Challenges and results – Medieval, season 10
Moderators: pantherboy, Slitherine Core, NewRoSoft
-
- General - King Tiger
- Posts: 3776
- Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2010 6:43 pm
- Location: Wales
Re: Challenges and results – Medieval, season 10
No prob, although because it is you, I may add some very small italics stating, "All practice games with chosen LOEG armies is acceptable. However in the case of Dave Ruddock, he will be deducted 1 point per second of practice game" LOL Sarcasm will get you nowhere LOEL.
-
- 1st Lieutenant - Grenadier
- Posts: 774
- Joined: Sat Dec 15, 2012 1:12 am
- Location: Hamilton, Ontario, Canada
Re: Challenges and results – Medieval, season 10
Div C
Jonathan4290 (Timurids) 9/34 defeats Okie (Khwarizman) 25/25
Timurids held the high ground, allowing the center and right to hold while a combined arms flanking force of elephants/MF bow/cavalry defeated the Khwarizman left wing. The Timurid center also joined in the attack once it gained momentum.
Jonathan4290 (Timurids) 9/34 defeats Okie (Khwarizman) 25/25
Timurids held the high ground, allowing the center and right to hold while a combined arms flanking force of elephants/MF bow/cavalry defeated the Khwarizman left wing. The Timurid center also joined in the attack once it gained momentum.
Check out my website, The Art of Battle: Animated Battle Maps, where I recreate the greatest battles and campaigns of history: http://www.theartofbattle.com
Re: Challenges and results – Medieval, season 10
I still need to play: Div. C
Supervark
Kmaher
George123
Razorback77
I have 4 challenges up, pw = okie for all.
Supervark
Kmaher
George123
Razorback77
I have 4 challenges up, pw = okie for all.
Last edited by Okie on Thu May 09, 2013 8:04 pm, edited 3 times in total.
Division C
Londo 26/45 (Anglo-Irish L) vs Jonathan4290 (Timurid 1360-1500) 28/28
Londo 19/45 (Anglo-Irish L) vs greetings44 (Wallachian 1441-1500) 43/43
I think Anglo-Irish is one of the best armies in all of FOG, and it's particularly hard for cavalry armies to fight them. In the above games, I don't know what my opponents could have done better, but they still lost by quite a wide margin in BPs. I like Anglo-Irish because it's an almost perfect "combined-arms" team, with a combination of:
* Solid HF (Superior, Protected, HW) - a steal at only 9 points each!
* Longbowmen (Average, Protected, Longbow, Swordsmen) - the best missile infantry in the game, with stakes if you need them.
* Useful cavalry (Superior, Armoured, LS, Swordsmen) who aren't prone to anarchy charges like damned lancers!
* Cheapo MF (Average, Protected, LS) to bulk out the army and fight in rough terrain.
I think they're the best all-round Medieval army, though you could make a case for Medieval Crown of Aragon (Early), with its Superior Impact MF. Does anyone have any other candidates?
Londo 19/45 (Anglo-Irish L) vs greetings44 (Wallachian 1441-1500) 43/43
I think Anglo-Irish is one of the best armies in all of FOG, and it's particularly hard for cavalry armies to fight them. In the above games, I don't know what my opponents could have done better, but they still lost by quite a wide margin in BPs. I like Anglo-Irish because it's an almost perfect "combined-arms" team, with a combination of:
* Solid HF (Superior, Protected, HW) - a steal at only 9 points each!
* Longbowmen (Average, Protected, Longbow, Swordsmen) - the best missile infantry in the game, with stakes if you need them.
* Useful cavalry (Superior, Armoured, LS, Swordsmen) who aren't prone to anarchy charges like damned lancers!
* Cheapo MF (Average, Protected, LS) to bulk out the army and fight in rough terrain.
I think they're the best all-round Medieval army, though you could make a case for Medieval Crown of Aragon (Early), with its Superior Impact MF. Does anyone have any other candidates?

