ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
Moderators: rbodleyscott, Slitherine Core, Gothic Labs
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
.
Last edited by lascar on Mon Jun 26, 2017 9:48 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
Warlord wrote:There is no arrow showing on the map lascar hence my query.lascar wrote:Warlord, I moved a flying column from 11 to 12 to 7.Warlord wrote:GD, you have lascar in 11, how does that support TGM ? The battle is in 6
Right, they are not on the common thread map but they are on the Royalist LOC map which of course you cannot see.
-
KiwiWarlord
- Lieutenant Colonel - Panther D

- Posts: 1205
- Joined: Mon Sep 24, 2007 7:39 am
- Location: Christchurch, New Zealand
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
Well done K2 moving your Flyer across the top of the Northern Counties then down to the South Western tip of Lancanshire in two days through the driving winds, snow, ice and mud of winter, over fields and through swamps to arrive in good order, well vitaled with dry powder to assist in the defence of Lancanshire.
Shows how good Flyers are.
Shows how good Flyers are.
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
Gavin, warlord and doyleys battle is also on the border so snuggles cannot reinforce. Kingi can send a small force to aid me just as easily as Iandavid can send one to aid kerry.
-
ulysisgrunt
- Colonel - Fallschirmjäger

- Posts: 1420
- Joined: Thu Apr 26, 2007 4:59 pm
- Location: The California Central Coast Wine Country
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
Challenge up for TGM
PW : London
Ulysisgrunt
PW : London
Ulysisgrunt
-
GDod
- Brigadier-General - 8.8 cm Pak 43/41

- Posts: 1849
- Joined: Sun Oct 30, 2016 4:26 am
- Location: New Zealand
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
Correct snuggles can't reinforce.... no awsum Kingi cannot reinforce otherwise snuggles can also reinforce... if mutual move and clash reinforcing army MUST border both counties... Umpire has spoken (to the sound of thunderawesum4 wrote:Gavin, warlord and doyleys battle is also on the border so snuggles cannot reinforce. Kingi can send a small force to aid me just as easily as Iandavid can send one to aid kerry.
"La guerre ne détermine pas qui a raison, mais qui reste" - Bertrand Russell
-
GDod
- Brigadier-General - 8.8 cm Pak 43/41

- Posts: 1849
- Joined: Sun Oct 30, 2016 4:26 am
- Location: New Zealand
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
Warlord and Damatrois (just Warlord updated 29/6) have retired to the countryside to write their memoirs so this is the new regime
Triarius takes over warlords territories and army. His Southern army is disbanded and the territories become unclaimed (changed not disbanded 29/6)
Damatrois's army is also disbanded (changed not disbanded, just late 29/6)
Thus the sides remain equal
Triarius takes over warlords territories and army. His Southern army is disbanded and the territories become unclaimed (changed not disbanded 29/6)
Damatrois's army is also disbanded (changed not disbanded, just late 29/6)
Thus the sides remain equal
Last edited by GDod on Thu Jun 29, 2017 8:05 am, edited 2 times in total.
"La guerre ne détermine pas qui a raison, mais qui reste" - Bertrand Russell
-
GDod
- Brigadier-General - 8.8 cm Pak 43/41

- Posts: 1849
- Joined: Sun Oct 30, 2016 4:26 am
- Location: New Zealand
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
Warlord wrote:GD, you have lascar in 11, how does that support TGM ? The battle is in 6
Sorry the "Battle bubble" has blocked out the movement arrows and army in 7 (but be assured it is thereRight, they are not on the common thread map but they are on the Royalist LOC map which of course you cannot see.
"La guerre ne détermine pas qui a raison, mais qui reste" - Bertrand Russell
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
Gavin, I see you have redone the forces up north, snuggles and Kingi both unable to reinforce. My gallant Cornishmen will fight against overwhelming odds knowing their sacrifice is for a great cause. God save King Charles, the first of his name.
-
GDod
- Brigadier-General - 8.8 cm Pak 43/41

