BHGS Challenge
Moderators: terrys, Slitherine Core, FOGR Design
-
quackstheking
- 1st Lieutenant - 15 cm sFH 18

- Posts: 844
- Joined: Tue Jul 20, 2010 2:41 pm
- Location: Hertfordshire, England
Re: BHGS Challenge
Now Alasdair - if you'd have said Louis XIV French you would have got 6 right (I only use the Royalist's to beat Paddy!!)
TYW Swedes, Later Imperial Spanish or Later Austrian Imperial were the back ups but having got a newly painted army I thought I'd better use it!!! Vive la France!
Don
TYW Swedes, Later Imperial Spanish or Later Austrian Imperial were the back ups but having got a newly painted army I thought I'd better use it!!! Vive la France!
Don
Re: BHGS Challenge
Having got my list in shamefully lateDave M Allen (No idea but Large)
I am fielding a "No Idea" army and it is a bit big.
Dave
Actually, Scots Covenant and less than 21 BGs.
-
alasdair2204
- Sergeant Major - SdKfz 234/2 8Rad

- Posts: 600
- Joined: Sun Dec 09, 2007 1:40 pm
Re: BHGS Challenge
That means 20.9 battlegroups and it scared the living daylights out of me at warfare so not looking forward to itdaveallen wrote:Having got my list in shamefully lateDave M Allen (No idea but Large)I can confirm that Alastair got another right.
I am fielding a "No Idea" army and it is a bit big.
Dave
Actually, Scots Covenant and less than 21 BGs.
cheers
Alasdair
Re: BHGS Challenge
Strange, because I'm so looking forward to facing that Austrian Grand Battery again.alasdair2204 wrote:That means 20.9 battlegroups and it scared the living daylights out of me at warfare so not looking forward to it
Dave
Re: BHGS Challenge
Oooh, ooh can I have a go at this ...alasdair2204 wrote: well we can always play the guessing game
THESE ARE ALL GUESSES before someone posts these as the actual armies
Alisdair Harley Late Imperial Austrian
Pete Dalby (TYW Swedish)
Kevin Johnson (later Royalist)
Ben Jones (Anglo Dutch)
Lance Flint (TYW Swedish)
Bob Medcraft (Later Louis XIV French)
Simon LeRay Meyer (Later Imperial Austrian)
Charles Masefield (Ottoman)
Don Avis (Later Royalist)
Andy Kitcher (Later Swedish)
Adrian Steer (Later 30YW German)
Richard Young (Central Sudanese)
Martin Van Tol (Early TYW Catholic)
Richard Bodley-Scott (Early Royalist - Cornish)
Dave M Allen (Scottish)
Ric Davey (No idea)
cheers
Dave
PS I've kept more than 5 of Alistairs so I can't be all right
Re: BHGS Challenge
Hmm my post crossed with Don's and Daves - so 1 definitely wrong and 1 half right
Re: BHGS Challenge
Well there are two Later Swedish (one early and one late) I know of plus a TYW French with an ally.
Bob
Bob
-
kevinj
- Major-General - Tiger I

- Posts: 2379
- Joined: Sun Feb 25, 2007 11:21 am
- Location: Derbyshire, UK
Re: BHGS Challenge
Dave scores 4.5. Three of his correct ones are the same as Alasdair's.
I've, now had lists from everybody (thank you all), I'm just awaiting clarification of a couple.
Cheers,
Kevin
I've, now had lists from everybody (thank you all), I'm just awaiting clarification of a couple.
Cheers,
Kevin
-
petedalby
- Lieutenant-General - Do 217E

- Posts: 3116
- Joined: Mon Sep 18, 2006 5:23 pm
- Location: Fareham, UK
Re: BHGS Challenge
How about?
Alisdair Harley Late Imperial Austrian
Pete Dalby (TYW Swedish)
Kevin Johnson (Later Swedish)
Ben Jones (TYW French)
Lance Flint (Central Sudanese)
Bob Medcraft (Later Swedish)
Simon LeRay Meyer (Later Imperial Austrian)
Charles Masefield (Royalist Raiders)
Don Avis ((Later Louis XIV French)
Andy Kitcher (Later Swedish)
Adrian Steer (Anglo Danish)
Richard Young (Central Sudanese)
Martin Van Tol (Later TYW German)
Richard Bodley-Scott (Ottoman)
Dave M Allen (Scots Covenanters)
Ric Davey (Dutch Colonial)
Alisdair Harley Late Imperial Austrian
Pete Dalby (TYW Swedish)
Kevin Johnson (Later Swedish)
Ben Jones (TYW French)
Lance Flint (Central Sudanese)
Bob Medcraft (Later Swedish)
Simon LeRay Meyer (Later Imperial Austrian)
Charles Masefield (Royalist Raiders)
Don Avis ((Later Louis XIV French)
Andy Kitcher (Later Swedish)
Adrian Steer (Anglo Danish)
Richard Young (Central Sudanese)
Martin Van Tol (Later TYW German)
Richard Bodley-Scott (Ottoman)
Dave M Allen (Scots Covenanters)
Ric Davey (Dutch Colonial)
Pete
-
kevinj
- Major-General - Tiger I