Re: Challenges and results – Medieval, season 10
Div C,
philoi (later ottoman) 8/43 vs Okie (Khwarazmians) 26/25
thank you !
philoi (later ottoman) 8/43 vs Okie (Khwarazmians) 26/25
thank you !
Division C
Forgot to mention this one:
Londo (Anglo-Irish L) 28/46 vs Dave_r (Swiss) 53/51
Ugly terrain, with ditches and scrub everywhere, made things impossible for the Swiss.
I wonder if halberdiers should have the option of deploying as MF, not just HF? I thought they were more mobile and flexible than pikes, and for that reason used to cover the flanks of pike blocks.
Having halberdier MF would give armies like the Swiss a chance in bad terrain, rather than being basically a foregone conclusion as it is now.
Londo (Anglo-Irish L) 28/46 vs Dave_r (Swiss) 53/51
Ugly terrain, with ditches and scrub everywhere, made things impossible for the Swiss.
I wonder if halberdiers should have the option of deploying as MF, not just HF? I thought they were more mobile and flexible than pikes, and for that reason used to cover the flanks of pike blocks.
Having halberdier MF would give armies like the Swiss a chance in bad terrain, rather than being basically a foregone conclusion as it is now.
Re: Challenges and results – Medieval, season 10
Div A Result
CheAhn (Latin Greek) 22/58 vs hidde (Yorkist) 49/47
England stamped on the passport, next stop Ireland. The greeks would like to give special thanks to the dice gods.
CheAhn (Latin Greek) 22/58 vs hidde (Yorkist) 49/47
England stamped on the passport, next stop Ireland. The greeks would like to give special thanks to the dice gods.
-
- Sergeant Major - SdKfz 234/2 8Rad
- Posts: 612
- Joined: Fri Sep 07, 2012 5:47 pm
- Location: Uppsala, Sweden
Re: Challenges and results – Medieval, season 10
Div. B
voskarp (WotR Richard III) [44/44] vs Solly (Santa Hermada Nueva Castilian) [46/45]
A draw... The English knights lined up on high ground while the archers marched off to rain some death on the advancing pike- and spearmen. A couple of longbow units got caught in a bog and was cut down by skilled swordsmen and Almughavars.
With the Spanish line closing in the archers took refuge in a forrest, and the knights braced for impact. On the English right flank the Spanish equites were held up on a strip of steep hills between a lake and the edge of the map by some poor archers and a sub commander.
The following melee was brutal and battle groups were routed left and right. Jinetes raided the English camp and the longbows on the right flank had a hard time dealing with the Almughavars and skilled swordsmen. Eventually the English knights beat the pikemen and moved of to help the archers on the flanks, but it was too late...
The last turn was so exciting I almost fell of my chair, several times!
Thanks for a good game Solly!
voskarp (WotR Richard III) [44/44] vs Solly (Santa Hermada Nueva Castilian) [46/45]
A draw... The English knights lined up on high ground while the archers marched off to rain some death on the advancing pike- and spearmen. A couple of longbow units got caught in a bog and was cut down by skilled swordsmen and Almughavars.
With the Spanish line closing in the archers took refuge in a forrest, and the knights braced for impact. On the English right flank the Spanish equites were held up on a strip of steep hills between a lake and the edge of the map by some poor archers and a sub commander.
The following melee was brutal and battle groups were routed left and right. Jinetes raided the English camp and the longbows on the right flank had a hard time dealing with the Almughavars and skilled swordsmen. Eventually the English knights beat the pikemen and moved of to help the archers on the flanks, but it was too late...
The last turn was so exciting I almost fell of my chair, several times!
Thanks for a good game Solly!
-
- Lieutenant Colonel - Elite Panther D
- Posts: 1368
- Joined: Tue Dec 08, 2009 9:38 am
- Location: Italy
Re: Challenges and results – Medieval, season 10
Division A
Lysimachos (Catalan Company) 23/48 Tiavals (Scots in Britain) 58/52
A strange battle where in the 1st phase the Catalans launched ahead their LF and cavalry archers to pepper with missile fire the opponents HF, in the process loosing about 10 pts and prompting a reaction of the enemy on both flanks.
After a steady retreat of my outnumbered right wing, the charge of the Almughavar in the centre and on the left flank completely routed the Scottish spearmen hacking them to pieces before their left wing could arrive.
A victory mostly due to the inherent strongness of this army rather than to the skillness of his commander!
Lysimachos (Catalan Company) 23/48 Tiavals (Scots in Britain) 58/52
A strange battle where in the 1st phase the Catalans launched ahead their LF and cavalry archers to pepper with missile fire the opponents HF, in the process loosing about 10 pts and prompting a reaction of the enemy on both flanks.
After a steady retreat of my outnumbered right wing, the charge of the Almughavar in the centre and on the left flank completely routed the Scottish spearmen hacking them to pieces before their left wing could arrive.
A victory mostly due to the inherent strongness of this army rather than to the skillness of his commander!
"Audentis fortuna iuvat"
- Virgilius
(Good luck favours the brave)
- Virgilius
(Good luck favours the brave)
-
- Lieutenant Colonel - Fw 190A
- Posts: 1138
- Joined: Tue May 18, 2010 1:14 pm
- Location: Victor Harbor South Australia
Re: Challenges and results – Medieval, season 10
Division B Result
Turk1964(Later Hungarians (early) ) 2/39 vs Caiko(Ordonnance French (early) )51/44
The Hungarians were far too strong the the French and the result shows. Thanks for the game Cheers Turk
Turk1964(Later Hungarians (early) ) 2/39 vs Caiko(Ordonnance French (early) )51/44
The Hungarians were far too strong the the French and the result shows. Thanks for the game Cheers Turk
-
- Staff Sergeant - StuG IIIF
- Posts: 272
- Joined: Sun Mar 28, 2010 3:12 am
Div b Challenges
3 Div B. challenges posted/available vs zumHeuriger (Condotta-Milan) pw=cookie
Cheers
Tom
Cheers
Tom
Re: Challenges and results – Medieval, season 10
Div C challenge for matsuHiroshi pw: santa
Re: Challenges and results – Medieval, season 10
Div A Result
CheAhn (Latin Greek) 36/54 vs klayeckles (Irish) 78/77
Northern Ireland was delightful. Returning to England now.
CheAhn (Latin Greek) 36/54 vs klayeckles (Irish) 78/77
Northern Ireland was delightful. Returning to England now.
-
- Sergeant First Class - Elite Panzer IIIL
- Posts: 426
- Joined: Thu May 06, 2010 1:56 pm
- Location: Brisbane, Australia
Re: Challenges and results – Medieval, season 10
A Medii-eval Biv D challenge for flatsix518
I think that your Mamlukes will give my Swiss a "run" for their money
passtheword = hemipacer
Cheers, Claymore
I think that your Mamlukes will give my Swiss a "run" for their money

