AAR - modified scenario Obedience to Orders - Spoilers

[fsx]

Abstract

I would like to present an After Action Report of one of my modified scenarios. I chosed "Obedience to Orders".
Sorry, but my English is poor. If someone would help me and would write the text, let me know.

If you want to play a beta-version of the modified scenarios, please look at this thread.
viewtopic.php?f=326&t=55332
Here you will find the download and a "how to" for installation and how to start the modified scenarios (in a campaign).


First analysis and deployment

At first we have the Mission objectives:

orders.jpg (113.99 KiB) Viewed 11199 times

The communication officer gives additional informations:

intell.jpg (66.34 KiB) Viewed 11199 times

Lets take a look at the map.

map.jpg (300.7 KiB) Viewed 11199 times

We see the areas mentioned in the briefings in north-east and south-west, the Victory Hex, the hex-fields with flags and the deploy fields.
Lets find a strategy for this scenario.

titan.jpg (104.16 KiB) Viewed 11197 times

The Steel Hammer is covered in a ruin. It is not allowed to move his unit before we killed all enemy units in this area. Another way to free this area is to force the enemies to move.
The Titan has very strong and long ranged weapons. He could help to clear the area, if we could place a unit with high spotting in the region.
--> We should place our Salamander Scout in the north. Perhaps he could move to the east and avoid enemies. Because we have only six turns to clear the district, we should place most of our units in a way that they help to fulfill this order. I expect enemy forces on the way to the east.

I will place two of my three Basilisks in the south of the deploy area. Perhaps they could support the other units in the first turn(s). We need a unit with high spotting value in this sector too. I have to use my Sentinel. Some other units (one infantery and a tank) should protect the Basilisks.

deploy.jpg (93.58 KiB) Viewed 11191 times

To reach the secondary objective, I have to capture all hex-fields with flags and four of them with my unique "Your Company Command" unit. Lets try to reach the flag in the middle of the map first and lets look in wich direction we will move afterwards. I guess this unit will move to the flag in the east and next to the double-flag southwards.

second.jpg (124.73 KiB) Viewed 11189 times

to be continued......

[nexusno2000]

You're awarded 1000 req; to what end might I ask? Since they don't carry over into the next scenario it seems kind of pointless (not your fault of course, just a feature of the game).

[fsx]

You're awarded 1000 req; to what end might I ask? Since they don't carry over into the next scenario it seems kind of pointless (not your fault of course, just a feature of the game).

As you see in the tread at viewtopic.php?f=326&t=55332 I try to modify one scenario after another. Now, you could play (a beta version) the first 5 scenarios from the 1st campaign.

Another topic is, that unit actions dont work now in WH40K. I would use these actions with the special Company Command unit.
If you have some ideas for reward, let me know. What do you think about changing number of turns or the number of core slots (This will be lost in the next scenario in a campaign!), a free unit ... ?

[nexusno2000]

You're awarded 1000 req; to what end might I ask? Since they don't carry over into the next scenario it seems kind of pointless (not your fault of course, just a feature of the game).

As you see in the tread at viewtopic.php?f=326&t=55332 I try to modify one scenario after another. Now, you could play (a beta version) the first 5 scenarios from the 1st campaign.

Another topic is, that unit actions dont work now in WH40K. I would use these actions with the special Company Command unit.
If you have some ideas for reward, let me know. What do you think about changing number of turns or the number of core slots (This will be lost in the next scenario in a campaign!), a free unit ... ?

You're altering more scenarios? I'll give them a try...

The problem of extra requisition still persists, however. AFAIK there is no way to script in a what-if-I-got-extra-req-last-mission. The scenario req is the final word. Or do you have a working solution?

Getting requisition in-scenario could be useful if you got if fairly early, as you could use it for replacements. Say, take one objective hex, get 250 req, instead of needing all of them for the whole pool. That way you could use all your req to start with, but have a way of getting replacements. Caveat: only relevant if the scenarios is challenging enough to make you need more req.

I have one other idea: I really wish there was a bigger gap between available req and number of unit slots. If there were you could play the game in more fashions than one; you could go for a lot of cheap infantry units, just a few high-value ones, or a mix. Especially from the start of Act 2 this would be super-relevant: do you disband and buy ultrasmurf tanks and bloodangel assault inf, or do you keep you weaker, but experienced low-cost unit and just add a few elites to your roster? I think that would add some depth.

Now to the point: if you could get extra req in-scenario (like in this one you've made) there are even more options. Maybe you can't afford to fill all your slots at start, but once you complete those secondary objectives you get that extra req. Do you use it for reinforcements or new units?

[fsx]

Turn 1

First, we look in the south-west.
There is a Warbuggy with a spotting value of 4. We must kill this unit, because it will be the eyes of the announced cannons.

turn01_south.jpg (136.41 KiB) Viewed 11113 times

turn01_warbuggy.jpg (67.13 KiB) Viewed 11118 times

After this task we step ahead (a little bit) and we see the first cannon.

turn01_cannon_south.jpg (150.4 KiB) Viewed 11118 times

In the north I try to move to east. It would be great, if I could kill all enemy units spotting my units.
Many enemy units have a spotting range of 2.

turn01_distance.jpg (93.93 KiB) Viewed 11118 times

turn01_kill.jpg (167.86 KiB) Viewed 11118 times

After this kill no enemies see me.

