routers and bisected angles
Posted: Mon Mar 17, 2008 9:11 pm
this created a geometric question
imagine a pike block engaged frontally
elephants next them (on the pikes left) engaged frontally and to the flank, so the elephants are two elements deep in relation to the pikes front
ccccc
cepp
cepp
xxpp
xxpp
c= emeny
e = elephant
p= pike
x= space
the elephants rout, question is what happens?
in the rules (my limited understanding) routers can 'slide' upto 1 base width to avoid friends, the routers bisect the angle to get direction of rout
Q's when the elephants turn to make the bisected angle they will temporarily 'interpenetrate' the pikes bases, does this 'count' as interpenetration, are they even allowed to do this 'turn' due to lack of room
if they are allowed to do this turn and it doesn't count as interpenetration, where do you count the 1 base width slide from?
if its the original position of the elephants, 1 base width won't get them around the pike
if its the new bisected angle, the rotation of the base gets them a few millimetres towards the gap and the 1 base width slide will clear the pike and there isn't any interpenetration
so what should have happened?
imagine a pike block engaged frontally
elephants next them (on the pikes left) engaged frontally and to the flank, so the elephants are two elements deep in relation to the pikes front
ccccc
cepp
cepp
xxpp
xxpp
c= emeny
e = elephant
p= pike
x= space
the elephants rout, question is what happens?
in the rules (my limited understanding) routers can 'slide' upto 1 base width to avoid friends, the routers bisect the angle to get direction of rout
Q's when the elephants turn to make the bisected angle they will temporarily 'interpenetrate' the pikes bases, does this 'count' as interpenetration, are they even allowed to do this 'turn' due to lack of room
if they are allowed to do this turn and it doesn't count as interpenetration, where do you count the 1 base width slide from?
if its the original position of the elephants, 1 base width won't get them around the pike
if its the new bisected angle, the rotation of the base gets them a few millimetres towards the gap and the 1 base width slide will clear the pike and there isn't any interpenetration
so what should have happened?