wecker wrote: ↑Mon Jan 30, 2023 4:10 pm
Hi Stormchaser,
thank you for your work and effort on improving Panzercorps 2 units with your unit tool box.
As I understand it is also used in other mods.
Like all players I got my own thoughts which I would like to share with you.
The newest thing with the Grenadiers seems a little bit too strong. I mean it is ok to give them more "strength" but it seems too much. For grenade launchers for example we got already Heavy Infantry.
My biggest questiaon is regarding Artillery. Do we really need that many Artillery pieces in the german roster?
A ton of sFHs and heavy artillery with minimal difference in the stats.
I am no history buff so I don`t know whether this is all historically correct - but is seems also too much to me. I simply don`t know what arty to choose from. And I have always to click on everyone of them and scroll around.
Maybe you can think about reducing the amount of available arty pieces.
Also it hurts my eyes when I see the Flakpnazer I and the likes of them. I understand the desire and good will to give us more historical units - but as I said. It looks not good - this game with this engine is eye candy
Maybe you can talk to the devs and ask them to make new correct models.
No offense meant - just my thoughts.
The Ferocious Defense buff only matters when attacked by Pioneers, Flame Tanks, and other Units with Ignores Entrenchment, as it cancels out that trait. Grenadiers, in my mind, should be the more defensive orientated, and this should help prevent an Hero and Overstrength buff Ignores Entrenchment tank from just Overruning it's way through an enemy defensive line as easily.
There is a somewhat ridiculous amount of Artillery. But that's the case historically.
Part of that is probably due to the fact that while tank, AT gun, and aircraft design was a relatively recent development and thus would see an explosion of new models and improvements throughout WW2, towed Artillery predates even WW1, and many older guns were still very serviceable throughout the war, while pre- and early WW2 tanks, AT guns, and aircrafts were quickly replaced with better equipment as it became available.
This has the side effect of making the Artillery tab is very frontloaded. There are more German Tanks in my mod than Germany Artillery (76 to 63, but only 36 of the 63 are towed artillery, the rest being SPGs.), but because Tank development is spread out throughout the war instead of having a bunch of pre- and early war equipment dumped into the shop at once at the beginning it likely doesn't feel like it.
As for the units being very similar, unfortunate consequence of their being few options in terms of stats to tweak that are actually relevant for Artillery. I threw in Alpine, Paratrooper, AT gun modes, and even some Naval Attack where I could, but a lot of it came down to me deciding between making a gun better against Soft Targets, better against Hard Targets, or balanced offensively.
The last reason as to why I went ahead and made so many even with above problems? So players would have plenty of options when playing with Collector on. In the base game, the 15cm size Artillery is probably the best one for general use in my option, but Germany only ever gets the 1 15cm model, if you want more with Collector you have to capture them (a mechanic some people don't like to use). With my mod, there are now 4 15cm guns at the start, and 2 more that unlock by 1942, without needing to mess with captures.
Somewhat related note, I would kill for a way to add a search or sort option of some kind to the shop. A way to say, only show 15cm towed Artillery, or Light Tanks, or Fighter-Bombers.
As for the last bit, trust me, I would
love to have a way to put proper models into the game, but until then I'm just having to make do with what we have. I've seen plenty of others cooment about and bemoan the lack of better modding tools, and I doubt my voice carries any more weight.