The dustbin

[sirlancelot22]

group c
challemged group c

paswword: hola

[ericdoman1]

Div A

Issued challenge to Londo , pw = londo

[rexhurley]

Div A 3 challenges up for whom who want them password = League

Cheers Rex

[ulysisgrunt]

Draw:
Ulysisgrunt Early Bulgarians 44/41

Yuknoom Lombards 34/34

[Jonathan4290]

Div A

Challenge up for Klayeckles, password: Sciri

[kenh000]

Division F

Challenge for landwehr
PW = landwehr

[Cunningcairn]

Div B

cunningcairn (Lombard) 12/32 beat steve-h8 (Thematic Byzantine) 38/33

[Londo]

Battle of Seminara 1495

Londo (French) 41/61 defeated zumHeuriger (Neapolitan/Spanish) 61/60

Londo (N/S) 54/60 defeated zumHeuriger (French) 64/61

Great games, a lot of thorny tactical problems that had me thinking and thinking (and then often doing completely the wrong thing, particularly in the latter game).

One thing that may have saved my ass in the second game is telling the Calabrian militia to go home! Poor Protected HF with Off Spear - just walking French VPs. I marched them away from turn 1.

This scenario illustrates that FOG isn't always a perfect vehicle for simulating history. (Gosh, Londo, you're kidding?) Historically, the Swiss pikemen pushed across the river and broke their opponents. Good luck trying to recreate that in FOG. Even for Superior troops, the effect of disorder crossing the stream are just too severe.

Ideally you would be able to designate hexes as having a % chance of disordering. So a gentle shallow stream might only have a 25% chance of causing disorder, or whatever number the scenario designer specifies. Maybe we can have that feature when v 2 comes out!

[mcwar]

Div. D

Hi, I've posted challenges and PM for Breogan, chris6, otbc, Yuknoom, Ulysisgrunt, mchargmg, tullius and zumHeuriger against my Achaemenid.

pw = classical

Stefano

[mcwar]

Div. B

I've posted challenges and PM against steve-h8, epos, Kilroy, lydianed, Okie, ricoual74, Cunningcairn, otbc and mchargmg.

Pw = earlyma

Cheers,

Stefano

[ulysisgrunt]

Ulysisgrunt win Italian Condotta Florence 28/31

over

maulet Nueva Castillian 33/33

[maulet]

DIV C. Challenge issued for:

otbc - Later Serbian (later)
pass: maulet

thanks.

[maulet]

DIV C. Challenge issued for:

Arminius - Later Ottoman Turkish (1430-1458)
pass: maulet

thanks.

[Jonathan4290]

Div A

Jonathan4290 (Arab Conquest) 10/37 defeats Matsuhiroshi (Lombards) 48/44

[CharlesWayneRobinson1]

Re: Early Middle Ages: arrange your matches here

Postby Jonathan4290 » Mon Jun 02, 2014 8:52 pm

Div A

Challenge up for CharlesWayneRobinson, password: Charles

Accepted Challenge

[ericdoman1]

If new maps can be used can Slitherine/Newrosoft be able to erase some of the "bugs/discrepancies"

1. When you have destroyed a bg, a unit or units can not move properly

2. Cavalry are still standing when on AI evade vs other mounted troops that have a better impact factor and on ocassions a better combat factor as well. For example superior drilled armoured cav bow and sword will stand vs undrilled superior, HA, knights, lance and sword or average prot (undrilled), cav bow and sword will stand on AI vs superior, undrilled, protected, lance and sword cav.

3. Cavalry can evade through a 1 hex wide gap even passing by enemy bgs

4. Some troops who are always on evade, have not moved and have room to move sometimes stand agst pursuing enemy bgs

5. There are still the odd ocassions, bgs rout or evade through a friendly bg that is in combat

6. Hobilars in the HYW English Britain early dismount incorrectly

7. Any chance I could get some help with my edit and create scenarios it has been well over a year and nothing. Technical tried to help but still I can not use them. Also I can not downnload other scenarios.

There may well be others. SLitherine had informed me that they would not do anything about the above as they are now focussing on V2. As V2 is taking a long time, (is it 18+ months) shouldn't they solve the above.

Do we have any idea when V2 is to be completed or has it stopped?

[ericdoman1]

If new maps can be used can Slitherine/Newrosoft be able to erase some of the "bugs/discrepancies"

1. When you have destroyed a bg, a unit or units can not move properly

2. Cavalry are still standing when on AI evade vs other mounted troops that have a better impact factor and on ocassions a better combat factor as well. For example superior drilled armoured cav bow and sword will stand vs undrilled superior, HA, knights, lance and sword or average prot (undrilled), cav bow and sword will stand on AI vs superior, undrilled, protected, lance and sword cav.

3. Cavalry can evade through a 1 hex wide gap even passing by enemy bgs

4. Some troops who are always on evade, have not moved and have room to move sometimes stand agst pursuing enemy bgs

5. There are still the odd ocassions, bgs rout or evade through a friendly bg that is in combat

6. Hobilars in the HYW English Britain early dismount incorrectly

7. Any chance I could get some help with my edit and create scenarios it has been well over a year and nothing. Technical tried to help but still I can not use them. Also I can not downnload other scenarios.

There may well be others. SLitherine had informed me that they would not do anything about the above as they are now focussing on V2. As V2 is taking a long time, (is it 18+ months) shouldn't they solve the above.

Do we have any idea when V2 is to be completed or has it stopped?

[ericdoman1]

Div A

eric 9/33 (Foederate Roman east) vs cavehobbit 36/36 (Mid republican Roman/Later)

[kenh000]

Division F

Challenge posted for Constan

My Alexandrian Macedonians vs your Spanish Celtiberians

PW = Constan

[Cunningcairn]

Div B Challenges

Challenges have been posted for ironclad and rexhurley.

PW ironclad
PW rexhurley