- Posts: 2379
- Joined: Sun Feb 25, 2007 11:21 am
- Location: Derbyshire, UK
Re: BHGS Challenge
Pete scores an impressive 9!
-
quackstheking
- 1st Lieutenant - 15 cm sFH 18

- Posts: 844
- Joined: Tue Jul 20, 2010 2:41 pm
- Location: Hertfordshire, England
Re: BHGS Challenge
How's about Kevin scoring a perfect 16 and putting us all out of our misery!!!
Don
Don
Re: BHGS Challenge
Here's another attempt to waste the list checker's time:
Alisdair Harley Late Imperial Austrian
Pete Dalby (TYW Swedish)
Kevin Johnson (Later Swedish)
Ben Jones (TYW French)
Lance Flint (Jacobites)
Bob Medcraft (Later Swedish)
Simon LeRay Meyer (Later TYW German)
Charles Masefield (Royalist Raiders)
Don Avis (Later Louis XIV French)
Andy Kitcher (Later Swedish)
Adrian Steer (Anglo Dutch)
Richard Young (Bornu)
Martin Van Tol (Later Louis XIV French)
Richard Bodley-Scott (ECW Early Royalist)
Dave M Allen (Scots Covenanters)
Ric Davey (Dutch Colonial)
The dominance of WoR and D&G effectively making the case for more themed comps in Dave World
Dave
Alisdair Harley Late Imperial Austrian
Pete Dalby (TYW Swedish)
Kevin Johnson (Later Swedish)
Ben Jones (TYW French)
Lance Flint (Jacobites)
Bob Medcraft (Later Swedish)
Simon LeRay Meyer (Later TYW German)
Charles Masefield (Royalist Raiders)
Don Avis (Later Louis XIV French)
Andy Kitcher (Later Swedish)
Adrian Steer (Anglo Dutch)
Richard Young (Bornu)
Martin Van Tol (Later Louis XIV French)
Richard Bodley-Scott (ECW Early Royalist)
Dave M Allen (Scots Covenanters)
Ric Davey (Dutch Colonial)
The dominance of WoR and D&G effectively making the case for more themed comps in Dave World
Dave
-
petedalby
- Lieutenant-General - Do 217E

- Posts: 3116
- Joined: Mon Sep 18, 2006 5:23 pm
- Location: Fareham, UK
Re: BHGS Challenge
How cool is that!Pete scores an impressive 9!
I'll second that motion!!How's about Kevin scoring a perfect 16 and putting us all out of our misery!!!
Pete
-
kevinj
- Major-General - Tiger I

- Posts: 2379
- Joined: Sun Feb 25, 2007 11:21 am
- Location: Derbyshire, UK
Re: BHGS Challenge
Dave scores 11
I'm still awaiting the outcome of some queries. I'm hoping to be able to publish the full list when I'm next at home, which is probably on Thursday.
I'm still awaiting the outcome of some queries. I'm hoping to be able to publish the full list when I'm next at home, which is probably on Thursday.
-
TimChild
- Sergeant First Class - Panzer IIIL

- Posts: 356
- Joined: Mon Sep 08, 2008 10:12 pm
- Location: Reading, UK
- Contact:
Re: BHGS Challenge
Just a quick note to say thank you to everyone who has entered this year's Challenge. Numbers are well up overall this year (60% increase in FOG R
), to the extent that we have filled all the tables. We cannot therefore take any more late entries.
I do, however, have a reserve waiting anxiously in the wings. With 120-odd entries, my experience is that usually something unexpected comes up for someone (hopefully nothing too drastic!!) and we get a drop-out or two over the last fortnight. I am not asking anyone to volunteer not to come!! However, if anyone does already know that they will not after all be able to make the event, please can you let me know?
Thank you all - I am looking forward to a great event!
Cheers,
Tim
I do, however, have a reserve waiting anxiously in the wings. With 120-odd entries, my experience is that usually something unexpected comes up for someone (hopefully nothing too drastic!!) and we get a drop-out or two over the last fortnight. I am not asking anyone to volunteer not to come!! However, if anyone does already know that they will not after all be able to make the event, please can you let me know?
Thank you all - I am looking forward to a great event!
Cheers,
Tim
Re: BHGS Challenge
I think that I would change Charles Masefield's list to Ottomans, possibly Early.
I think Richard would go for something other than ECW Early Royalist say Late Imperial Austrian.
Bob
I think Richard would go for something other than ECW Early Royalist say Late Imperial Austrian.
Bob
-
urbanbunny1
- Sergeant First Class - Elite Panzer IIIL

- Posts: 438
- Joined: Tue Apr 21, 2009 11:54 am
- Location: London
Re: BHGS Challenge
Lots of swedes in the list.
Who the heck picked Royalist's for me? I was aiming for Later Venitian.

