Companions Cup
Moderators: Slitherine Core, FoG PC Moderator, NewRoSoft
-
ericdoman1
- General - King Tiger

- Posts: 3776
- Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2010 6:43 pm
- Location: Wales
Re: Companions Cup
Jonno 83/81 vs eric 25/58
As has been mentioned Jon's cohesion test rolls prob lost him the game. Although he did make a game of it. he could have quite easily stayed on top of the steep hills on his right and further back in the woods on his left and back further in the centre.
As has been mentioned Jon's cohesion test rolls prob lost him the game. Although he did make a game of it. he could have quite easily stayed on top of the steep hills on his right and further back in the woods on his left and back further in the centre.
-
ericdoman1
- General - King Tiger

- Posts: 3776
- Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2010 6:43 pm
- Location: Wales
Re: Companions Cup
Round 1 ROTW vs North America
Game 1 (very crowded) Thracian(ROTW) – jonno 68/76 vs Classical Indian(NA) - iversonjm 83/79
Game 2 (crowded) Thracian(NA) – TGM 77/77 vs Skythian(ROTW) – Massina-NZ - 43/73
Game 3 (mixed) Classical Indian (ROTW) – rexhurley 52/47 vs Skythian(NA) – Todd645 39/67
Game 4 (open) Alexandrian Macedonian(NA) – Deeter 6/48 vs Late Archie Persians (ROTW) - tullius 64/62
Game 5 (very open) Alexandrian Macedonian (ROTW) – Fedem 25/50 vs Late Archie Persians (NA) - batesmotel 49/49
North America 2 (252 bps) vs ROTW 3 (254 bps)
Europe vs UK and Ireland
Round 1 Europe vs UK & EIRE
Game 1 (very crowded) Classical Indian (UK&Eire) – stockwellpete 70/64 vs Thracian(Europe) - cavehobbit 49/74
Game 2 (crowded) Classical Indian(Europe) – Finir 66/63 vs Skythian (UK&Eire) - Eric - 25/75
Game 3 (mixed) Achmaenid (UK&Eire) – maharg25 vs Macedonian(Europe) - dvorkin - started
Game 4 (open) Achmaenid (Europe) – hidde 31/50 vs Macedonian (UK&Eire) - ianiow 46/56
Game 5 (very open) Thracian (UK&Eire)- Triarius 40/77 vs Skythian (Europe) - Boores 64/56
Europe 1 (181bps) vs UK & Eire 2 (210bps)
Game 1 (very crowded) Thracian(ROTW) – jonno 68/76 vs Classical Indian(NA) - iversonjm 83/79
Game 2 (crowded) Thracian(NA) – TGM 77/77 vs Skythian(ROTW) – Massina-NZ - 43/73
Game 3 (mixed) Classical Indian (ROTW) – rexhurley 52/47 vs Skythian(NA) – Todd645 39/67
Game 4 (open) Alexandrian Macedonian(NA) – Deeter 6/48 vs Late Archie Persians (ROTW) - tullius 64/62
Game 5 (very open) Alexandrian Macedonian (ROTW) – Fedem 25/50 vs Late Archie Persians (NA) - batesmotel 49/49
North America 2 (252 bps) vs ROTW 3 (254 bps)
Europe vs UK and Ireland
Round 1 Europe vs UK & EIRE
Game 1 (very crowded) Classical Indian (UK&Eire) – stockwellpete 70/64 vs Thracian(Europe) - cavehobbit 49/74
Game 2 (crowded) Classical Indian(Europe) – Finir 66/63 vs Skythian (UK&Eire) - Eric - 25/75
Game 3 (mixed) Achmaenid (UK&Eire) – maharg25 vs Macedonian(Europe) - dvorkin - started
Game 4 (open) Achmaenid (Europe) – hidde 31/50 vs Macedonian (UK&Eire) - ianiow 46/56
Game 5 (very open) Thracian (UK&Eire)- Triarius 40/77 vs Skythian (Europe) - Boores 64/56
Europe 1 (181bps) vs UK & Eire 2 (210bps)
-
massina_nz
- Lieutenant Colonel - Fw 190A