passtheword = hemipacer
Cheers, Claymore
-
- Field of Glory Moderator
- Posts: 14501
- Joined: Fri Oct 01, 2010 2:50 pm
Re: Challenges and results – Medieval, season 10
Another very negative performance by my Tudor chaps . . .
Division B
stockwellpete (Tudors) 2/40 beat zumHeuriger (Milanese Condotta) 27/27
Thanks very much for the game, Tom.

Division B
stockwellpete (Tudors) 2/40 beat zumHeuriger (Milanese Condotta) 27/27
Thanks very much for the game, Tom.

-
- Sergeant First Class - Elite Panzer IIIL
- Posts: 413
- Joined: Thu Feb 02, 2012 11:08 pm
- Location: Imladris, Ch'ang-an, Delphi
Re: Challenges and results – Medieval, season 10
Voskarp 42/40 vs Aristides 50/48.
‘I go North, to the swords and the siege,
That yet for a while rivers may run clean and birds build their nests,
Ere Night comes.’
That yet for a while rivers may run clean and birds build their nests,
Ere Night comes.’
-
- Senior Corporal - Ju 87G
- Posts: 75
- Joined: Mon Apr 18, 2011 3:21 pm
Re: Challenges and results – Medieval, season 10
DIV C
Wallachian Greeting44 53/43
Santa Hermandad Nueva Castilian Matsu Hiroshi 19/42
Thanks for the game
Wallachian Greeting44 53/43
Santa Hermandad Nueva Castilian Matsu Hiroshi 19/42
Thanks for the game
-
- 1st Lieutenant - Grenadier
- Posts: 753
- Joined: Tue Dec 14, 2010 10:43 pm
- Location: Texas
Re: Challenges and results – Medieval, season 10
ZumHeuriger and Claymore,
I'll pick up your challenges tomorrow. I've got company coming in and need to slow down on game play. Or find a new wife.
It'll probably be easier to slow down on the gaming.
flatsix518
I'll pick up your challenges tomorrow. I've got company coming in and need to slow down on game play. Or find a new wife.
It'll probably be easier to slow down on the gaming.
flatsix518
-
- Sergeant Major - SdKfz 234/2 8Rad
- Posts: 612
- Joined: Fri Sep 07, 2012 5:47 pm
- Location: Uppsala, Sweden
Re: Challenges and results – Medieval, season 10
Oops, I recorded it in the spreadsheet, but forgot to post here...Aristides wrote:Voskarp 42/40 vs Aristides 50/48.

Thanks Aristides.
-
- General - King Tiger
- Posts: 3776
- Joined: Tue Jun 15, 2010 6:43 pm
- Location: Wales
Re: Challenges and results – Medieval, season 10
div a result
eric (Late Hungarians) 32/44 vs ianiow (English Continental) 47/46
I had a number of bgs on their last legs, a fews hots and they would have auto routed, predominantly my mounted troops as well. Based on that this was a very very tough game.
eric (Late Hungarians) 32/44 vs ianiow (English Continental) 47/46
I had a number of bgs on their last legs, a fews hots and they would have auto routed, predominantly my mounted troops as well. Based on that this was a very very tough game.