The Great Rebellion Campaign
Moderators: rbodleyscott, Slitherine Core, Gothic Labs
-
Blathergut
- Field Marshal - Elefant

- Posts: 5882
- Joined: Tue Jan 22, 2008 1:44 am
- Location: Southern Ontario, Canada
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
Well, I was definitely historical!!!!! 
-
ulysisgrunt
- Colonel - Fallschirmjäger

- Posts: 1420
- Joined: Thu Apr 26, 2007 4:59 pm
- Location: The California Central Coast Wine Country
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
I must admit that this is very, very educational in many respects.
I am looking forward to the extension of these basic rules into other areas and periods.
Danny Weitz
I am looking forward to the extension of these basic rules into other areas and periods.
Danny Weitz
What? Over? Did you say "over"? Nothing is over until we decide it is! Was it over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor? Hell no!
-
Blathergut
- Field Marshal - Elefant

- Posts: 5882
- Joined: Tue Jan 22, 2008 1:44 am
- Location: Southern Ontario, Canada
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
South-East
Warlord (Parliament 20%) win versus Blathergut (Royalist 45%)
Warlord (Parliament 20%) win versus Blathergut (Royalist 45%)
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
Well done Warlord you have made the South-East super fervent (deluded fools!) and as for our esteemed leader - no more bubblettes on campaign for him! 
-
ulysisgrunt
- Colonel - Fallschirmjäger

- Posts: 1420
- Joined: Thu Apr 26, 2007 4:59 pm
- Location: The California Central Coast Wine Country
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
Parliament loss...
A tough, tough loss.
Ulysisgrunt 61%
cavehobbit 45%
In some respects it resembled a naval battle with units of both side's lines interpenetrating their foe and trying to engage from the rear.
At least our right wing won and was able to disengage....
Ulysisgrunt
A tough, tough loss.
Ulysisgrunt 61%
cavehobbit 45%
In some respects it resembled a naval battle with units of both side's lines interpenetrating their foe and trying to engage from the rear.
At least our right wing won and was able to disengage....
Ulysisgrunt
-
cavehobbit
- Brigadier-General - Elite Grenadier

- Posts: 2010
- Joined: Tue Dec 07, 2010 2:31 pm
- Location: Sweden
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
Thanks for a good game!Ulysisgrunt wrote:Parliament loss...
A tough, tough loss.
Ulysisgrunt 61%
cavehobbit 45%
In some respects it resembled a naval battle with units of both side's lines interpenetrating their foe and trying to engage from the rear.
At least our right wing won and was able to disengage....
Ulysisgrunt
A large wood surrounded by hedged fields in the middle of the map made it hard to form ordered lines. My left was cut off early from my main force to the right. The battle could have ended with either side winning, but in the end I think luck was on my side...
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
Just finished a Magnificent battle with Doyley50.
His Royalists (66%) came within a hair of overthrowing my line of Parliamentary heroes (41%) before a series of fortunate breaks gave me the victory
As you can see from the casualty reports it was an extremely bloody affair.
Those looking for a limp-wristed dandified hanky-waving Royalist foe would be well-advised to look elsewhere.
His Royalists (66%) came within a hair of overthrowing my line of Parliamentary heroes (41%) before a series of fortunate breaks gave me the victory
As you can see from the casualty reports it was an extremely bloody affair.
Those looking for a limp-wristed dandified hanky-waving Royalist foe would be well-advised to look elsewhere.
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
It was indeed a hard fought and bloody battle, Shawkans' infantry behemoth caused confusion and dismay to begin with, but later the battle tended to break up into desperate smaller actions, and the Roundheads ultimately prevailed. Thanks for a first class battle.There will be much sorrow and grief in the NW at this unhappy outcome.
-
ulysisgrunt
- Colonel - Fallschirmjäger

- Posts: 1420
- Joined: Thu Apr 26, 2007 4:59 pm
- Location: The California Central Coast Wine Country
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
Well Done Shawkhan2!
We needed a victory
We needed a victory
What? Over? Did you say "over"? Nothing is over until we decide it is! Was it over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor? Hell no!
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
Current report from the front(s): the dull and mirthless traitors have so far effected a three point swing to Parliament...
Keyth
ubi solitudinem faciunt, pacem appellant.
ubi solitudinem faciunt, pacem appellant.
-
deadtorius
- Field Marshal - Me 410A

- Posts: 5290
- Joined: Mon Oct 20, 2008 12:41 am
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
2 games to report
Stunning victory for Parliament 15% victorious over Turenne Royalist 63%
In a complete reversal of the above
Royalist Aryaman 12% Victorious over Parliament 46%
Well played by Aryaman a very able and not so hanky waving general for the King.
Thank you to both opponents for great games.
Stunning victory for Parliament 15% victorious over Turenne Royalist 63%
In a complete reversal of the above
Royalist Aryaman 12% Victorious over Parliament 46%
Thank you to both opponents for great games.
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
General Aryaman reports from the South
Aryaman won 12% vs 46% Deadtorius (+34%)
As our army entered the South we found Lord Deadtorius awaiting in a good defensive position, on a hill, with marshes covering his left flank and a pond to the front, but despite all this our brave troops carried the position in a frontal assault. God save the King!
Aryaman won 12% vs 46% Deadtorius (+34%)
As our army entered the South we found Lord Deadtorius awaiting in a good defensive position, on a hill, with marshes covering his left flank and a pond to the front, but despite all this our brave troops carried the position in a frontal assault. God save the King!
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
Turenne against iandavidsmith : 24% against 40% - for God and the King
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
correction : turenne against iandavidsmith : 20 % against 46 %
-
Blathergut
- Field Marshal - Elefant

