Slitherine

When assaulting a fortofied baggage camp do quality re-rolls still count?

Cheers

Andy Robinson

Does anyone have an opinion on this?

Cheers

Andy

andy816 wrote:Does anyone have an opinion on this?

Cheers

Andy

IMO not currently covered by the rules. We need to decide. On general principles I don't see any reason why they shouldn't count.

I think they should count and the rules say that only death rolls and shock troop CMTs are not covered. So if Richard and Terry agree I would take that as the view for Leeds and then we need to insert it to be clear as it is only covered by inference at present.

See you soon. I have just packed my Indians - and mighty poor they look.....still I guess I will be a good test for the "MF bow are mincemeat vs cavalry in the open" brigade. I am anticipating having lots of time to wander round the games and chat....

Si

shall wrote: See you soon. I have just packed my Indians - and mighty poor they look.....still I guess I will be a good test for the "MF bow are mincemeat vs cavalry in the open" brigade. I am anticipating having lots of time to wander round the games and chat....

Si

Are you honestly going to be able to bring yourself to stand out in the open and take it? Surely there will be a cunning plan involved...

I am sure I will think of something in the car on the way up to Leeds.....

I am going to play 2 games in head on mode and then switch to full competition mode for the other two to see how different I can get the army to play...if I lose all four 32-0 that will tell me soemthing for sure. But I am not going to say which game is in which mode at the outset.....i will let the cubes of chance decide

Si

PS In the last 10 years I have used classical Indians on about 15 occasions....it is the army with which I have the worst record over that time!! I think I have only won 3 games with it in total.