Who the heck picked Royalist's for me? I was aiming for Later Venitian.
-
kevinj
- Major-General - Tiger I

- Posts: 2379
- Joined: Sun Feb 25, 2007 11:21 am
- Location: Derbyshire, UK
Re: BHGS Challenge
Here we are, the R&R (in date order). These will be on the BHGS site soon.
Lance Flint - Central Sudanese 1520
Alisdair Harley - Later Imperial Austrian 1595
Charles Masefield - Hungarian-Transylvanian 1620
Pete Dalby - Early TYW Swedish 1632
Richard Young - Later TYW German Protestant 1632
Simon LeRay Meyer - Later TYW German Catholic 1636
Ben Jones - TYW French 1642
Richard Bodley-Scott - Early ECW Royalist 1643
Dave Allen - Scots Covenanter 1644
Andy Kitcher - Later Swedish 1675
Ric Davey - League of Augsburg Anglo Dutch 1689
Adrian Steer - League of Augsburg Anglo Dutch 1691
Martin Van Tol - League of Augsburg Anglo Dutch 1692
Don Avis - Later Louis XIV French 1694
Bob Medcraft - Later Swedish 1696
Kevin Johnson - Later Swedish 1696
If someone can tell me how to embed a table into a post I can tidy up the format.
Lance Flint - Central Sudanese 1520
Alisdair Harley - Later Imperial Austrian 1595
Charles Masefield - Hungarian-Transylvanian 1620
Pete Dalby - Early TYW Swedish 1632
Richard Young - Later TYW German Protestant 1632
Simon LeRay Meyer - Later TYW German Catholic 1636
Ben Jones - TYW French 1642
Richard Bodley-Scott - Early ECW Royalist 1643
Dave Allen - Scots Covenanter 1644
Andy Kitcher - Later Swedish 1675
Ric Davey - League of Augsburg Anglo Dutch 1689
Adrian Steer - League of Augsburg Anglo Dutch 1691
Martin Van Tol - League of Augsburg Anglo Dutch 1692
Don Avis - Later Louis XIV French 1694
Bob Medcraft - Later Swedish 1696
Kevin Johnson - Later Swedish 1696
If someone can tell me how to embed a table into a post I can tidy up the format.
-
alasdair2204
- Sergeant Major - SdKfz 234/2 8Rad

- Posts: 600
- Joined: Sun Dec 09, 2007 1:40 pm
Re: BHGS Challenge
kevinj wrote:Here we are, the R&R (in date order). These will be on the BHGS site soon.
Lance Flint - Central Sudanese 1520
Alisdair Harley - Later Imperial Austrian 1595
Charles Masefield - Hungarian-Transylvanian 1620
Pete Dalby - Early TYW Swedish 1632
Richard Young - Later TYW German Protestant 1632
Simon LeRay Meyer - Later TYW German Catholic 1636
Ben Jones - TYW French 1642
Richard Bodley-Scott - Early ECW Royalist 1643
Dave Allen - Scots Covenanter 1644
Andy Kitcher - Later Swedish 1675
Ric Davey - League of Augsburg Anglo Dutch 1689
Adrian Steer - League of Augsburg Anglo Dutch 1691
Martin Van Tol - League of Augsburg Anglo Dutch 1692
Don Avis - Later Louis XIV French 1694
Bob Medcraft - Later Swedish 1696
Kevin Johnson - Later Swedish 1696
If someone can tell me how to embed a table into a post I can tidy up the format.
In summary at some stage over the wekend we'll play swedes or anglo dutch
can't wait
cheers
Alasdair
-
timmy1
- Lieutenant-General - Nashorn

- Posts: 3436
- Joined: Fri Feb 29, 2008 8:39 pm
- Location: Chelmsford, Essex, England
Re: BHGS Challenge
Alasdair
Unless you meet the Swedes or Anglo-Dutch in the first round, I suspect you will play Sudanese, Hungarian, French, something ECW, and then Swedes in the last round.
Unless you meet the Swedes or Anglo-Dutch in the first round, I suspect you will play Sudanese, Hungarian, French, something ECW, and then Swedes in the last round.