- Posts: 1137
- Joined: Fri Dec 18, 2009 12:12 am
- Location: Wellington, New Zealand
Re: Companions Cup
NP Ian, thanks for letting me know. Will post the challenge once you are up and running.ianiow wrote:hidde and massina,
Yesterday my poor old computer passed away to silicon heaven. My only access to the internet at the moment is an old pre touch screen phone, so no fog until i can find a repair man next week.
Ian the Invincible
-
ericdoman1
- General - King Tiger

- Posts: 3776
- Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2010 6:43 pm
- Location: Wales
Re: Companions Cup
Round 2
ROTW vs UK&Eire
Game 1 (very crowded) Classical Indian-ericdoman1 (UK&Eire) 25/58 vs Thracian-jonno (ROTW) 83/81
Game 2 (crowded) Skythian-massina_NZ (ROTW) vs Achmaenid – ianiow (UK&Eire)
Game 3 (mixed) Skythian (UK&Eire)-maharg25 vs Classical Indian-rexhurley (ROTW)
Game 4 (open) Alexandrian Macedonian (ROTW)-Fedem 48/54 vs Thracian-Triarius (UK&Eire) 76/76
Game 5 (very open) Alexandrian Macedonian (UK&Eire)-stockwellpete vs Achmaenid-tullius(ROTW)
ROTW 1 (101 BPs) vs Uk&Eire 1 (131 BPs)
Europe vs North America
Game 1 (very crowded) Thracian-cavehobbit(Europe) vs Classical Indian iversonjm(NA)
Game 2 (crowded) Thracian-TGM(NA) vs Classical Indian-Finir(Europe)
Game 3 (mixed) Alexandrian Macedonian-dvorkin(Europe) vs Skythian-Todd645(NA)
Game 4 (open)Alexandrian Macedonian-Deeter(NA) vs Skythian-Boores(Europe)
Game 5 (very open) Later Achaeminiad- Hidde(Europe) vs Later Achaeminiad-batesmotel(NA)
ROTW vs UK&Eire
Game 1 (very crowded) Classical Indian-ericdoman1 (UK&Eire) 25/58 vs Thracian-jonno (ROTW) 83/81
Game 2 (crowded) Skythian-massina_NZ (ROTW) vs Achmaenid – ianiow (UK&Eire)
Game 3 (mixed) Skythian (UK&Eire)-maharg25 vs Classical Indian-rexhurley (ROTW)
Game 4 (open) Alexandrian Macedonian (ROTW)-Fedem 48/54 vs Thracian-Triarius (UK&Eire) 76/76
Game 5 (very open) Alexandrian Macedonian (UK&Eire)-stockwellpete vs Achmaenid-tullius(ROTW)
ROTW 1 (101 BPs) vs Uk&Eire 1 (131 BPs)
Europe vs North America
Game 1 (very crowded) Thracian-cavehobbit(Europe) vs Classical Indian iversonjm(NA)
Game 2 (crowded) Thracian-TGM(NA) vs Classical Indian-Finir(Europe)
Game 3 (mixed) Alexandrian Macedonian-dvorkin(Europe) vs Skythian-Todd645(NA)
Game 4 (open)Alexandrian Macedonian-Deeter(NA) vs Skythian-Boores(Europe)
Game 5 (very open) Later Achaeminiad- Hidde(Europe) vs Later Achaeminiad-batesmotel(NA)
Re: Companions Cup
Round 2
ROTW vs UK&Eire
Game 4 (open) Alexandrian Macedonian (ROTW) -Fedem 48/54 vs Thracian-Triarius (UK&Eire) 76/76
Bloody tough battle against a herd of Tracians and an Excellent Commander. For being open and though I won the initiative I wasn't able to find a very good map for the Alexandrian Army. My center formed by 2 Superior Hypaspits MF Off Spears supported by some MF HW, MF Off Spears and Lght SPrs with Swrd Fought a long battle for the steep hills on the center. Thnks to a great performance of the Supeior Hypaspits and rear support (and luck of course) they were able to hold the line till the very last couple of turns when they collapse. That gave enough time mostly to our left flank were the Agema's Cavalry and Companions supporte by some HF Off Sprs, 2 or 3 MF Off Sprs and one HF Pike did most of the killing capturing a lot of LF, LC some thracian Cav and MF Light Spears. However our cavalry there barely survived as of course they were outnumbered.
On our Right flank we catch mos of thet LC (Light Sprs w/javelins), however they resist there more than I thought causing some BP's on our forces.
We started with a good advantage till their superior numbers started to matter. But we made it....hardly
very difficult as cause of the terrain i was able to use my Pikes not very often.
Tks for the battle Triarius and go go go ROTW!!!

