Drawn Melee - who tests?

[Three]

Our first game this afternoon without an experienced overseer, this caused a bit of discussion - Situation is as set out below -

= Horse with pistol facing down
= Horse with Light Lance/sword facing down
= Determined Horse with pistol facing up





do 1 casualty
do 3 casualties
do 4 casualties, 2 against each of the Horse BGs

tests because it has lost 2:1, no issues with that.

The question - does test as it loses part of the melee 3:2 or does it not test because it is 4:4 overall.

[Vespasian28]

The latter; it does not test as it has not suffered more hits from all its opponents than it inflicted on same.

[gibby]

Agreed...It does not test.

cheers
Jim

[deadtorius]

They took 4 total and gave 4 total so no test for the determined horse.

[Three]

Thanks for the replies, "no test" was my position so that is a relief

[durrati]

Don't forget it will take a death test and lose a base on a 1 or a 2 though.

[Three]

Don't forget it will take a death test and lose a base on a 1 or a 2 though.

Yep, remembered that, thanks