We played like this from the very first battle in the campaign as you can see it from quote.ilpars wrote: Sun Apr 05, 2026 11:02 am Rolled 1 for battle map type.
As Etruscan army intercepted, Etruscans are the attackers.
Battle map terrain is the terrain in attacker's hex which is Mediterranean Plain.
Armies are 1550 pts, map is wide.
I setup the battle. Password is Vulci
Vae Victis - Romans vs. Etruscans: Ongoing
Moderators: kronenblatt, Field of Glory 2 Tournaments Managers
Re: Vae Victis - Romans vs. Etruscans: Ongoing
-
teodor6100
- Corporal - Strongpoint

- Posts: 57
- Joined: Sat Oct 07, 2023 7:05 pm
Re: Vae Victis - Romans vs. Etruscans: Ongoing
But this doesn't actually make any sense. This first engagement sees a fresh army that has not taken any damage. If it is considered 50 points penalty is too low for an army going to a second battle, then we can make it 100 points with no problem, but nothing should be taken from an army that hasn't fought.
If the argument would go that the second army is already reinforcing the first one, then battle settings should be 1650-1600. And then in the second battle, that second army should also get just 1550p if they choose to reinforce.
And why is the wording like that anyway? Why is it armies at plural? What affliction hit the sabines?
If the argument would go that the second army is already reinforcing the first one, then battle settings should be 1650-1600. And then in the second battle, that second army should also get just 1550p if they choose to reinforce.
And why is the wording like that anyway? Why is it armies at plural? What affliction hit the sabines?
-
Chris Townsend
- Staff Sergeant - StuG IIIF

- Posts: 255
- Joined: Sun Jun 16, 2024 9:31 pm
Re: Vae Victis - Romans vs. Etruscans: Ongoing
I think that the rules are clear for the one battle situation, and I hope and expect that this situation will provoke some rules discussion at the end of this year.
Re: Vae Victis - Romans vs. Etruscans: Ongoing
We can change it at the end of year. We really did not think about it when we first read the rules.
Re: Vae Victis - Romans vs. Etruscans: Ongoing
I also thought the -50FP would happen after the first battle, and have an incremental reduction of -50FP for each battle the same army does (that would be very limited).
However the rules are ambiguous about it, and it could well be an army force penalty for getting "surrounded" or having to leave a garrison behind to watch the second army.
We definitely need to clarify it.
However the rules are ambiguous about it, and it could well be an army force penalty for getting "surrounded" or having to leave a garrison behind to watch the second army.
We definitely need to clarify it.
Re: Vae Victis - Romans vs. Etruscans: Ongoing
If you want we can only change the "1600 FP" to "1650 FP" in the rulebook right after this battle.
It is a simple change which will make all strong armies first battle in an operation at 1600 unless they are crossing a river.
It is a simple change which will make all strong armies first battle in an operation at 1600 unless they are crossing a river.
-
teodor6100
- Corporal - Strongpoint

- Posts: 57
- Joined: Sat Oct 07, 2023 7:05 pm
Re: Vae Victis - Romans vs. Etruscans: Ongoing
I would be in favour of this change
-
kronenblatt
- General - Carrier

- Posts: 4907
- Joined: Mon Jun 03, 2019 4:17 pm
- Location: Stockholm, SWEDEN
Re: Vae Victis - Romans vs. Etruscans: Ongoing
Just some background: Yes, the rules are vague about when two or more battles are fought out, but the original intention was for them to be fought out simultaneously (to save time). And therefore the -50 FP per battle applies to all battles, e.g.,
).
Of course, this is just background information from when rules were originally drafted, so you guys should freely amend rules to your liking.
Enjoy!
- 1 battle for an army => -50 FP in the battle for that army
- 2 battles for an army => -100 FP per battle in both of the two battles for that army
- 3 battles for an army => -150 FP per battle in all three battles for that army
Of course, this is just background information from when rules were originally drafted, so you guys should freely amend rules to your liking.
Enjoy!
kronenblatt's campaign and tournament thread hub:
https://www.slitherine.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=108643
https://www.slitherine.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=108643
Re: Vae Victis - Romans vs. Etruscans: Ongoing
Probably there was not any time before that we have this situation. So we have not done it before.
As first battle is due to interception, we may assume that battles happen at different dates.
In any case we just started this way.
As first battle is due to interception, we may assume that battles happen at different dates.
In any case we just started this way.
-
kronenblatt
- General - Carrier

- Posts: 4907
- Joined: Mon Jun 03, 2019 4:17 pm
- Location: Stockholm, SWEDEN
Re: Vae Victis - Romans vs. Etruscans: Ongoing
Excellent!
kronenblatt's campaign and tournament thread hub:
https://www.slitherine.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=108643
https://www.slitherine.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=108643
-
teodor6100
- Corporal - Strongpoint

- Posts: 57
- Joined: Sat Oct 07, 2023 7:05 pm
Re: Vae Victis - Romans vs. Etruscans: Ongoing
Well, I like the idea that it helps the speed of play for the campaign, but at the same time it feels like it causes more issues. Because now the etruscans could lose the game and have to retreat before the second battle, but if we played a second battle at the same time and won then the roman army would have to retreat at the same time with the etruscan army which is a bit weird. Or maybe the sabine army damages etruscan army beyond 40%, which would drop the army power and give 50 points advantage for the romans in the next battle, something we wouldn't know if we didn't play them in order. Not sure how I feel about this being fair for the side with two armies
-
Chris Townsend
- Staff Sergeant - StuG IIIF

- Posts: 255
- Joined: Sun Jun 16, 2024 9:31 pm
Re: Vae Victis - Romans vs. Etruscans: Ongoing
I like the idea that the battles happen in the order that they are declared - it is a simple logic. In the event that one (or more) battle is not an interception, it would give the defending army the option of choosing the order of the battles, or, if they declined to attack, it would give that same option to the attackers.
As you point out with your example of 40 rout points, an important issue is how the effects of the battle are applied - if sequential, it is fairly obvious, less so if simultaneous. If results are applied simultaneously, it could go as follows:
1. Two battle army wins both - it has choice of which hex to advance into.
2, One loss and one defeat (either could be a draw with the random DR determining who retreats) - army does not move, defeated attacked retreats, winner does not advance.
3. two-battle army loses both - must retreat away from both attackers, attackers choose one army to advance.
As you point out with your example of 40 rout points, an important issue is how the effects of the battle are applied - if sequential, it is fairly obvious, less so if simultaneous. If results are applied simultaneously, it could go as follows:
1. Two battle army wins both - it has choice of which hex to advance into.
2, One loss and one defeat (either could be a draw with the random DR determining who retreats) - army does not move, defeated attacked retreats, winner does not advance.
3. two-battle army loses both - must retreat away from both attackers, attackers choose one army to advance.
Re: Vae Victis - Romans vs. Etruscans: Ongoing
Yes simultanenous battles will be too complicated.
Instead giving an army additional -50 FP penalty for each battle after first that they fought in a single operation is much more simpler.
Instead giving an army additional -50 FP penalty for each battle after first that they fought in a single operation is much more simpler.