- Posts: 1849
- Joined: Sun Oct 30, 2016 4:26 am
- Location: New Zealand
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
Umm just received orders from Damatrois...unfortunately too late to process this season. He's clearly still in the game so he won't be disbanding, so he's the proud owner of Wales! I still need a player to take over Triarius's (Mike's) army in the south so anyone interested pm me as soon as possible.
Last edited by GDod on Thu Jun 29, 2017 8:07 am, edited 1 time in total.
"La guerre ne détermine pas qui a raison, mais qui reste" - Bertrand Russell
-
GDod
- Brigadier-General - 8.8 cm Pak 43/41

- Posts: 1849
- Joined: Sun Oct 30, 2016 4:26 am
- Location: New Zealand
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
Doley please issue challenge to Triarius (who is taking over the north) not Warlord
"La guerre ne détermine pas qui a raison, mais qui reste" - Bertrand Russell
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
OK,but can you advise how large the armies should be?
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
Gavin/DoyleyDoyley50 wrote:OK,but can you advise how large the armies should be?
As a newbie am I right that armies are
Royalists Renegadoes 1200 = 1000 + 2 additional counties (2x50) +NW Region (1x100)
Parliamentarian Purists 1250 = 1000 + 3 additional counties (3x50) + NC Region (1x100)
Both are field armies - neither being a flying column.
No nearby reinforcements for either of us.
That being the case I am ready to bring bell and good book south to mend the error of the renegadoes ways.
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
Triarius wrote:Gavin/DoyleyDoyley50 wrote:OK,but can you advise how large the armies should be?
As a newbie am I right that armies are
Royalists Renegadoes 1200 = 1000 + 2 additional counties (2x50) +NW Region (1x100)
Parliamentarian Purists 1250 = 1000 + 3 additional counties (3x50) + NC Region (1x100)
Both are field armies - neither being a flying column.
No nearby reinforcements for either of us.
That being the case I am ready to bring bell and good book south to mend the error of the renegadoes ways.
According to Gdod i'm reinforcing Doley, so his force will be 1200 + 180 reinforcement = 1380pts
Border between Westmoreland and County 34 Lancashire
Doley for King, Brian for Parliament, Kelen reinforcing Doley Royalists reinforcing bonus. Open battele (Sorry got this one wrong first time...Snuggles can't reinforce as battle on border between Westmoreland and Lanchashire, Kelen can because county borders both Westmoreland and Lancashire...hope this clarifies situation!))
NB (Flying columns can reinforce as it is assumed they move quickly so takes same time to move two counties as a field army moves one county. Thus, in time for battle)
Also my understanding based on previous turns is that movement and county ownership are resolved before combat, so as you'll ony have 2 counties by then the Rebel force will only be 1050pts.
-
GDod
- Brigadier-General - 8.8 cm Pak 43/41

