 126
Joined: Sat Jan 24, 2009 7:39 am

Post by OzHawkeye2 »

Still no reply. I've now sent MarkClarke an Email asking for the Axis Password so that I might offer this game to someone else (on the assumption he no longer seems to be playing it).
JyriErik
Sergeant - Panzer IIC
Sergeant - Panzer IIC
Posts: 182
Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2007 9:28 am

Post by JyriErik »

OzHawkeye wrote:Still no reply. I've now sent MarkClarke an Email asking for the Axis Password so that I might offer this game to someone else (on the assumption he no longer seems to be playing it).


I suspect he's in Führerbunker waiting for ArmeeGruppe Steiner to make its counterattack. :)

Jyri
OzHawkeye2
Administrative Corporal - SdKfz 251/1
Administrative Corporal - SdKfz  251/1
Posts: 126
Joined: Sat Jan 24, 2009 7:39 am

Post by OzHawkeye2 »

JyriErik wrote:
OzHawkeye wrote:Still no reply. I've now sent MarkClarke an Email asking for the Axis Password so that I might offer this game to someone else (on the assumption he no longer seems to be playing it).


I suspect he's in Führerbunker waiting for ArmeeGruppe Steiner to make its counterattack. :)

Jyri
Perhaps I should offer terms. Well, it's been over two weeks now with not a word from him, nor any reply to my Emails, including the one asking for the Axis password so I could at least complete the game with someone else. At this point, I'll leave the AAR here unhappily.
joerock22
Captain - Heavy Cruiser
Captain - Heavy Cruiser
Posts: 928
Joined: Fri Oct 03, 2008 12:38 am
Location: Connecticut, USA

Post by joerock22 »

Come to think of it, I had this happen to me once, where an opponent just vanished off the face of the planet. I was the Allies and still holding France in January 1941, so I'm sure that's why. Still, it would be nice if people had the courage and decency to at least tell you "hey, I'm getting my ass kicked, so I surrender. I'm going to go practice some more against the AI." I mean, it is still just a game.
rkr1958
General - Elite King Tiger
General - Elite King Tiger
Posts: 4264
Joined: Wed Dec 12, 2007 2:20 am

Post by rkr1958 »

OzHawkeye wrote:Perhaps I should offer terms. Well, it's been over two weeks now with not a word from him, nor any reply to my Emails, including the one asking for the Axis password so I could at least complete the game with someone else. At this point, I'll leave the AAR here unhappily.
I hope he's ok.
Amicofritz
Lance Corporal - SdKfz 222
Lance Corporal - SdKfz 222
Posts: 28
Joined: Fri Mar 27, 2009 2:02 pm

AAR: OzHawkeye V MarkClark (no MarkClark allowed)

Post by Amicofritz »

Well, I received a PM from him 24th of May, so he was able to operate a personal computer at that time at least.
Post Reply

Return to “Commander Europe at War : AAR's”