afk_nero wrote:To be honest I think you got very very very lucky with the result - I thought Plaid had you stalemated in Italy and only some miracle (such as happened) would save the operation.
I guess in war you got to take the luck even if it's once in a hundred.
You still have to fight your way through Italy - you should win but it will be tough for you going through those mountains.
Very interesting AAR - thanks for doing it.
It was surely a lucky shot, but I think a miracle is exaggerated. The last few turns I tried to dispatch the INF defending Taranto and brought it constantly down to 3-5 steps, so the chance that a "lucky shot" will succeed after some time was not so bad. The BB bombarding Taranto has max experience and regularly did 2 steps of damage. As I first neutralised the Luftwaffe with other air strikes, my TAC and CV could also attack unmolested for good casualities.
I think Plaid did a major tactical mistake. He should have tried a counterattack against the US INF near Taranto with the MECH he stationed there last turn or attack my TAC with his FTR. With a damaged US INF I do not think I could have dispatched the defenders in Taranto and I only can repair 1 step each turn, because of low supply. I also think taht he should have brought another FTR a lot earlier than he did.
Nevertheless, I think Plaid will still get his stalemate, because US and UK forces are exhausted right now and there is still the Gustav line as obstacle.