Regardless of anything else, you need to change the sandbox name from Rise of Rome to something more obvious. The reviewer at Strategamer.com didn't even realize what it was. He thinks it is just one of the historical campaigns.

How about calling it: Custom Campaign

To help the devs here's a summary of many of the suggestions.

MORE VARIETY
More enemy variety
More battle type scenario variety
More strategic choice variety
More terrain variety
Longer than 7 battles
Reinforcement variety by recruiting a few allies
Enemy units can gain experience

MORE TENSION
Can ...

Look at THIS guys suggestions. lol

Everyone is a 'designer' hardly anyone wants to do the work to code it though.

:D

Some of the things I mentioned are actually in the game, they're just not being used. The more exotic stuff, such as a mid-battle earthquake and troop type rivalries, was just ...

To Summarize there are 3 key concepts.

Currently too repetitive, it needs More variety of: scenario, deployment, terrain, weather, events and strategic choices.

Not enough tension, allow players to lose both battles and the campaign.

Tournament and leagues are popular and fun, so allow solo ...

More battle variety. Open Battle happens way too often, and every other scenario happens too rarely or not at all. Please add all the existing scenarios to the campaign. If it is an option for a battle, it should have an even chance of happening in the campaign. Keep the last battle being an Open ...