Page 1 of 1

Conforming and Flanks

Posted: Fri Feb 22, 2008 4:18 pm
by mikekh
Two foot BGs, each of 8 elements, are in contact frontally and neither side has an overlap.

AAAA
AAAA
BBBB
BBBB*

Imagine a BG friendly to side A charging Bs and contacting the rightmost second rank element (marked B*) as a legal flank contact. The contact is not at right angles. The B* element is contacted on its rhs edge by the front corner of the charging enemy BG. (Not shown but referred to as C).
The B* element turns 90 degrees so that its front edge is in contact with the front corner of C, is this correct? The impact is fought at -2 and +2 POE with 1 element each. What happens in Cs movement phase. Does the whole of the C BG swing round so that its at right angles to B? (and parallel to B*)(That's what we did).

What happens if there are units friendly to B to the rear and right of B and in a position such that they prevent(?) all of C from swinging round to conform at right angles. Any other general comments about this type of circumstance would be welcome. For example would C have to conform if it exposed his flank - I guess it would, wouldn't it?

Hope this is clear - if not I'll draw a picture.


Thanks

BTW Excellent rules !

Re: Conforming and Flanks

Posted: Fri Feb 22, 2008 4:37 pm
by rbodleyscott
mikekh wrote: Does the whole of the C BG swing round so that its at right angles to B? (and parallel to B*/
Yes
What happens if there are units friendly to B to the rear and right of B and in a position such that they prevent(?) all of C from swinging round to conform at right angles.
Then it doesn't conform but fights as if it had done so.
For example would C have to conform if it exposed his flank - I guess it would, wouldn't it?
Yes. It is important to think ahead about such things.

Re: Conforming and Flanks

Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2008 1:55 pm
by mikekh
What happens if there are units friendly to B to the rear and right of B and in a position such that they prevent(?) all of C from swinging round to conform at right angles.
Then it doesn't conform but fights as if it had done so.
If C cannot fully conform - i.e. can't completely swing round to conform at right angles, due to enemy units, does C swing round as far as the 'blocking' enemy unit allows it? And if so, how far short of the blocking unit must C stop?

Thanks

mike

Re: Conforming and Flanks

Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2008 2:12 pm
by rbodleyscott
mikekh wrote:
What happens if there are units friendly to B to the rear and right of B and in a position such that they prevent(?) all of C from swinging round to conform at right angles.
Then it doesn't conform but fights as if it had done so.
If C cannot fully conform - i.e. can't completely swing round to conform at right angles, due to enemy units, does C swing round as far as the 'blocking' enemy unit allows it? And if so, how far short of the blocking unit must C stop?
Nope, there is no such thing as partially conforming. If it can confom it does, if it can't it doesn't.

Re: Conforming and Flanks

Posted: Sat Feb 23, 2008 4:54 pm
by mikekh
rbodleyscott wrote:
mikekh wrote:
Then it doesn't conform but fights as if it had done so.
If C cannot fully conform - i.e. can't completely swing round to conform at right angles, due to enemy units, does C swing round as far as the 'blocking' enemy unit allows it? And if so, how far short of the blocking unit must C stop?
Nope, there is no such thing as partially conforming. If it can confom it does, if it can't it doesn't.
Thanks, that make sense.