rmouzon First Impressions
Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2011 6:20 pm
Thank you for the chance to beta this game. I am a software programmer (old ada code) for the military so I do this a bit in real life.
Download: Instructions clear. Zip worked good and installed with no problems.
Game intro screen: Nice and simple. I did press the button which took me to the beta forum first by accident. Its slightly unclear of the first step you should take.
Into the Game: The first day weather and items. I did not know what to do at first. I finally figured out I had to click the screen to get started. A message that explains to click on the screen to get it started maybe helpful to a newbie.
Game play first turn: As a vet of panzer general 2 (my favorite game of all time) it is very similar. I liked how it showed the move for the inf as truck or walking. The allied armies are almost the same colour scheme as the German on a quick glance. It maybe helpful to have something that shows the Allied forces differently. It was also slightly confusing as to the goal I was going to take. The instruction maybe made slightly clearer. Again as a panzer general vet it proved no problem to myself.
First move and combat. Very clear and consise. I did like the battle sounds and clearly saw the odds before hand. Its good to have the rugged defense as well. I have to say I did not like the arty being able to retreat from the panzer attack. Arty should not be able to move very easily, in my opinion. Still not a big deal. Overall very similar to panzer general 2. I enjoyed it.
Each additional move and combat operation: Enjoyable. Easy to understand. Pushed the enemy back easily. Give a newbie a good basic idea of the need to use combined arms, but with simple commands.
Buttons, maps, menu, etc: The weather, and turn button could be made a bit clearer. I performed the normal moving cursor over each item to see what it was, but it is not clear. Maybe a quick tutorial over the buttons before hand or during the first move maybe helpful to a total newbie. Sadly I did not use the small map very much. Everything worked that I pressed with no problems.
Final victory: I won. Good. However I did not get the idea I did until I hit the next turn button. I think a message to tell the person of the victory might be a better way of informing the user.
Overall: Very good. Stable. Fun. Easy to use. Very much like Panzer General 2. This was clearly based on that concept. A few minor tweaks to help newbies and it would almost be perfect. However, I would like to be able to name my General.
Again, thanks for this chance. I will update this after each mission or new item I perform.
Rmouzon
Download: Instructions clear. Zip worked good and installed with no problems.
Game intro screen: Nice and simple. I did press the button which took me to the beta forum first by accident. Its slightly unclear of the first step you should take.
Into the Game: The first day weather and items. I did not know what to do at first. I finally figured out I had to click the screen to get started. A message that explains to click on the screen to get it started maybe helpful to a newbie.
Game play first turn: As a vet of panzer general 2 (my favorite game of all time) it is very similar. I liked how it showed the move for the inf as truck or walking. The allied armies are almost the same colour scheme as the German on a quick glance. It maybe helpful to have something that shows the Allied forces differently. It was also slightly confusing as to the goal I was going to take. The instruction maybe made slightly clearer. Again as a panzer general vet it proved no problem to myself.
First move and combat. Very clear and consise. I did like the battle sounds and clearly saw the odds before hand. Its good to have the rugged defense as well. I have to say I did not like the arty being able to retreat from the panzer attack. Arty should not be able to move very easily, in my opinion. Still not a big deal. Overall very similar to panzer general 2. I enjoyed it.
Each additional move and combat operation: Enjoyable. Easy to understand. Pushed the enemy back easily. Give a newbie a good basic idea of the need to use combined arms, but with simple commands.
Buttons, maps, menu, etc: The weather, and turn button could be made a bit clearer. I performed the normal moving cursor over each item to see what it was, but it is not clear. Maybe a quick tutorial over the buttons before hand or during the first move maybe helpful to a total newbie. Sadly I did not use the small map very much. Everything worked that I pressed with no problems.
Final victory: I won. Good. However I did not get the idea I did until I hit the next turn button. I think a message to tell the person of the victory might be a better way of informing the user.
Overall: Very good. Stable. Fun. Easy to use. Very much like Panzer General 2. This was clearly based on that concept. A few minor tweaks to help newbies and it would almost be perfect. However, I would like to be able to name my General.
Again, thanks for this chance. I will update this after each mission or new item I perform.
Rmouzon