Slitherine

AI don't defend its supply base... and no matter if it would do a good job of that (was only last couple of turns almost all axis was out of supply), it is too weak.

Or rather, the soviet forces are amazingly good!

frozen mud screenshot is probably turn 15, i.e. a few turns after the renewed axis offensive (prep attacks).

cold winter screenshot is end of final turn... very sad not completely destroying the axis forces.

Yes, my very 1st campaign as Rus vs Ger, VP= -5 (neg!), and in thougher difficulty: critical success!
I did 3 campaigns as Ger vs Rus, easy difficulty, and only made 25VP: loss each time

Way to easy as Rus, too difficult as Ger.

EDIT: There is a unique strategy to win with German: with massive elite armors, rush VictoryPoints right side, then the Reinforcement points up side: 94VP in easy difficulty...

Play against people.