Pike & Shot Caracole II
Moderators: rbodleyscott, Slitherine Core, Gothic Labs
Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
Two more games finished. I managed to win both.
One battle was against Cavehobbit. He had Transylvanians and I has Polish. A bad matchup for him as he had many medium infantry units that he tried to protect against my massed cavalry. He played excepcionally well and was beating me until I managed a breaktrough by pure brute force and that was a disaster for his densely packed troops as he had to take many morale checks from seeing nearby friendly units breaking, and my horse could make many flank charges. Despite that, the battle was in balance for some time as he played better than me and could make terrific flank charges against my troops. Finally victory was mine with a narrow 47% to 67% or something similar.
The other one was against Aryaman. Late Italian Wars armies, French mine and Spanish his. I started charging like crazy, berserker like, I still don´t know why, and he took advantage of that. Then it was a long struggle to catch up and I was luckier (broke a kiel with three or four rounds of artillery fire). We both had many light units and some parts of the battle were very tactical, specially with light horse, both trying to get a little advantage in what was a chess-like situation. At the end I had the upper hand and came as the winner.
Thank you to my rivals (just in the field of battle!) for two very interesting games.
One battle was against Cavehobbit. He had Transylvanians and I has Polish. A bad matchup for him as he had many medium infantry units that he tried to protect against my massed cavalry. He played excepcionally well and was beating me until I managed a breaktrough by pure brute force and that was a disaster for his densely packed troops as he had to take many morale checks from seeing nearby friendly units breaking, and my horse could make many flank charges. Despite that, the battle was in balance for some time as he played better than me and could make terrific flank charges against my troops. Finally victory was mine with a narrow 47% to 67% or something similar.
The other one was against Aryaman. Late Italian Wars armies, French mine and Spanish his. I started charging like crazy, berserker like, I still don´t know why, and he took advantage of that. Then it was a long struggle to catch up and I was luckier (broke a kiel with three or four rounds of artillery fire). We both had many light units and some parts of the battle were very tactical, specially with light horse, both trying to get a little advantage in what was a chess-like situation. At the end I had the upper hand and came as the winner.
Thank you to my rivals (just in the field of battle!) for two very interesting games.
-
flatsix518
- 1st Lieutenant - Grenadier

- Posts: 753
- Joined: Tue Dec 14, 2010 10:43 pm
- Location: Texas
Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
A pod 1 result:
- flatsix518 Italian 1494-1530 (0%) won vs. kmaher French 1494-1525 (41%)
The Italian army was light troop and gendarme heavy vs a more balanced french army. The skirmishing was rapidly degrading the french army's ability to fight and then disaster struck. An italian gendarmes unit broke a french gendarmes unit and broke into the rear and flank of the main french gendarmes force. In one turn, it completely wiped out all of the french army left flank. I've never seen a single unit do so much damage in one turn. It was devastating and there was no way for the french army to recover.
John
- flatsix518 Italian 1494-1530 (0%) won vs. kmaher French 1494-1525 (41%)
The Italian army was light troop and gendarme heavy vs a more balanced french army. The skirmishing was rapidly degrading the french army's ability to fight and then disaster struck. An italian gendarmes unit broke a french gendarmes unit and broke into the rear and flank of the main french gendarmes force. In one turn, it completely wiped out all of the french army left flank. I've never seen a single unit do so much damage in one turn. It was devastating and there was no way for the french army to recover.
John
-
flatsix518
- 1st Lieutenant - Grenadier

- Posts: 753
- Joined: Tue Dec 14, 2010 10:43 pm
- Location: Texas
Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
Results posted.
53% of Phase 1 games completed.
John
53% of Phase 1 games completed.
John
Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
Result Pod 3:
Tiopepe (German Catholic) 5% won ggarynorman (French) 42%
The French display too much cavalry for this battle. Worried about my left cavalry flank to be outnumbered clearly, was forced to divide my inf regiments in 2 groups to support the heavy cavalry charge. My inf arrived at the right momment to support them. Step by step, french cavalry was wiped out slowly but without stop. At this time, when french inf arrived to battlefield, it was too late. This time german catholics had their happy day.
Tiopepe (German Catholic) 5% won ggarynorman (French) 42%
The French display too much cavalry for this battle. Worried about my left cavalry flank to be outnumbered clearly, was forced to divide my inf regiments in 2 groups to support the heavy cavalry charge. My inf arrived at the right momment to support them. Step by step, french cavalry was wiped out slowly but without stop. At this time, when french inf arrived to battlefield, it was too late. This time german catholics had their happy day.
-
flatsix518
- 1st Lieutenant - Grenadier

- Posts: 753
- Joined: Tue Dec 14, 2010 10:43 pm
- Location: Texas
Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
Result posted.
54% of Phase 1 games completed.
John
54% of Phase 1 games completed.
John
-
ulysisgrunt
- Colonel - Fallschirmjäger

- Posts: 1420
- Joined: Thu Apr 26, 2007 4:59 pm
- Location: The California Central Coast Wine Country
Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
Challenge for Tiopepe
Pw: Tiopepe
Ulysisgrunt
Pw: Tiopepe
Ulysisgrunt
What? Over? Did you say "over"? Nothing is over until we decide it is! Was it over when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor? Hell no!
-
ggarynorman
- Staff Sergeant - StuG IIIF

