Davouthojo ( 38/58 ) ianiow (24/60) now. Still a pike grind-fest but Hannibalites is starting to edge ahead in this battle.Morbio wrote:Latest Score...
Alexander (1) vs (2) Hannibal
Match 1 (Very Open): Ptolemaic (Greek) Davouthojo ( 25/58 ) vs Ptolemaic (Greek) IanIOW ( 19/60 ) latest - it seems this was misreported previously![]()
RoR Companions Cup
Moderators: Slitherine Core, NewRoSoft, FoG PC Moderator
-
ianiow
- Lieutenant Colonel - Panther D

- Posts: 1235
- Joined: Fri Apr 27, 2007 11:24 am
- Location: Isle of Wight, UK
-
Morbio
- Brigadier-General - Elite Grenadier

- Posts: 2164
- Joined: Fri Jan 01, 2010 4:40 pm
- Location: Wokingham, UK
Latest Score...
Alexander (1) vs (3) Hannibal
Match 1 (Very Open): Ptolemaic (Greek) Davouthojo ( 38/58 ) vs Ptolemaic (Greek) IanIOW ( 24/60 ) latest
Match 2 (Open): Pyrrhic (In Italy) Claymore ( 62/61 ) v Pyrrhic (In Italy) Morbio ( 13/65 ) WIN Hannibal
Match 3 (Mixed): Later Carthage (post 235 BC) Pantherboy ( 47/75 ) v Later Carthage (post 235 BC) Triarius ( 68/66 ) WIN Alexander
Match 4 (Open): Mid-Republican Roman IanDavidSmith ( 67/55 ) v Mid-Republican Roman Steve-H8 ( 35/60 ) WIN Hannibal
Match 5 (Very Open): Suren Indo-Parthian Cheahn ( 71/63 ) v Suren Indo-Parthian Ericdoman1 ( 44/61 ) WIN Hannibal
Pyrrhus (4) vs (1) Caesar
Match 1 (Very Open): Suren Indo-Parthian Petran1978 ( 49/47 ) vs Mid-Republican Roman Blathergut ( 35/59 ) WIN Caesar
Match 2 (Open): Pyrrhic (In Italy) TheKraken ( 42/64 ) vs Suren Indo-Parthian BatesMotel ( 73/69 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Match 3 (Mixed): Later Carthage (post 235 BC) Hidde ( 35/68 ) v Later Carthage (post 235 BC) ( 81/73 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Match 4 (Open): Ptolemaic (Greek) Lysimachos ( 47/54 ) v Ptolemaic (Greek) Deeter ( 60/53 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Match 5 (Very Open): Mid-Republican Roman Tofman04 ( 40/56 ) v Pyrrhic (In Italy) Deadtorius ( 56/56 ) WIN Pyrrhus
The victories teams are now known, so I'll start the process for determining home and away and the armies for each match. Davouthojo and Ian can continue the battle while the admin progresses!
Alexander (1) vs (3) Hannibal
Match 1 (Very Open): Ptolemaic (Greek) Davouthojo ( 38/58 ) vs Ptolemaic (Greek) IanIOW ( 24/60 ) latest
Match 2 (Open): Pyrrhic (In Italy) Claymore ( 62/61 ) v Pyrrhic (In Italy) Morbio ( 13/65 ) WIN Hannibal
Match 3 (Mixed): Later Carthage (post 235 BC) Pantherboy ( 47/75 ) v Later Carthage (post 235 BC) Triarius ( 68/66 ) WIN Alexander
Match 4 (Open): Mid-Republican Roman IanDavidSmith ( 67/55 ) v Mid-Republican Roman Steve-H8 ( 35/60 ) WIN Hannibal
Match 5 (Very Open): Suren Indo-Parthian Cheahn ( 71/63 ) v Suren Indo-Parthian Ericdoman1 ( 44/61 ) WIN Hannibal
Pyrrhus (4) vs (1) Caesar
Match 1 (Very Open): Suren Indo-Parthian Petran1978 ( 49/47 ) vs Mid-Republican Roman Blathergut ( 35/59 ) WIN Caesar
Match 2 (Open): Pyrrhic (In Italy) TheKraken ( 42/64 ) vs Suren Indo-Parthian BatesMotel ( 73/69 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Match 3 (Mixed): Later Carthage (post 235 BC) Hidde ( 35/68 ) v Later Carthage (post 235 BC) ( 81/73 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Match 4 (Open): Ptolemaic (Greek) Lysimachos ( 47/54 ) v Ptolemaic (Greek) Deeter ( 60/53 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Match 5 (Very Open): Mid-Republican Roman Tofman04 ( 40/56 ) v Pyrrhic (In Italy) Deadtorius ( 56/56 ) WIN Pyrrhus
The victories teams are now known, so I'll start the process for determining home and away and the armies for each match. Davouthojo and Ian can continue the battle while the admin progresses!
Last edited by Morbio on Sat Feb 26, 2011 1:26 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
Morbio
- Brigadier-General - Elite Grenadier

