When committing suppression fire on a tile, you can hear the cries of the wounded if an enemy unit is present, thus letting the attacking player know if a unit is in the tile therefore knowing he must keep pounding the tile.
I would suggest that no hints are revealed until the unit is visible by scouting.
Suggestion for suppresion fire
Moderators: Slitherine Core, BA Moderators
Suggestion for suppresion fire
GG AWD, WBTS, WiTE Beta Tester
Time of Fury Beta Tester
Panzer Corps, CtGW Beta Tester
Decisive campaigns Case Blue,Barbarossa, beta tester.
SC WiE, WaW, WWI Beta Tester
Time of Fury Beta Tester
Panzer Corps, CtGW Beta Tester
Decisive campaigns Case Blue,Barbarossa, beta tester.
SC WiE, WaW, WWI Beta Tester
Re: Suggestion for suppresion fire
Similar to the last one is when you do suppression fire from a building and hit an enemy unit without the enemy spotting you, please suppress the ambush message unless the enemy unit is visible.
GG AWD, WBTS, WiTE Beta Tester
Time of Fury Beta Tester
Panzer Corps, CtGW Beta Tester
Decisive campaigns Case Blue,Barbarossa, beta tester.
SC WiE, WaW, WWI Beta Tester
Time of Fury Beta Tester
Panzer Corps, CtGW Beta Tester
Decisive campaigns Case Blue,Barbarossa, beta tester.
SC WiE, WaW, WWI Beta Tester
Re: Suggestion for suppresion fire
I think that is too binary for the right feel of battle. Suppressive fire comes in different flavors, from true suppression of active enemy fire to recon by fire, interdiction, or harassment.
The presence of something can be detected by visual, auditory, and even olfactory clues with respect to what is there and what is not - absence can also be important, such as when shooting into some cover does not flush birds. The better the soldiers and especially NCOs, the better the fieldcraft for this sort of thing.
The presence of something can be detected by visual, auditory, and even olfactory clues with respect to what is there and what is not - absence can also be important, such as when shooting into some cover does not flush birds. The better the soldiers and especially NCOs, the better the fieldcraft for this sort of thing.
-
- Slitherine
- Posts: 535
- Joined: Tue Nov 13, 2012 6:24 pm
Re: Suggestion for suppresion fire
On a successful ambush, the location of the message seen by the opponent is shifted randomly so the player knows they were ambushed and from which general direction, but not the exact tile.rjh1971 wrote:Similar to the last one is when you do suppression fire from a building and hit an enemy unit without the enemy spotting you, please suppress the ambush message unless the enemy unit is visible.
Re: Suggestion for suppresion fire
I was referring to the info gained by the attacker, not the defender. If the ambush message shows up when attacking a tile you positively know there is an enemy unit.AndrewGardner wrote:On a successful ambush, the location of the message seen by the opponent is shifted randomly so the player knows they were ambushed and from which general direction, but not the exact tile.rjh1971 wrote:Similar to the last one is when you do suppression fire from a building and hit an enemy unit without the enemy spotting you, please suppress the ambush message unless the enemy unit is visible.
GG AWD, WBTS, WiTE Beta Tester
Time of Fury Beta Tester
Panzer Corps, CtGW Beta Tester
Decisive campaigns Case Blue,Barbarossa, beta tester.
SC WiE, WaW, WWI Beta Tester
Time of Fury Beta Tester
Panzer Corps, CtGW Beta Tester
Decisive campaigns Case Blue,Barbarossa, beta tester.
SC WiE, WaW, WWI Beta Tester
Re: Suggestion for suppresion fire
Personally, I prefer to have the sound of voices when firing at a suspected location. Perhaps there can be an option to turn that off or change in a config file?
Re: Suggestion for suppresion fire
Code: Select all
On a successful ambush, the location of the message seen by the opponent is shifted randomly so the player knows they were ambushed and from which general direction, but not the exact tile.
-
- Slitherine
- Posts: 535
- Joined: Tue Nov 13, 2012 6:24 pm
Re: Suggestion for suppresion fire
I will take a look, it certainly sounds like the center tile should be included.rf900 wrote:Regarding this, in the original BA I look at the code and the ambush message never appears on the exact tile where the unit was, that gave me a big hint on where the unit can possibly be. Can you update the random message code so that it includes the center tile also (the one where the unit actually is)?
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 13558
- Joined: Fri Apr 01, 2005 10:19 am
Re: Suggestion for suppresion fire
The sound effect is by design. Suppressing fire is not that useful and without some feedback it would be really hard to use at all. The centre tile should be included if its not on an ambush.