Hoplites at Marathon
Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 12:06 am
Page 1 of 1
Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 6:48 am
Great to see the historical re-enactment. Too bad the Greek government didnt help out. Those guys do need to learn a few things about boffer-combat safety. Those arrows the "Persian" archers were firing were far too narrow; they could have easily taken out an eye.
Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 6:53 am
Thanks for the link! Actually I was looking forward to that!
I had a visit pending to Greece and I wanted to make it at the same time of the 2500 aniversary of the battle. I checked but Greece did not seem to organize anything about that. It is such a pity that I missed that. If I wait a little I can be there in the 2500 aniversary of Thermopylae
I had a visit pending to Greece and I wanted to make it at the same time of the 2500 aniversary of the battle. I checked but Greece did not seem to organize anything about that. It is such a pity that I missed that. If I wait a little I can be there in the 2500 aniversary of Thermopylae
Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 10:25 am
Good to see, but if real hoplites charged like the ones in this video they would have been cut to ribbons by the Sparabara 
Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 12:28 pm
Hehehe note that in the background it is possible to see how one of them falls terribly. If I were there I would fear my comrades running behind me with pointy sticks!ravenflight wrote:Good to see, but if real hoplites charged like the ones in this video they would have been cut to ribbons by the Sparabara
Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 3:03 pm
I really wanted to go.
I know a lot of the guys in the photos, and did a little training myself. I even have most of my own kit!
The event was on, then off, then on, then off, then on again. In the end, it was budget reasons that prevented me. I'm sad I missed it.
Also I noticed:
That the helmet's nose-guard and cheek plates are partly there to protect you from yourself. When shields clash, the rim of your own shield can very easily be bashed against your nose or your face. There have been a few injuries in the mock-fighting along those lines, and some blood.
The sword on the hanging baldric is also very convenient, and probably couldn't be suspended a better way. The vases show them hanging too low, but tighten it up a little and the sword tips out with a simple rotation.
I know a lot of the guys in the photos, and did a little training myself. I even have most of my own kit!
The event was on, then off, then on, then off, then on again. In the end, it was budget reasons that prevented me. I'm sad I missed it.
It is too bad, but I think at this point they are having trouble organizing who will deliver the mail...I checked but Greece did not seem to organize anything about that
If I'm not mistaken, precautions were taken for that specific event -- protective eye-wear underneath the helmets.Those arrows the "Persian" archers were firing were far too narrow; they could have easily taken out an eye.
Yes, it is a little scary. It's also a good argument for the overhand spear fighting. If the hoplites held the spears underhand and start jabbing, as a rear-ranker it is very likely that you will get a sauroter in the nuts!Hehehe note that in the background it is possible to see how one of them falls terribly. If I were there I would fear my comrades running behind me with pointy sticks!
Also I noticed:
That the helmet's nose-guard and cheek plates are partly there to protect you from yourself. When shields clash, the rim of your own shield can very easily be bashed against your nose or your face. There have been a few injuries in the mock-fighting along those lines, and some blood.
The sword on the hanging baldric is also very convenient, and probably couldn't be suspended a better way. The vases show them hanging too low, but tighten it up a little and the sword tips out with a simple rotation.
Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 4:58 pm
I am thinking about getting myself the equipment too, but having started yet (just toyed with the idea and checked prices of items). In fact I have seen some wonderful helmets and breast plates in the website, much better than any other sold around. I guess some people asked or made their own specific equipment.
The good thing about reenactment is that you learn many things. I have never thought about the balance of a weapon until I saw them used. Another thing when involved in those is that the most important thing for a soldier is not being killed, thus making that the actual fighting barelly ressembles to Hollywood movies. And when you spend 3 or 4 hours under the Mediterranean sun, you realize that all rulesets should have some rules about being tired just for standing in there!
The good thing about reenactment is that you learn many things. I have never thought about the balance of a weapon until I saw them used. Another thing when involved in those is that the most important thing for a soldier is not being killed, thus making that the actual fighting barelly ressembles to Hollywood movies. And when you spend 3 or 4 hours under the Mediterranean sun, you realize that all rulesets should have some rules about being tired just for standing in there!
Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 5:54 pm
Some of us of a certain age would be really grateful if that argument were never mentioned again.It's also a good argument for the overhand spear fighting.
Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 6:10 pm
Indeed - please gods spare us that ...kevinj wrote:Some of us of a certain age would be really grateful if that argument were never mentioned again.It's also a good argument for the overhand spear fighting.
Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2011 8:05 pm
Was that big issue at one time?kevinj wrote:Some of us of a certain age would be really grateful if that argument were never mentioned again.It's also a good argument for the overhand spear fighting.