- Posts: 259
- Joined: Sat Nov 21, 2009 7:37 pm
Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
Here are my challenges for pod 3 namely:
Rbodelyscott
Dortmund
Tiopepe
Iandavidmith
shawkhan2
ulysisgrunt
Choose between
Royalist 1645-1648
New model army 1646-1660
at W1 L6 I am going to wish my self good luck in these battles.
I await your challenges
Rbodelyscott
Dortmund
Tiopepe
Iandavidmith
shawkhan2
ulysisgrunt
Choose between
Royalist 1645-1648
New model army 1646-1660
at W1 L6 I am going to wish my self good luck in these battles.
I await your challenges
Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
Oh good!
I am about fresh out of games to play, battles to lose!
My challenge is up, GGN.
PW=khannnn, as usual
I had to take the Parliamentarians.
If there is anyone else out there who feels like kicking around a newbie I am always up for another defeat.
I am about fresh out of games to play, battles to lose!
My challenge is up, GGN.
PW=khannnn, as usual
I had to take the Parliamentarians.
If there is anyone else out there who feels like kicking around a newbie I am always up for another defeat.
Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
Aryaman (French 1635-1643) won 54% vs 64% Egos (Spanish 1635-1648)
Very tough match!
Very tough match!
-
cavehobbit
- Brigadier-General - Elite Grenadier

- Posts: 2010
- Joined: Tue Dec 07, 2010 2:31 pm
- Location: Sweden
Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
Cavehobbit (Transylvanian 1632-1645) 18% won vs Egos (Imperial 1619-1632) 44%
Thanks for a good game!
Thanks for a good game!
-
rbodleyscott
- Field of Glory 2

- Posts: 28320
- Joined: Sun Dec 04, 2005 6:25 pm
Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
I will take the Royalists. Challenge created. PW: divinerightggarynorman wrote:Here are my challenges for pod 3 namely:
Rbodelyscott
Choose between
Royalist 1645-1648
New model army 1646-1660
Richard Bodley Scott


Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
Hi ggarynorman,
Ill take Parlamentarians. Pass: civilwar
greetings!
Ill take Parlamentarians. Pass: civilwar
greetings!
Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
Result pod 3:
Tiopepe (Scots) 5% won Iandavidsmith (Royalist) 40%
The numerous scot infantry could close the flanks againts royal cavalry before the could flank my army. Pikes and muskeeters take the day
Tiopepe (Scots) 5% won Iandavidsmith (Royalist) 40%
The numerous scot infantry could close the flanks againts royal cavalry before the could flank my army. Pikes and muskeeters take the day
-
flatsix518
- 1st Lieutenant - Grenadier

- Posts: 753
- Joined: Tue Dec 14, 2010 10:43 pm
- Location: Texas
Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
Results posted to here.
55% of Phase 1 games completed.
John
55% of Phase 1 games completed.
John
-
batesmotel
- Field of Glory Moderator

- Posts: 3614
- Joined: Thu Mar 13, 2008 8:52 pm
Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
Pod 1 game
batesmotel (Spanish) 23% beat Pantherboy (French) 53%
Thanks for the game. The loss of both French keils were the big factor in this game. One was shot to breaking by Spanish lights and the other was eventually broken by a Spanish Keil catching it after it had pursues into the woods into some Spanish detached musketeers or crossbowmen.
Chris
batesmotel (Spanish) 23% beat Pantherboy (French) 53%
Thanks for the game. The loss of both French keils were the big factor in this game. One was shot to breaking by Spanish lights and the other was eventually broken by a Spanish Keil catching it after it had pursues into the woods into some Spanish detached musketeers or crossbowmen.
Chris
....where life is beautiful all the time
-
batesmotel
- Field of Glory Moderator

- Posts: 3614
- Joined: Thu Mar 13, 2008 8:52 pm
Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
Pod 1
Challenges for Triarius, flasix518 and Hutzen:
Imperial (1619-32) vs. Bohemian Revolt(1618-19)
Chris
Challenges for Triarius, flasix518 and Hutzen:
Imperial (1619-32) vs. Bohemian Revolt(1618-19)
Chris
....where life is beautiful all the time
-
flatsix518
- 1st Lieutenant - Grenadier

- Posts: 753
- Joined: Tue Dec 14, 2010 10:43 pm
- Location: Texas
Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
Pod 1 result
flatsix518 (Spanish) 51% won vs Pantherboy (French) 61%
I had the advantage in the game in numbers of light troops -- which, in the end, decided the game. I was also fortunate. A raw kiel hung on way longer than one should expect and I gave up a couple of flank/rear attacks where my unit stood stoutly. Game was decided on both flank battles which I won. The french kept pressing the center -- but lost too much elsewhere.
flatsix518 (Spanish) 51% won vs Pantherboy (French) 61%
I had the advantage in the game in numbers of light troops -- which, in the end, decided the game. I was also fortunate. A raw kiel hung on way longer than one should expect and I gave up a couple of flank/rear attacks where my unit stood stoutly. Game was decided on both flank battles which I won. The french kept pressing the center -- but lost too much elsewhere.
-
flatsix518
- 1st Lieutenant - Grenadier

- Posts: 753
- Joined: Tue Dec 14, 2010 10:43 pm
- Location: Texas
Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
Results posted to here.
57% of Phase 1 games completed.
John
57% of Phase 1 games completed.
John
Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
Another game completed. My early Polish beat Vadim84 Turks. A huge horde of bow armed cavalry tried to envelope my left flank but somehow it didn´t happen and my better quality mounted units could grind them down. Most of the battle was decided here as the center and right flank were sideshows. Thank you Vadim.
Re: Pike & Shot Caracole II
Aryaman (royalists) won 42% vs 69% Rumguff (Parliamentarians)
The brave royalist infantry assaulted the Parliament defenses through a storm of fire.
The brave royalist infantry assaulted the Parliament defenses through a storm of fire.