[fsx]

You're altering more scenarios? I'll give them a try...

The problem of extra requisition still persists, however. AFAIK there is no way to script in a what-if-I-got-extra-req-last-mission. The scenario req is the final word. Or do you have a working solution?

Getting requisition in-scenario could be useful if you got if fairly early, as you could use it for replacements. Say, take one objective hex, get 250 req, instead of needing all of them for the whole pool. That way you could use all your req to start with, but have a way of getting replacements. Caveat: only relevant if the scenarios is challenging enough to make you need more req.

I have one other idea: I really wish there was a bigger gap between available req and number of unit slots. If there were you could play the game in more fashions than one; you could go for a lot of cheap infantry units, just a few high-value ones, or a mix. Especially from the start of Act 2 this would be super-relevant: do you disband and buy ultrasmurf tanks and bloodangel assault inf, or do you keep you weaker, but experienced low-cost unit and just add a few elites to your roster? I think that would add some depth.

Now to the point: if you could get extra req in-scenario (like in this one you've made) there are even more options. Maybe you can't afford to fill all your slots at start, but once you complete those secondary objectives you get that extra req. Do you use it for reinforcements or new units?

You are right if you play a scenario. Requisition points at the end are (near) useless. It works in campaigns.
In a single scenario I would add core slots or additional units triggered in the map.
Or, if the unit action works, to add experience or give replacements during the scenario.

The additional points I use in / before the next scenario in the campaign to buy / update.

[fsx]

Turn 2

Dte Deff Dread is an inveterate foe.

turn02_attackDeff.jpg (157.27 KiB) Viewed 11108 times

And we have bad luck as a unit moves aside the Deff Dread.

turn02_bad_luck.jpg (175.42 KiB) Viewed 11108 times

In the south are some more enemy units.

turn02_more_long_ranged_south.jpg (202.69 KiB) Viewed 11108 times

Turn 3

Clearing the north is in progress.

turn03_clearing_north.jpg (233.81 KiB) Viewed 11108 times

Turn 4

My Rough Riders are gone, but now attacks Steel Hammer with his weapons.

turn04_kaval_killed_titan_attacks.jpg (83.7 KiB) Viewed 11108 times

Turn 5

These two units should be killed in this turn.
Only one turn left!

turn05_north.jpg (87.48 KiB) Viewed 11108 times

[fsx]

Turn 6

The last turn for the first task.
I have to move my special unit in a transport to drain the last hitpoints from the Deff Dread.

turn06_north_attack_2.jpg (98.82 KiB) Viewed 11107 times

After killing this unit, the Titan is liberated.
Yes, I must rewrite this message (delete the second part).

turn06_go.jpg (100.05 KiB) Viewed 11107 times

In the south a Warbuggy disturbs the termination of the cannons.

turn06_south_attention.jpg (98.31 KiB) Viewed 11107 times

[fsx]

Turn 7

The next task is to capture the city in the center.

turn07_city_middle.jpg (82.14 KiB) Viewed 11101 times

Turn 8

The Titan moves.

turn08_city_middle.jpg (83.85 KiB) Viewed 11101 times

Why this? If the Steel Hammer steps into a trap, you could move the other units away from the dangerous zone.

turn08_attention.jpg (71.07 KiB) Viewed 11101 times

Turn 9

The 1st Victory Hex is captured.

turn09_vh1.jpg (80.86 KiB) Viewed 11101 times

Now, I should make a break.

turn09_stop.jpg (82.95 KiB) Viewed 11101 times

The situation in the south.

turn09_south.jpg (168.66 KiB) Viewed 11101 times

[fsx]

Turn 10

Now we could attack with Steel Hammer.

turn10_spot.jpg (144.08 KiB) Viewed 11100 times

Turn 12

The Company Command had captured the 2nd hex and moves now to the other two.

turn12_spot.jpg (153.72 KiB) Viewed 11100 times

Turn 14

My Salamander Scout detect strong enemy forces. I stop some hexes away.

turn14_att.jpg (147.13 KiB) Viewed 11100 times

My Company Command captures the 3rd Victory Hex

turn14_middle.jpg (93.95 KiB) Viewed 11100 times

Last battles in the south.

turn14_south.jpg (109.63 KiB) Viewed 11100 times

Turn 15

The Titan moves first. A trap!

turn15_ene.jpg (95.68 KiB) Viewed 11100 times

The last hexes with flags are mine.

turn15_middle.jpg (88.43 KiB) Viewed 11099 times

turn15_south.jpg (96.15 KiB) Viewed 11099 times

[fsx]

Turn 16

The Titan captures the Victory Hex. The secondary objectives are reached.

turn16_vh.jpg (91.82 KiB) Viewed 11098 times

The player won the scenario. If he had not captured some other flag-hexes, he could do it now. As long as Steel Hammer is alive, the scenario goes on.

turn16_win.jpg (77.78 KiB) Viewed 11098 times

The map after the victory

turn17_end.jpg (95.04 KiB) Viewed 11098 times