- Posts: 2164
- Joined: Fri Jan 01, 2010 4:40 pm
- Location: Wokingham, UK
Draw for the final and 3rd/4th play-off
Final
Pyrrhus 4, Hannibal 2. Pyrrhus is at home, so Hannibal (Eric) needs to nominate the army for match 1.
3rd/4th Play-Off
Caesar 6, Alexander 1. Caesar is at home so Alexander (Davouthojo) needs to nominate the army for match 1.
Match 1 (Very Open):
Match 2 (Open):
Match 3 (Mixed):
Match 4 (Open):
Match 5 (Very Open):
The players and the armies are the same, but the captain has the option to change which players command each army. Think on this as you nominate the armies for each match.
Away captains, please post your 1st army.
Final
Pyrrhus 4, Hannibal 2. Pyrrhus is at home, so Hannibal (Eric) needs to nominate the army for match 1.
3rd/4th Play-Off
Caesar 6, Alexander 1. Caesar is at home so Alexander (Davouthojo) needs to nominate the army for match 1.
Match 1 (Very Open):
Match 2 (Open):
Match 3 (Mixed):
Match 4 (Open):
Match 5 (Very Open):
The players and the armies are the same, but the captain has the option to change which players command each army. Think on this as you nominate the armies for each match.
Away captains, please post your 1st army.
-
davouthojo
- Sergeant First Class - Elite Panzer IIIL

- Posts: 423
- Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2010 1:49 pm
- Location: Hong Kong
My congratulations to Hannibal for his comprehensive victory.......next time we will get our revenge.......
Alexander nominates Ptolemaic for the first battle vs Caesar.
Can my team post on our forum if they would like to change teams...we need to redeem our honour!
The result is academic now.....ian and my battle is still a grind....it has highlighted in a push of pike how much difference it makes whether you control the order of combat or your enemy......I pull back in my turns, but dread ian's turns. Currently 36/58 to 32/60.
Alexander nominates Ptolemaic for the first battle vs Caesar.
Can my team post on our forum if they would like to change teams...we need to redeem our honour!
The result is academic now.....ian and my battle is still a grind....it has highlighted in a push of pike how much difference it makes whether you control the order of combat or your enemy......I pull back in my turns, but dread ian's turns. Currently 36/58 to 32/60.
-
ericdoman1
- General - King Tiger

- Posts: 3776
- Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2010 6:43 pm
- Location: Wales
Well done CHAPS
Congratulations to the Brit team and thanks to the ROTW team.
PMing the team to confirm army order.
PMing the team to confirm army order.
-
ianiow
- Lieutenant Colonel - Panther D

- Posts: 1235
- Joined: Fri Apr 27, 2007 11:24 am
- Location: Isle of Wight, UK
49/58 to 34/60 now. Things are getting desperate as we both are running out of pikemen. The thracian and galatian reserves are in action on both sides now though no one has resorted to using the cretans yet hehe.davouthojo wrote: The result is academic now.....ian and my battle is still a grind....it has highlighted in a push of pike how much difference it makes whether you control the order of combat or your enemy......I pull back in my turns, but dread ian's turns. Currently 36/58 to 32/60.
-
Morbio
- Brigadier-General - Elite Grenadier

