OH DEAR!
Posted: Sun Mar 28, 2010 1:32 am
This is my sixth Slitherine game.I buy without demos because I trust them.
This game may be the best yet,but after an hour of fiddling around,I am finding it very hard to raise any interest.
Why?
1 EGYPT engineering an empire----- but the Grand campaign plays as Persia or Assyria,no Egypt.
Seems like a misnamed product to me.
2 The tutorials are nearly non existant.
3 The short manual tells you nothing about the various scenarios.
4 No scenario uses the full map,not even the Grand campaign
5 Egypt scenario runs 665-300 BC. Sea control scenario runs 650-250 BC.
Basically the same time frame.
But map is different , for instance, different cities and no Ethiopians to the south.
strange for a company that prides itself historical accuracy,or were there two different Egypts?
I will not go on looking for gripes and hope it may turn out to be a great game,but unusually I felt the need to express my initial disappointment instead of remaining a silent forum member.
I thought I was getting the opportunity to build the great cities and monuments of the Egyptian civilisation down past Thebes to to Cateracts,but of course this this occured before 650BC.
This game may be the best yet,but after an hour of fiddling around,I am finding it very hard to raise any interest.
Why?
1 EGYPT engineering an empire----- but the Grand campaign plays as Persia or Assyria,no Egypt.
Seems like a misnamed product to me.
2 The tutorials are nearly non existant.
3 The short manual tells you nothing about the various scenarios.
4 No scenario uses the full map,not even the Grand campaign
5 Egypt scenario runs 665-300 BC. Sea control scenario runs 650-250 BC.
Basically the same time frame.
But map is different , for instance, different cities and no Ethiopians to the south.
strange for a company that prides itself historical accuracy,or were there two different Egypts?
I will not go on looking for gripes and hope it may turn out to be a great game,but unusually I felt the need to express my initial disappointment instead of remaining a silent forum member.
I thought I was getting the opportunity to build the great cities and monuments of the Egyptian civilisation down past Thebes to to Cateracts,but of course this this occured before 650BC.