- Posts: 1849
- Joined: Sun Oct 30, 2016 4:26 am
- Location: New Zealand
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
Doley is correct, unfortunatelt Triarius you only have 1000 + 50pts for 1 county =1050 (the other is your home county so no added points, and also unfortunately Doley is reinforcing after having captured two of your counties....dire straits queue musicTriarius wrote:Gavin/DoyleyDoyley50 wrote:OK,but can you advise how large the armies should be?
As a newbie am I right that armies are
Royalists Renegadoes 1200 = 1000 + 2 additional counties (2x50) +NW Region (1x100)
Parliamentarian Purists 1250 = 1000 + 3 additional counties (3x50) + NC Region (1x100)
Both are field armies - neither being a flying column.
No nearby reinforcements for either of us.
That being the case I am ready to bring bell and good book south to mend the error of the renegadoes ways.
Triarius pull this one off and you'll be a parliamentarian candidate for Lord Protector!
"La guerre ne détermine pas qui a raison, mais qui reste" - Bertrand Russell
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
Thanks for the help, challenge duly set up, password Triarius.
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
Kelen is correct, unfortunately Triarius you only have 1000 + 50pts for 1 county =1050 (the other is your home county so no added points, and also unfortunately Kelen is reinforcing after having captured two of your counties....dire straits queue music
...may I suggest the parliamentatians + scots list to counter)
Triarius pull this one off and you'll be a parliamentarian candidate for Lord Protector![/quote]
Reversely Doley, 1380 - 1050 is one hell of an advantage, so no pressure, but if you loss this one....
Triarius pull this one off and you'll be a parliamentarian candidate for Lord Protector![/quote]
Reversely Doley, 1380 - 1050 is one hell of an advantage, so no pressure, but if you loss this one....
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
Reversely Doley, 1380 - 1050 is one hell of an advantage, so no pressure, but if you loss this one....Kelen2 wrote:Kelen is correct, unfortunately Triarius you only have 1000 + 50pts for 1 county =1050 (the other is your home county so no added points, and also unfortunately Kelen is reinforcing after having captured two of your counties....dire straits queue music...may I suggest the parliamentatians + scots list to counter)
Triarius pull this one off and you'll be a parliamentarian candidate for Lord Protector!
Whereas in good Parliamentary fashion I blame Warlord - so Doyley no pressure on me but for you? Prince Rupert and York?
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
Reversely Doley, 1380 - 1050 is one hell of an advantage, so no pressure, but if you loss this one....Kelen2 wrote:Kelen is correct, unfortunately Triarius you only have 1000 + 50pts for 1 county =1050 (the other is your home county so no added points, and also unfortunately Kelen is reinforcing after having captured two of your counties....dire straits queue music...may I suggest the parliamentatians + scots list to counter)
Triarius pull this one off and you'll be a parliamentarian candidate for Lord Protector!
Whereas in good Parliamentary fashion I blame Warlord - so Doyley no pressure on me but for you? Prince Rupert and York?
-
KiwiWarlord
- Lieutenant Colonel - Panther D

- Posts: 1205
- Joined: Mon Sep 24, 2007 7:39 am
- Location: Christchurch, New Zealand
Re: ECW Campaign 2017 Common Thread
GD this system of the Army Points available to Players per turn is completely unfair and should be revised.
Player's armies should be mustered and plans made using the resources available to them from the Counties held at the start of the turn, not two minutes after the moves are known.
Having the Northern Counties Lancashire Invasion Army smashed in numbers, when it is already marching across the border into Lancashire, by a Flyer trudging through snow, rain, hail, gale force winds and ice through two counties in another part of the Division of Counties seems ridiculous.
I would also like to see players having an option to accumulate resources i.e. Militia and supplies, in their Counties by not including that Counties value in the Field Army of that turn.
eg A player with three Counties can have a Field Army of 1000 + 2x 50 = 1100 points and Home County X gains 50 pts of Militia.
These Militia are made available to the defence of the County by being added to the Field Army of of the Defending Player when that County is attacked.
This should read "Player's decide points for battles by adding up the points from their claimed provinces at the start of the Turn and referring to the following table.Player's decide points for battles by adding up the points from their claimed provinces and referring to the following table.
Player's armies should be mustered and plans made using the resources available to them from the Counties held at the start of the turn, not two minutes after the moves are known.
Having the Northern Counties Lancashire Invasion Army smashed in numbers, when it is already marching across the border into Lancashire, by a Flyer trudging through snow, rain, hail, gale force winds and ice through two counties in another part of the Division of Counties seems ridiculous.
I would also like to see players having an option to accumulate resources i.e. Militia and supplies, in their Counties by not including that Counties value in the Field Army of that turn.
eg A player with three Counties can have a Field Army of 1000 + 2x 50 = 1100 points and Home County X gains 50 pts of Militia.
These Militia are made available to the defence of the County by being added to the Field Army of of the Defending Player when that County is attacked.