- Posts: 2164
- Joined: Fri Jan 01, 2010 4:40 pm
- Location: Wokingham, UK
Draw for the final and 3rd/4th play-off
Final
Match 1 (Very Open): ? v TBA
Match 2 (Open):
Match 3 (Mixed):
Match 4 (Open):
Match 5 (Very Open):
Eric please nominate the army for match 1.
3rd/4th Play-Off
Match 1 (Very Open): TBA vs Ptolemaic (Greek)
Match 2 (Open): TBA v ?
Match 3 (Mixed):
Match 4 (Open):
Match 5 (Very Open):
TGM: Please nominate the army for match 1 and match 2.
The players and the armies are the same, but the captain has the option to change which players command each army. Think on this as you nominate the armies for each match.
Final
Match 1 (Very Open): ? v TBA
Match 2 (Open):
Match 3 (Mixed):
Match 4 (Open):
Match 5 (Very Open):
Eric please nominate the army for match 1.
3rd/4th Play-Off
Match 1 (Very Open): TBA vs Ptolemaic (Greek)
Match 2 (Open): TBA v ?
Match 3 (Mixed):
Match 4 (Open):
Match 5 (Very Open):
TGM: Please nominate the army for match 1 and match 2.
The players and the armies are the same, but the captain has the option to change which players command each army. Think on this as you nominate the armies for each match.
-
Morbio
- Brigadier-General - Elite Grenadier

- Posts: 2164
- Joined: Fri Jan 01, 2010 4:40 pm
- Location: Wokingham, UK
Latest Score...
Alexander (1) vs (3) Hannibal
Match 1 (Very Open): Ptolemaic (Greek) Davouthojo ( 49/58 ) vs Ptolemaic (Greek) IanIOW ( 36/60 ) latest
Match 2 (Open): Pyrrhic (In Italy) Claymore ( 62/61 ) v Pyrrhic (In Italy) Morbio ( 13/65 ) WIN Hannibal
Match 3 (Mixed): Later Carthage (post 235 BC) Pantherboy ( 47/75 ) v Later Carthage (post 235 BC) Triarius ( 68/66 ) WIN Alexander
Match 4 (Open): Mid-Republican Roman IanDavidSmith ( 67/55 ) v Mid-Republican Roman Steve-H8 ( 35/60 ) WIN Hannibal
Match 5 (Very Open): Suren Indo-Parthian Cheahn ( 71/63 ) v Suren Indo-Parthian Ericdoman1 ( 44/61 ) WIN Hannibal
Pyrrhus (4) vs (1) Caesar
Match 1 (Very Open): Suren Indo-Parthian Petran1978 ( 49/47 ) vs Mid-Republican Roman Blathergut ( 35/59 ) WIN Caesar
Match 2 (Open): Pyrrhic (In Italy) TheKraken ( 42/64 ) vs Suren Indo-Parthian BatesMotel ( 73/69 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Match 3 (Mixed): Later Carthage (post 235 BC) Hidde ( 35/68 ) v Later Carthage (post 235 BC) ( 81/73 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Match 4 (Open): Ptolemaic (Greek) Lysimachos ( 47/54 ) v Ptolemaic (Greek) Deeter ( 60/53 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Match 5 (Very Open): Mid-Republican Roman Tofman04 ( 40/56 ) v Pyrrhic (In Italy) Deadtorius ( 56/56 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Alexander (1) vs (3) Hannibal
Match 1 (Very Open): Ptolemaic (Greek) Davouthojo ( 49/58 ) vs Ptolemaic (Greek) IanIOW ( 36/60 ) latest
Match 2 (Open): Pyrrhic (In Italy) Claymore ( 62/61 ) v Pyrrhic (In Italy) Morbio ( 13/65 ) WIN Hannibal
Match 3 (Mixed): Later Carthage (post 235 BC) Pantherboy ( 47/75 ) v Later Carthage (post 235 BC) Triarius ( 68/66 ) WIN Alexander
Match 4 (Open): Mid-Republican Roman IanDavidSmith ( 67/55 ) v Mid-Republican Roman Steve-H8 ( 35/60 ) WIN Hannibal
Match 5 (Very Open): Suren Indo-Parthian Cheahn ( 71/63 ) v Suren Indo-Parthian Ericdoman1 ( 44/61 ) WIN Hannibal
Pyrrhus (4) vs (1) Caesar
Match 1 (Very Open): Suren Indo-Parthian Petran1978 ( 49/47 ) vs Mid-Republican Roman Blathergut ( 35/59 ) WIN Caesar
Match 2 (Open): Pyrrhic (In Italy) TheKraken ( 42/64 ) vs Suren Indo-Parthian BatesMotel ( 73/69 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Match 3 (Mixed): Later Carthage (post 235 BC) Hidde ( 35/68 ) v Later Carthage (post 235 BC) ( 81/73 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Match 4 (Open): Ptolemaic (Greek) Lysimachos ( 47/54 ) v Ptolemaic (Greek) Deeter ( 60/53 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Match 5 (Very Open): Mid-Republican Roman Tofman04 ( 40/56 ) v Pyrrhic (In Italy) Deadtorius ( 56/56 ) WIN Pyrrhus
-
claymore58
- Sergeant First Class - Elite Panzer IIIL

