Page 1 of 1

Combat Resolution Question

Posted: Wed Jun 06, 2007 1:58 am
by Daringdachshund
Hi There

A battle group of four wide Heavy Chariots frontally charges a battle group of 12 (3 wide 4 deep) fragmented pike causing them to break. The chariots pursue the pike maintaining contact and inflicting casualties. During a following impact phase a battle group of knights charge into the side of one of the pursuing chariots which is still frontally engaged against the rear of the broken pike it is pursuing. The knight’s charge does not qualify as a legal flank or rear charge. What is the following sequence of events relating to these three battle groups from the knights initial impact until the end of the melee phase of this particular bound?

Rgrds
Martin Abel

Posted: Wed Jun 06, 2007 6:02 am
by shall
Not 100% certain without a piccie but here goes: BASICALLY IGNORE THE ROUTERS EXIST OTHER THAN IN SO FAR AS THEY BLOCK CONFORMING

1. The charge on the chariots is a frontal charge just catching a side edge with a front corner
2. The combat is fought normally at impact probably with 2 dice each
3. Normal results apply
4. Chargers attempt to conform to the front but cannot do so due to the routers being in the way at this stage
5. Melee is fought offset - both side get 1 overlap as if they had conformed
6. Normal results apply
7. In the JAP the routers make their next rout move - should be their 3rd rout move
8. Pursuing chariots are stopped and will fight the people who charged them - conforming to them in their active manouvre phase

now to check something on (7)

Did you do:

1. An initial rout at the time of the break AND
2. A second rout in the JAP
3. Take a base off for remaining in contact
4. or Attempt to stop the chariots prusuing the second time with a CMT

SI

Posted: Wed Jun 06, 2007 6:11 am
by Daringdachshund
1. Yes.
2. Yes.
3. Yes.
4. No.

The chariots chose to continue to pursue. Bases in contact were removed from the pike battle group. The chariot on the left of the battlegroup was still in contact with a pike when it was charged by the knights.

We played it as you have stated but were not sure if this was the correct way. If the knights charge had been a legal flank charge (nearly was) would the chariot, in contact with both pike and knight, have turned to face the flank attack?

Posted: Thu Jun 07, 2007 2:43 pm
by shall
Indeed thery would

Si