P.S.: Any one knows how to post an image in a way to be able to see on this forum the right side of it? Dont know why it doesnt fit.
Thks!
ROTW vs UK&Eire
Game 4 (open) Alexandrian Macedonian (ROTW) -Fedem 48/54 vs Thracian-Triarius (UK&Eire) 76/76
Bloody tough battle against a herd of Tracians and an Excellent Commander. For being open and though I won the initiative I wasn't able to find a very good map for the Alexandrian Army. My center formed by 2 Superior Hypaspits MF Off Spears supported by some MF HW, MF Off Spears and Lght SPrs with Swrd Fought a long battle for the steep hills on the center. Thnks to a great performance of the Supeior Hypaspits and rear support (and luck of course) they were able to hold the line till the very last couple of turns when they collapse. That gave enough time mostly to our left flank were the Agema's Cavalry and Companions supporte by some HF Off Sprs, 2 or 3 MF Off Sprs and one HF Pike did most of the killing capturing a lot of LF, LC some thracian Cav and MF Light Spears. However our cavalry there barely survived as of course they were outnumbered.
On our Right flank we catch mos of thet LC (Light Sprs w/javelins), however they resist there more than I thought causing some BP's on our forces.
We started with a good advantage till their superior numbers started to matter. But we made it....hardly
very difficult as cause of the terrain i was able to use my Pikes not very often.
Tks for the battle Triarius and go go go ROTW!!!

P.S.: Any one knows how to post an image in a way to be able to see on this forum the right side of it? Dont know why it doesnt fit.
Thks!
-
stockwellpete
- Field of Glory Moderator

- Posts: 14501
- Joined: Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:50 pm
Re: Companions Cup
UK/Eire v ROTW
stockwellpete (Alex Macs) 18/51 beat tullius (Persians) 68/57
My opponent had no chance. The Macs just advanced and crushed everything in sight.
stockwellpete (Alex Macs) 18/51 beat tullius (Persians) 68/57
My opponent had no chance. The Macs just advanced and crushed everything in sight.
-
ericdoman1
- General - King Tiger

- Posts: 3776
- Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2010 6:43 pm
- Location: Wales
Re: Companions Cup
Top man
-
batesmotel
- Field of Glory Moderator

- Posts: 3616
- Joined: Thu Mar 13, 2008 8:52 pm
Re: Companions Cup
While 10 turns seemed to work ok this time, I'd still rather see the limit at 12 turns than 10, especially with my HF and MF based Irish.
Chris
Chris
....where life is beautiful all the time
Re: Companions Cup
??. You missed the thread?batesmotel wrote:While 10 turns seemed to work ok this time, I'd still rather see the limit at 12 turns than 10, especially with my HF and MF based Irish.
Chris
-
ericdoman1
- General - King Tiger