- Posts: 426
- Joined: Thu May 06, 2010 1:56 pm
- Location: Brisbane, Australia
-
ianiow
- Lieutenant Colonel - Panther D

- Posts: 1235
- Joined: Fri Apr 27, 2007 11:24 am
- Location: Isle of Wight, UK
FINAL SCOREMorbio wrote:Latest Score...
Alexander (1) vs (3) Hannibal
Match 1 (Very Open): Ptolemaic (Greek) Davouthojo ( 49/58 ) vs Ptolemaic (Greek) IanIOW ( 36/60 ) latest
Match 1 (Very Open): Ptolemaic (Greek) Davouthojo ( 60/58 ) vs Ptolemaic (Greek) IanIOW ( 48/60 )
I'd like to say I won by great generalship and inspired manuevering but I think it just hinged on the fact that I won the skirmish encounter with some sneaky entrapments and hung on to this small lead until the end of the battle. Thanks for the game DH. GO HANNIBAL!
-
Morbio
- Brigadier-General - Elite Grenadier

- Posts: 2164
- Joined: Fri Jan 01, 2010 4:40 pm
- Location: Wokingham, UK
Final Result
Alexander (1) vs (4) Hannibal
Match 1 (Very Open): Ptolemaic (Greek) Davouthojo ( 60/58 ) vs Ptolemaic (Greek) IanIOW ( 48/60 ) WIN Hannibal
Match 2 (Open): Pyrrhic (In Italy) Claymore ( 62/61 ) v Pyrrhic (In Italy) Morbio ( 13/65 ) WIN Hannibal
Match 3 (Mixed): Later Carthage (post 235 BC) Pantherboy ( 47/75 ) v Later Carthage (post 235 BC) Triarius ( 68/66 ) WIN Alexander
Match 4 (Open): Mid-Republican Roman IanDavidSmith ( 67/55 ) v Mid-Republican Roman Steve-H8 ( 35/60 ) WIN Hannibal
Match 5 (Very Open): Suren Indo-Parthian Cheahn ( 71/63 ) v Suren Indo-Parthian Ericdoman1 ( 44/61 ) WIN Hannibal
Pyrrhus (4) vs (1) Caesar
Match 1 (Very Open): Suren Indo-Parthian Petran1978 ( 49/47 ) vs Mid-Republican Roman Blathergut ( 35/59 ) WIN Caesar
Match 2 (Open): Pyrrhic (In Italy) TheKraken ( 42/64 ) vs Suren Indo-Parthian BatesMotel ( 73/69 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Match 3 (Mixed): Later Carthage (post 235 BC) Hidde ( 35/68 ) v Later Carthage (post 235 BC) ( 81/73 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Match 4 (Open): Ptolemaic (Greek) Lysimachos ( 47/54 ) v Ptolemaic (Greek) Deeter ( 60/53 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Match 5 (Very Open): Mid-Republican Roman Tofman04 ( 40/56 ) v Pyrrhic (In Italy) Deadtorius ( 56/56 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Alexander (1) vs (4) Hannibal
Match 1 (Very Open): Ptolemaic (Greek) Davouthojo ( 60/58 ) vs Ptolemaic (Greek) IanIOW ( 48/60 ) WIN Hannibal
Match 2 (Open): Pyrrhic (In Italy) Claymore ( 62/61 ) v Pyrrhic (In Italy) Morbio ( 13/65 ) WIN Hannibal
Match 3 (Mixed): Later Carthage (post 235 BC) Pantherboy ( 47/75 ) v Later Carthage (post 235 BC) Triarius ( 68/66 ) WIN Alexander
Match 4 (Open): Mid-Republican Roman IanDavidSmith ( 67/55 ) v Mid-Republican Roman Steve-H8 ( 35/60 ) WIN Hannibal
Match 5 (Very Open): Suren Indo-Parthian Cheahn ( 71/63 ) v Suren Indo-Parthian Ericdoman1 ( 44/61 ) WIN Hannibal
Pyrrhus (4) vs (1) Caesar
Match 1 (Very Open): Suren Indo-Parthian Petran1978 ( 49/47 ) vs Mid-Republican Roman Blathergut ( 35/59 ) WIN Caesar
Match 2 (Open): Pyrrhic (In Italy) TheKraken ( 42/64 ) vs Suren Indo-Parthian BatesMotel ( 73/69 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Match 3 (Mixed): Later Carthage (post 235 BC) Hidde ( 35/68 ) v Later Carthage (post 235 BC) ( 81/73 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Match 4 (Open): Ptolemaic (Greek) Lysimachos ( 47/54 ) v Ptolemaic (Greek) Deeter ( 60/53 ) WIN Pyrrhus
Match 5 (Very Open): Mid-Republican Roman Tofman04 ( 40/56 ) v Pyrrhic (In Italy) Deadtorius ( 56/56 ) WIN Pyrrhus
-
ericdoman1
- General - King Tiger

