Fragged evading off table, 1 point or 2 points?

[Robert241167]

Hi everyone

This has come up in a few competitions now.

What is the official line for fragged evading off table?

Is it 2 points? (1 for fragged and 1 for evading off table).

Cheers

Rob

[david53]

Hi everyone

This has come up in a few competitions now.

What is the official line for fragged evading off table?

Is it 2 points? (1 for fragged and 1 for evading off table).

Cheers

Rob

Richard answered this IIRC and its only 1 point as its a unit evading off table.

Dave

[dave_r]

Rules as written states it's two.

It may be how it was intended, but not how it was written. It is normally ruled as two Attrition Points.

[david53]

How was it ruled then Robert.

[dave_r]

It wasn't - Rob didn't call the umpire.

[Robert241167]

It's just each time it comes up each party is adamant their stance is correct and it would be nice for clarification to stop further confusion.

Rob

[hazelbark]

Ruddock is always so horribly wrong.

But in this case it is commonly, but not universely ruled as 2 points. 1 for Frag, 1 for off table.

And yes RBS did say that it was not meant that way.

[lawrenceg]

Ruddock is always so horribly wrong.

But in this case it is commonly, but not universely ruled as 2 points. 1 for Frag, 1 for off table.

And yes RBS did say that it was not meant that way.

Let's hope it gets fixed in FOG2

[grahambriggs]

Strangely it's not in the FAQ.

RAW says 2 points, but in a vague fashion, so you could easily misread it as 1 point