It's not gamey to use the edges. You can see that as up against terrain unsuitable for troops. Most ancient battles were anchored on some features. Or you could see it as the positions both armies have taken up. Rarely was one army's forces sent skittling over and around the other's flank like is ...

You're right it's not a huge deal but if it's penalized in TT then it would be nice if it was the same here.

You can camp all you want but if you use the map edges as a flank there should be a penalty.

There was no other flank. It was guarded by map edges. He made a wall around his camp and sat there.

It doesn't happen too often because the MP population here is pretty good but sometimes you will get the gamey camper. I recently played someone that was using the edges of the map to guard his flank. It's horribly unrealistic and extremely gamey. He sat there with a wall of Roman shield and refused ...

I counted 7 total wins for smaller BGs. One of those wins was 11/33 vs 48/46, quite a difference there. Also, some of these "bigger" BGs are as small as a 1-5 point difference, so I'm not sure I see the significance. I think it just depends on how you build your army, and if you are adjusting your ...

your in game posts suggested otherwise.

Not to mention that our original battle was not password protected.

Stilicho Grow up. I can't keep playing the same battle all over again and again.

Had the battle been opened for you to accept I would have notified you by email. No need to be rude about ...

The replayed battle between Ptolemaics and Carthaginians is over again,

The Carthaginian resigned when the losses had reached 40/53 for him and 31/51 for our illustrious army.

Ptolemy the 31st

Lol..this wasn't even a campaign battle. You accepted an UNpassworded game that I made to test an army ...

I have to say this mod looks amazing. I love the napoleonic era and greatly look forward to FoG Napoleonic release.

Shame that something happened to the work .