Slitherine

During the deployment phase i cant overstrength my veteran units, i can only reinforce to 10.
Is this a bug or by design?

Sounds like a bug. Could you please send me saved game to rudankort@rsdn.ru?

Rudankort wrote:Sounds like a bug. Could you please send me saved game to rudankort@rsdn.ru?

Sure mail is send!

Hmmm second thing i wonder a bit, the toughness of the Spitfire MK I ...
I attacked in turn 8 one Spit on 10 with my 4 core Me109f ...
1. I surrounded the Spit with all my Me109f
2. I attacked wit my 12 Strength Me109 than with 2 x 10 Strength Me109 and at least with 1 x 9 Strength Me109

My Me109f 1 x nearly 3 Stars, 2 with nearly 2 Stars one blank bought at the begin of sealion, the Spit was blank without Exp

Outcome ... i lost 4 Points of strength ... the Spit lost 8

http://i1185.photobucket.com/albums/z34 ... n_spit.jpg

was this a really lucky Spit??? Balance Problem? Or this this ok? i ever thought the Me109 and the Spit were equal? If they are equal than this outcome isn't ok ..

Steakenglisch wrote:Hmmm second thing i wonder a bit, the toughness of the Spitfire MK I ...
I attacked in turn 8 one Spit on 10 with my 4 core Me109f ...
1. I surrounded the Spit with all my Me109f
2. I attacked wit my 12 Strength Me109 than with 2 x 10 Strength Me109 and at least with 1 x 9 Strength Me109

My Me109f 1 x nearly 3 Stars, 2 with nearly 2 Stars one blank bought at the begin of sealion, the Spit was blank without Exp

Outcome ... i lost 4 Points of strength ... the Spit lost 8

http://i1185.photobucket.com/albums/z34 ... n_spit.jpg

was this a really lucky Spit??? Balance Problem? Or this this ok? i ever thought the Me109 and the Spit were equal? If they are equal than this outcome isn't ok ..

Hm.. combat log would be better than screnshoot of units after action (hit L key). Radars give +1 initiative to friendly units. Experience gives bonus to units but in some cases attack and defense ratings are moving on the edge like in opening stages of war so it is hard to kill a unit with two or three shots which was done to save player from his losses. Do note Bf109E has stronger AA than Bf109F but initiative and defense values differ as well as range. From combat experience I would say Bf109E is better. And do not forget dice can be really tricky from time to time.

The problem stems from the Spitfire having too high an Air Defense value.
109f firing at 12 strength against spitfire at 18 defense is very ineffectual, 19% chance for a kill.

For balance, I'd bump spitfire attack to 16(+1), 109e to 15(+1), and 109f to 14(+2), although how this will affect other contemporary air units, I am uncertain.

uran21 wrote:

Steakenglisch wrote:Hmmm second thing i wonder a bit, the toughness of the Spitfire MK I ...
I attacked in turn 8 one Spit on 10 with my 4 core Me109f ...
1. I surrounded the Spit with all my Me109f
2. I attacked wit my 12 Strength Me109 than with 2 x 10 Strength Me109 and at least with 1 x 9 Strength Me109

My Me109f 1 x nearly 3 Stars, 2 with nearly 2 Stars one blank bought at the begin of sealion, the Spit was blank without Exp

Outcome ... i lost 4 Points of strength ... the Spit lost 8

http://i1185.photobucket.com/albums/z34 ... n_spit.jpg

was this a really lucky Spit??? Balance Problem? Or this this ok? i ever thought the Me109 and the Spit were equal? If they are equal than this outcome isn't ok ..

Hm.. combat log would be better than screnshoot of units after action (hit L key). Radars give +1 initiative to friendly units. Experience gives bonus to units but in some cases attack and defense ratings are moving on the edge like in opening stages of war so it is hard to kill a unit with two or three shots which was done to save player from his losses. Do note Bf109E has stronger AA than Bf109F but initiative and defense values differ as well as range. From combat experience I would say Bf109E is better. And do not forget dice can be really tricky from time to time.

OK i will try it again with an Mix of Me109E and F and next time you get a Log