Views on mechanics sought - any offers
Posted: Mon Jul 22, 2019 4:07 pm
Dear all,
Help needed in my learning to explain the inability to move two cavalty units.
Sorry no screen shot but in the spirit of chess problems three representations of the synoptic situation.
Player A Red and Player B Blue.
Unit, state and facing.
1 start of Player B turn
At start of player B turn all units are in melee combat with facing shown.
The last move made was PlayerA's Noble Armoured Cavalry, a superior unit with General, that charged into contact with the fragmented HI spear. The fragmented HI stood up the charge.
In player B turn no new units join the combats but:-
a) Disrupted MI SCUTARI go to fragmented with combat loss.
b) Good LC JAV go to fragmented with combat loss.
c) Fragmented HI SPEAR rout with combat loss and disperse.
At end of Player B turn and start of Player A turn situation is now
During this move Player A (me) cannot move or rotate either Armoured Cavalry unit in any way.
The MI Scutari are able to be moved as normal.
Neither Armoured Cavalry is in any ZOC nor are they noted as pursuing – the routed HI had already dispersed.
Can anyone explain why neither cavalry unit could move or rotate in any way?
I had expected to flank charge and start rolling up the HI Spears and MI Spears with the first charge using superior cavalry with General against the fragmented HI. They stood against the charge which, though unlikely, can of course happen. What I cannot understand is why the cavalry (but not the Scutari) were frozen in my subsequent move after the HI had routed and dispersed.
Clarification would be much appreciated as this was a pivotal moment and I am keen to learn what I may be missing.
At the end of my move situation had become
a) Fragmented MI SCUTARI rout.
b) Fragmented LC Jav Rout
c) MI SCUTARI in combat with MI SPEAR flank attacked by a new unit and disrupted
d) MI SCUTARI charge and disrupt HI SPEAR
e) Both ARM CAV can make no move at all.

Help needed in my learning to explain the inability to move two cavalty units.
Sorry no screen shot but in the spirit of chess problems three representations of the synoptic situation.
Player A Red and Player B Blue.
Unit, state and facing.
1 start of Player B turn
The last move made was PlayerA's Noble Armoured Cavalry, a superior unit with General, that charged into contact with the fragmented HI spear. The fragmented HI stood up the charge.
In player B turn no new units join the combats but:-
a) Disrupted MI SCUTARI go to fragmented with combat loss.
b) Good LC JAV go to fragmented with combat loss.
c) Fragmented HI SPEAR rout with combat loss and disperse.
At end of Player B turn and start of Player A turn situation is now
The MI Scutari are able to be moved as normal.
Neither Armoured Cavalry is in any ZOC nor are they noted as pursuing – the routed HI had already dispersed.
Can anyone explain why neither cavalry unit could move or rotate in any way?
I had expected to flank charge and start rolling up the HI Spears and MI Spears with the first charge using superior cavalry with General against the fragmented HI. They stood against the charge which, though unlikely, can of course happen. What I cannot understand is why the cavalry (but not the Scutari) were frozen in my subsequent move after the HI had routed and dispersed.
Clarification would be much appreciated as this was a pivotal moment and I am keen to learn what I may be missing.
At the end of my move situation had become
a) Fragmented MI SCUTARI rout.
b) Fragmented LC Jav Rout
c) MI SCUTARI in combat with MI SPEAR flank attacked by a new unit and disrupted
d) MI SCUTARI charge and disrupt HI SPEAR
e) Both ARM CAV can make no move at all.