Wheeling and then moving straight
Posted: Sat Nov 13, 2021 9:12 pm
The subject of this post is whether when Wheeling and then moving straight the correct way to measure is
A) Measure the wheel and then measure off the remaining movement or
B) measure from the starting position to the end point in a straight line
i have noticed that for a crucial measure such as whether a charge including a wheel is in range, in my experience, everyone measures the distance wheeled and then whether the remaining straight line distance is enough to allow contact. Option A.
However, when wheeling units during normal movement many players measure using option B. Additionally, as the wheel is not measured out the position of what would be the none moving corner is completely free floating.
Page 40 of the rules says "Wheeling is a change of direction by rotating around one front corner of the battle group or battle line. one corner of the front edge remains in the same position. For ease of measuring, the distance moved during the wheel is taken as a straight linefrom the starting position to the ending position of the moving front corner.". It also says "When wheeling, be careful not to slide the corner on which the battle group is pivoting as this is not permitted in the rules."
Me and Dave Ruddock both point at the same section as proving our point. I believe that the statement "during the wheel" is key and therefore option A is correct.
Dave says the key part is 'ending position' as it doesn't say end of the wheel. Therefore, supporting option B.
Can some other umpires or indeed authors please elucidate.
Thanks
A) Measure the wheel and then measure off the remaining movement or
B) measure from the starting position to the end point in a straight line
i have noticed that for a crucial measure such as whether a charge including a wheel is in range, in my experience, everyone measures the distance wheeled and then whether the remaining straight line distance is enough to allow contact. Option A.
However, when wheeling units during normal movement many players measure using option B. Additionally, as the wheel is not measured out the position of what would be the none moving corner is completely free floating.
Page 40 of the rules says "Wheeling is a change of direction by rotating around one front corner of the battle group or battle line. one corner of the front edge remains in the same position. For ease of measuring, the distance moved during the wheel is taken as a straight linefrom the starting position to the ending position of the moving front corner.". It also says "When wheeling, be careful not to slide the corner on which the battle group is pivoting as this is not permitted in the rules."
Me and Dave Ruddock both point at the same section as proving our point. I believe that the statement "during the wheel" is key and therefore option A is correct.
Dave says the key part is 'ending position' as it doesn't say end of the wheel. Therefore, supporting option B.
Can some other umpires or indeed authors please elucidate.
Thanks