yest at club,
my oponent moved his general from the Bg he was fighting with arguing that movementrestrictions to générals only apply in manoeuvre phase so in the JAP he could move it even if it was engaged in melee. I checked the rule and couldn't argue but it looked weird to me
who's right?
movement of general
Moderators: hammy, philqw78, terrys, Slitherine Core, Field of Glory Design, Field of Glory Moderators
Re: movement of general
If i understand you correctly you say his general was fighting in melee. If this is the case page 50 top left side of page statesdomblas wrote:yest at club,
my oponent moved his general from the Bg he was fighting with arguing that movementrestrictions to générals only apply in manoeuvre phase so in the JAP he could move it even if it was engaged in melee. I checked the rule and couldn't argue but it looked weird to me
who's right?
....Once declared as fighting in the front rank the commander cannot leave the front rank of that battle group until it is no longer in close combat and no longer in contact with enemy routers'.........
-
rbodleyscott
- Field of Glory 2
- Posts: 28288
- Joined: Sun Dec 04, 2005 6:25 pm
Punch him.domblas wrote:OK BUT HE ARGUED THAT this restriction was wrote in manoeuvre chapter while in JAP chapter nothing restricts general moves.
is clear and unequivocal.....Once declared as fighting in the front rank the commander cannot leave the front rank of that battle group until it is no longer in close combat and no longer in contact with enemy routers'.........
Anyway, it isn't in the Manoeuvre Phase chapter it is in the General Movement Rules chapter.
You were robbed.
hazelbark wrote:rbodleyscott wrote:Punch him.domblas wrote:OK BUT HE ARGUED THAT this restriction was wrote in manoeuvre chapter while in JAP chapter nothing restricts general moves.
Can we get this ruling written into the FAQ.
Computers are fast, accurate and stupid. Humans are incredibly slow inaccurate and brilliant. Albert Einstein