- Posts: 3776
- Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2010 6:43 pm
- Location: Wales
Re: Companions Cup
Round 2
ROTW vs UK&Eire
Game 1 (very crowded) Classical Indian-ericdoman1 (UK&Eire) 25/58 vs Thracian-jonno (ROTW) 83/81
Game 2 (crowded) Skythian-massina_NZ (ROTW) vs Achmaenid – ianiow (UK&Eire)
Game 3 (mixed) Skythian (UK&Eire)-maharg25 vs Classical Indian-rexhurley (ROTW)
Game 4 (open) Alexandrian Macedonian (ROTW)-Fedem 48/54 vs Thracian-Triarius (UK&Eire) 76/76
Game 5 (very open) Alexandrian Macedonian (UK&Eire)-stockwellpete 18/51 vs Achmaenid-tullius(ROTW) 68/57
ROTW 1 (119 BPs) vs Uk&Eire 2 (199 BPs)
Europe vs North America
Game 1 (very crowded) Thracian-cavehobbit(Europe) vs Classical Indian iversonjm(NA)
Game 2 (crowded) Thracian-TGM(NA) vs Classical Indian-Finir(Europe)
Game 3 (mixed) Alexandrian Macedonian-dvorkin(Europe) vs Skythian-Todd645(NA)
Game 4 (open)Alexandrian Macedonian-Deeter(NA) vs Skythian-Boores(Europe)
Game 5 (very open) Later Achaeminiad- Hidde(Europe) vs Later Achaeminiad-batesmotel(NA)
ROTW vs UK&Eire
Game 1 (very crowded) Classical Indian-ericdoman1 (UK&Eire) 25/58 vs Thracian-jonno (ROTW) 83/81
Game 2 (crowded) Skythian-massina_NZ (ROTW) vs Achmaenid – ianiow (UK&Eire)
Game 3 (mixed) Skythian (UK&Eire)-maharg25 vs Classical Indian-rexhurley (ROTW)
Game 4 (open) Alexandrian Macedonian (ROTW)-Fedem 48/54 vs Thracian-Triarius (UK&Eire) 76/76
Game 5 (very open) Alexandrian Macedonian (UK&Eire)-stockwellpete 18/51 vs Achmaenid-tullius(ROTW) 68/57
ROTW 1 (119 BPs) vs Uk&Eire 2 (199 BPs)
Europe vs North America
Game 1 (very crowded) Thracian-cavehobbit(Europe) vs Classical Indian iversonjm(NA)
Game 2 (crowded) Thracian-TGM(NA) vs Classical Indian-Finir(Europe)
Game 3 (mixed) Alexandrian Macedonian-dvorkin(Europe) vs Skythian-Todd645(NA)
Game 4 (open)Alexandrian Macedonian-Deeter(NA) vs Skythian-Boores(Europe)
Game 5 (very open) Later Achaeminiad- Hidde(Europe) vs Later Achaeminiad-batesmotel(NA)
-
ericdoman1
- General - King Tiger

- Posts: 3776
- Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2010 6:43 pm
- Location: Wales
Very Important News
HI Guys
Based on, I believe Fedem's message to SLitherine.
They now have a system set up that will inform a player that he may have cheated.
This is great news as it again confirms that this game is fair and open.
Hopefully Slitherine will announce to the community if a player, players, (better still nobody at all) are breaking the rules.
Might be worth pming all friends and foes you have to inform them about this.
Based on, I believe Fedem's message to SLitherine.
They now have a system set up that will inform a player that he may have cheated.
This is great news as it again confirms that this game is fair and open.
Hopefully Slitherine will announce to the community if a player, players, (better still nobody at all) are breaking the rules.
Might be worth pming all friends and foes you have to inform them about this.
Re: Companions Cup
Hi Eric,
They informed you directly about that?
Tks
They informed you directly about that?
Tks
-
ericdoman1
- General - King Tiger

- Posts: 3776
- Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2010 6:43 pm
- Location: Wales
Re: Companions Cup
Nope but it does look that way.
I am going to wait for Iain to post a message confirming it.
I am going to wait for Iain to post a message confirming it.
-
ianiow
- Lieutenant Colonel - Panther D

- Posts: 1235
- Joined: Fri Apr 27, 2007 11:24 am
- Location: Isle of Wight, UK
Re: Companions Cup
I am back from computerless limbo, bigger and badder than ever
Massina,
I have posted a challenge (L Ach Persian - crowded), password massina
Hidde,
I managed to spirit my injured pike unit away from your bows with 1 AP left for my army. Turn 23 of our epic fight awaits you.
Massina,
I have posted a challenge (L Ach Persian - crowded), password massina
Hidde,
I managed to spirit my injured pike unit away from your bows with 1 AP left for my army. Turn 23 of our epic fight awaits you.
Re: Companions Cup
Thus ended "The Longest Game" :
Turn 23
Achmaenid (Europe) – hidde 41/50 vs Macedonian (UK&Eire) - ianiow 57/56
An epic battle if ever there was one. The injured pike might have slipped away but a Hoplite were sufficiently low in % and open for a rain of arrows.
Down to 57% it went and then four cavalry were in position to charge in...one was enough
Thanks to Ian for a memorable fight!
Turn 23
Achmaenid (Europe) – hidde 41/50 vs Macedonian (UK&Eire) - ianiow 57/56
An epic battle if ever there was one. The injured pike might have slipped away but a Hoplite were sufficiently low in % and open for a rain of arrows.
Down to 57% it went and then four cavalry were in position to charge in...one was enough
Thanks to Ian for a memorable fight!
-
ericdoman1
- General - King Tiger

