nehi wrote: ↑Thu Mar 04, 2021 3:04 am
Unwichtig wrote: ↑Fri Feb 26, 2021 11:19 pm
still could not win with Rupprecht plan after many many hours of Potzblitz experience. Did anyone ever do it?
almost decided rupprecht in saved file (V11.2)...
at the end of this turn it crashed (without autosave)
i dont see much difference in rupprecht and other scenarios except shlieffen, which is the easiest i guess
Good morning nehi,
okay well done, i ll check your file now.
We had many discussions about rupprecht plan on page 79-81 in this forum including some screenshots about the execution.
robotron and I were discussing it and uploaded some pictures as well previously.
Aufmarsch ost is the easiest plan, schlieffen is also managable and often leads to success, no issues with them.
I found the rupprecht plan the most difficult for some reasons tbh.
I managed many times to initially make it look good and invade france with some promissing results. but in the endgame my frontline always collapsed.
So you might need to play a little longer?!
a) Attacking via switzerland leads to much quicker war entry of italy. Once italy joins they easily attacked my french frontline from the south which always overstretched it. so i had to withdraw.
b) attacking via tha alpine regions trying to breach the many french fortresses takes a few extra turns compared to schlieffen. The execution is much slower and therefore the french and later even the british had time to get a strong footprint in france. I got 1 hex close to paris, but could not take it as i was facing fresh british army corps
c) german army corps are always exhausted when they arrive at the coast - fighting with ´red´ labled armies against fresh french and UK troops was insane, attacking not an option.
d) the rupprecht plan does not add any additional ports to germany. this makes the submarine warfare against the entente convoys more difficult - subs need to cross the channel all the time to go back to wilhelmshaven for resupply. this takes too much time. in the endgame rupprecht leads to disadvantages in the naval game as well.
these 4 reasons make is harder compared to the schlieffenplan, i think.
But then again some pro playes seem to make it work so i ll just keep trying.
I ll check the file now.