The argument here highlights the differences between ancients (DBM/Warrior) and many other popular tournament sets ie FOW, WHFB, WAB etc. The competitors are rewarded across the whole scope of the hobby rather then just those whom know the rules and how to bend them the best. Have generalship categ...

I dont think there should be any scope within a competative scoring system for "subjective" judgements. The scoring system should produce a result for a game that would be the same no matter who worked it out. It has to be this way so that all the competitors feel the results are fair and ...

It raises the interesting point that we should probably add - troops fighting a BG causing disorder as a top priority item in the list. This would force the dice reduction to come from the Kn vs the camels and make is 6-3/1-1/1-1/6-3 overall. Thanks, I follow how it's done now, this does mean that ...

I was the opponent in this game and did it find it confusing. In my next game, I had 2 spearmen BG's fighting a legion. As the legion became disrupted and lost bases, the number of die dropped until there were less die than bases in contact. At this point my opponent decided to allocate all the die ...

This was an enjoyable weekend, four good games and a good learning experience as far as the rules went. I had played before coming but had only skipped through the rules. This did not seem to matter, I could get on with the games and felt I had a good grasp of what was happening. It was good having ...