- Posts: 3776
- Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2010 6:43 pm
- Location: Wales
Update
Round 1 ROTW vs North America
Game 1 (very crowded) Thracian(ROTW) – jonno 68/76 vs Classical Indian(NA) - iversonjm 83/79
Game 2 (crowded) Thracian(NA) – TGM 77/77 vs Skythian(ROTW) – Massina-NZ - 43/73
Game 3 (mixed) Classical Indian (ROTW) – rexhurley 52/47 vs Skythian(NA) – Todd645 39/67
Game 4 (open) Alexandrian Macedonian(NA) – Deeter 6/48 vs Late Archie Persians (ROTW) - tullius 64/62
Game 5 (very open) Alexandrian Macedonian (ROTW) – Fedem 25/50 vs Late Archie Persians (NA) - batesmotel 49/49
North America 2 (252 bps) vs ROTW 3 (254 bps)
Europe vs UK and Ireland
Round 1 Europe vs UK & EIRE
Game 1 (very crowded) Classical Indian (UK&Eire) – stockwellpete 70/64 vs Thracian(Europe) - cavehobbit 49/74
Game 2 (crowded) Classical Indian(Europe) – Finir 66/63 vs Skythian (UK&Eire) - Eric - 25/75
Game 3 (mixed) Achmaenid (UK&Eire) – maharg25 vs Macedonian(Europe) - dvorkin - started
Game 4 (open) Achmaenid (Europe) – hidde 41/50 vs Macedonian (UK&Eire) - ianiow 57/56
Game 5 (very open) Thracian (UK&Eire)- Triarius 40/77 vs Skythian (Europe) - Boores 64/56
Europe 2 (192bps) vs UK & Eire 2 (220bps)
Game 1 (very crowded) Thracian(ROTW) – jonno 68/76 vs Classical Indian(NA) - iversonjm 83/79
Game 2 (crowded) Thracian(NA) – TGM 77/77 vs Skythian(ROTW) – Massina-NZ - 43/73
Game 3 (mixed) Classical Indian (ROTW) – rexhurley 52/47 vs Skythian(NA) – Todd645 39/67
Game 4 (open) Alexandrian Macedonian(NA) – Deeter 6/48 vs Late Archie Persians (ROTW) - tullius 64/62
Game 5 (very open) Alexandrian Macedonian (ROTW) – Fedem 25/50 vs Late Archie Persians (NA) - batesmotel 49/49
North America 2 (252 bps) vs ROTW 3 (254 bps)
Europe vs UK and Ireland
Round 1 Europe vs UK & EIRE
Game 1 (very crowded) Classical Indian (UK&Eire) – stockwellpete 70/64 vs Thracian(Europe) - cavehobbit 49/74
Game 2 (crowded) Classical Indian(Europe) – Finir 66/63 vs Skythian (UK&Eire) - Eric - 25/75
Game 3 (mixed) Achmaenid (UK&Eire) – maharg25 vs Macedonian(Europe) - dvorkin - started
Game 4 (open) Achmaenid (Europe) – hidde 41/50 vs Macedonian (UK&Eire) - ianiow 57/56
Game 5 (very open) Thracian (UK&Eire)- Triarius 40/77 vs Skythian (Europe) - Boores 64/56
Europe 2 (192bps) vs UK & Eire 2 (220bps)
-
ericdoman1
- General - King Tiger

- Posts: 3776
- Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2010 6:43 pm
- Location: Wales
All quiet on the NA and European front
Hi Gents
So any news out there.
The saga has ended, 23 turns wow one heck of a battle.
So any news out there.
The saga has ended, 23 turns wow one heck of a battle.
Re: Companions Cup
Round 2 challenge posted for Rex Hurley - password 'maharg'. Good luck.
Re: Companions Cup
accepted dude come on lets get it donemaharg25 wrote:Round 2 challenge posted for Rex Hurley - password 'maharg'. Good luck.
Re: Companions Cup
Game Over
Very Crowded
Cavehobbit(Eur) Thracians 82/74 v. iversonjm(NA) Indians 17/77
A bit of an uphill fight for the Thracians, who ended up with the wrong terrain.
Thanks for the game.
Very Crowded
Cavehobbit(Eur) Thracians 82/74 v. iversonjm(NA) Indians 17/77
A bit of an uphill fight for the Thracians, who ended up with the wrong terrain.
Thanks for the game.