- Posts: 5882
- Joined: Tue Jan 22, 2008 1:44 am
- Location: Southern Ontario, Canada
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
From South Wales:
News of a glorious win for the King and the Bubblettes! (There will be many bubbles in the pool tonight!) Blathergut (Roy.) 12% versus iandavidsmith (Parl.) 41%. A hard-fought battle that saw much dithering on the Royalist part at the start (since we didn't want to go up into a battle line completely behind hedges) and just about every unit in both armies fighting at one point. Thanks for an interesting game!!! (Sends you a bubblette as a consolation prize!)
News of a glorious win for the King and the Bubblettes! (There will be many bubbles in the pool tonight!) Blathergut (Roy.) 12% versus iandavidsmith (Parl.) 41%. A hard-fought battle that saw much dithering on the Royalist part at the start (since we didn't want to go up into a battle line completely behind hedges) and just about every unit in both armies fighting at one point. Thanks for an interesting game!!! (Sends you a bubblette as a consolation prize!)
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
With two results yet to be reported, the country state is Neutral with a tiny lean to the King (-1 overall). I will try to post 1643 rules additions later today or tomorrow, got a plane to catch this afternoon.
Keyth
ubi solitudinem faciunt, pacem appellant.
ubi solitudinem faciunt, pacem appellant.
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
Thanks Keith. It would be good to have sight of those whilst we are waiting.
-
cavehobbit
- Brigadier-General - Elite Grenadier

- Posts: 2010
- Joined: Tue Dec 07, 2010 2:31 pm
- Location: Sweden
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
Report from Lowlands:
The Scottish coward hid behind hedges from the very start of the battle. So it was for the King's brave men to either step back and wait for the Scottish cowards to come out in the open and fight (which I guess they never would have done), or I had to send the King's brave men to attack the Scottish cowards. The choice was easy as brave men attack! Said and done I started maneuvering to form a line ready to attack. Eventually the attack could start and soon the first Scottish broke, but the Scottish had some good gun powder and did lots of damage to my brave men. Even though, the King's men could force their way through the Scottish line. But as the sun set, the Scottish had caused more damage than the King's. So the King's men had to withdraw from the battlefield, but still in order...
Scots 39% won vs Royalists 45%
A very close battle. In the last 5 turns or so, it was impossible to tell which side would win. As the result above shows, it was a very close and bloody battle. Especially as most of the fighting started first with about 10 turns left of the game. If not one or two Scottish units had rallied from being broken, the result could have been the other way.
Shawkhan2, thanks for the game, and well played
The following is a plea/suggestion to RBS (if you read this)...
Of course I'm speaking as one of the players of this battle, but I'd like P&S to have the concept of Draw games. As some battles (not many, but some) end without one side being able to achieve neither the 40%/25% or 60% goals, I therefore think there's a place for Draws. I'm not sure how things works right now, but say a battle ends in 0% vs 0% and just 1 man was killed. Would the side having lost that man lose the battle? In Field of Glory a battle can end in a Draw, why not in P&S? I know the P&S game engine does not have the concept of a Draw, but it shouldn't be too hard scripting? In BA/BA2 I'm using a simple script to allow battles to end in a Draw. As I wrote, just a plea... 
The Scottish coward hid behind hedges from the very start of the battle. So it was for the King's brave men to either step back and wait for the Scottish cowards to come out in the open and fight (which I guess they never would have done), or I had to send the King's brave men to attack the Scottish cowards. The choice was easy as brave men attack! Said and done I started maneuvering to form a line ready to attack. Eventually the attack could start and soon the first Scottish broke, but the Scottish had some good gun powder and did lots of damage to my brave men. Even though, the King's men could force their way through the Scottish line. But as the sun set, the Scottish had caused more damage than the King's. So the King's men had to withdraw from the battlefield, but still in order...
Scots 39% won vs Royalists 45%
A very close battle. In the last 5 turns or so, it was impossible to tell which side would win. As the result above shows, it was a very close and bloody battle. Especially as most of the fighting started first with about 10 turns left of the game. If not one or two Scottish units had rallied from being broken, the result could have been the other way.
Shawkhan2, thanks for the game, and well played
The following is a plea/suggestion to RBS (if you read this)...
-
rbodleyscott
- Field of Glory 2

- Posts: 28320
- Joined: Sun Dec 04, 2005 6:25 pm
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
Hi Per-Anders,cavehobbit wrote:The following is a plea/suggestion to RBS (if you read this)...Of course I'm speaking as one of the players of this battle, but I'd like P&S to have the concept of Draw games. As some battles (not many, but some) end without one side being able to achieve neither the 40%/25% or 60% goals, I therefore think there's a place for Draws. I'm not sure how things works right now, but say a battle ends in 0% vs 0% and just 1 man was killed. Would the side having lost that man lose the battle? In Field of Glory a battle can end in a Draw, why not in P&S? I know the P&S game engine does not have the concept of a Draw, but it shouldn't be too hard scripting? In BA/BA2 I'm using a simple script to allow battles to end in a Draw. As I wrote, just a plea...
Read and acknowledged. Send me the script to take a look at please.
Richard Bodley Scott


-
cavehobbit
- Brigadier-General - Elite Grenadier

- Posts: 2010
- Joined: Tue Dec 07, 2010 2:31 pm
- Location: Sweden
Re: The Great Rebellion Campaign
Richard,
That's quick
I'll send you what I got later today when I'm back home.
That's quick