- Posts: 3776
- Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2010 6:43 pm
- Location: Wales
Round 1
Ptolemaic Greek please.
-
Morbio
- Brigadier-General - Elite Grenadier

- Posts: 2164
- Joined: Fri Jan 01, 2010 4:40 pm
- Location: Wokingham, UK
Draw for the final and 3rd/4th play-off
Final: Pyrrhus vs Hannibal
Match 1 (Very Open): Ptolemaic (Greek) v Ptolemaic (Greek)
Match 2 (Open): Pyrrhic(in Italy) v TBA
Match 3 (Mixed): TBA v ?
Match 4 (Open):
Match 5 (Very Open):
Eric please nominate the armies for match 2 & 3.
3rd/4th Play-Off: Caesar vs Alexander
Match 1 (Very Open): TBA vs Ptolemaic (Greek)
Match 2 (Open): TBA v ?
Match 3 (Mixed):
Match 4 (Open):
Match 5 (Very Open):
TGM: Please nominate the army for match 1 and match 2.
The players and the armies are the same, but the captain has the option to change which players command each army. Think on this as you nominate the armies for each match.
Final: Pyrrhus vs Hannibal
Match 1 (Very Open): Ptolemaic (Greek) v Ptolemaic (Greek)
Match 2 (Open): Pyrrhic(in Italy) v TBA
Match 3 (Mixed): TBA v ?
Match 4 (Open):
Match 5 (Very Open):
Eric please nominate the armies for match 2 & 3.
3rd/4th Play-Off: Caesar vs Alexander
Match 1 (Very Open): TBA vs Ptolemaic (Greek)
Match 2 (Open): TBA v ?
Match 3 (Mixed):
Match 4 (Open):
Match 5 (Very Open):
TGM: Please nominate the army for match 1 and match 2.
The players and the armies are the same, but the captain has the option to change which players command each army. Think on this as you nominate the armies for each match.
-
ericdoman1
- General - King Tiger

- Posts: 3776
- Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2010 6:43 pm
- Location: Wales
Next two choices
2nd round Pyrrhic
3rd Round Carthaginian
3rd Round Carthaginian
Final: Pyrrhus vs Hannibal
Match 1 (Very Open): Ptolemaic (Greek) v Ptolemaic (Greek)
Match 2 (Open): Pyrrhic(in Italy) v Pyrrhic(in Italy)
Match 3 (Mixed): Carthaginian v Carthaginian
Match 4 (Open): Mid-Republican Roman v TBA
The Brits are getting the same set-up that gave them such a successfull first round!
The Final will end differently, count on it!
Match 1 (Very Open): Ptolemaic (Greek) v Ptolemaic (Greek)
Match 2 (Open): Pyrrhic(in Italy) v Pyrrhic(in Italy)
Match 3 (Mixed): Carthaginian v Carthaginian
Match 4 (Open): Mid-Republican Roman v TBA
The Brits are getting the same set-up that gave them such a successfull first round!
The Final will end differently, count on it!
-
TheGrayMouser
- Field Marshal - Me 410A

- Posts: 5001
- Joined: Sat Nov 14, 2009 2:42 pm
-
ericdoman1
- General - King Tiger

- Posts: 3776
- Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2010 6:43 pm
- Location: Wales
Final matches
Mid Republic 4th and Parthian 5th
Let the games commence.
Come on you Brits
Let the games commence.
Come on you Brits
