Slitherine

i won my games by reaching 40% so i see the issue. the scoring will be reviewed. i haven't had time to think it through. i will make proposals later. i'm most concerned with the fact that the winner's losses get minimized at the end of the game and thus the loser's score gets lowered artificially.

two results from round 1

royalists (jomni) 5939
782 52
970 65
1206 205
8

parliament (fogman) 4882
267 52
538 109
20 13

fogman 5.2
jomni 2.3


catholics (iandavidsmith) 5148
456 132
564 168
935 474
14

swedes (fogman) 5348
168 82
341 167
9 30

fogman 5.7
iandavidsmith 1.9

i forgot but whoever is playing jomni right now please tell him to post his challenges.

ggarnorman 5550
647 203
799 256
1031 422
16

pantherboy 5348
180 0
365 0
0 0

ggarynorman 0.1
pantherboy 6.0
................................................
cavehobbit 7054
525 45
1055 92
192 9

pantherboy 5221
879 80
1083 100
1076 133
8

cavehobbit 6.0
pantherboy 2.8

Cavehobbit (Parliamentarian) 4.9 pts vs Iandavidsmith (Royalist) 0.5 pts

Parliamentarian (6465)
Killed 95/3
Wounded 192/8
Captured/Deserted 0/0
Guns Lost 0

Royalist (4555)
Killed 180/139
Wounded 227/175
Captured/Deserted 866/310
Guns Lost 12

The game ended very sudden in a 40%-0% win. Thanks for the game!

pantherboy wrote: cavehobbit 6.0
pantherboy 2.8

Great game! Don't know how I won this one, it was much closer than the point result indicate. In percent I think it was 53%-60%.
IIRC this was my first win against PB, ever

fogman 5651
478 263
592 330
887 480
16

pantherboy 6577
165 22
335 46
0 0

fogman 0.9
pantherboy 6.0

A friendly reminder , unless i have missed something , i am waiting on challenges from Pantherboy and jomni

Cheers
Ian

cavehobbit wrote:

pantherboy wrote: cavehobbit 6.0
pantherboy 2.8

Great game! Don't know how I won this one, it was much closer than the point result indicate. In percent I think it was 53%-60%.
IIRC this was my first win against PB, ever

That's a very small group you have become part off.

Challenges posted for iandavidsmith and jomni. Passwords iandavidsmith and jomni respectively.

Cheers,

Steve

Cavehobbit (Protestant) 6.0 pts vs ggarynorman (Catholic) 2.3 pts

Protestant (9831)
Killed 554/28
Wounded 1112/59
Captured/Deserted 83/0
Guns Lost 8

Catholic (7767)
Killed 920/388
Wounded 1137/483
Captured/Deserted 1187/334
Guns Lost 8

Thanks for a good game, well played!

Cavehobbit (Spanish) 6.0 pts vs Fogman (Frensh) 0.9 pts

Spanish (8062)
Killed 181/29
Wounded 363/62
Captured/Deserted 66/0
Guns Lost 0

Catholic (5037)
Killed 282/440
Wounded 348/549
Captured/Deserted 477/655
Guns Lost 8

Thanks for the game!

No news from Jomni?

No sign from jomni.

Sorry i've been out of action. Challenge coming up.

Challenges are out

pw = fogman, cavehobbit, iandavidsmith

iandavidsmith 5969
758 211
939 263
1034 378
8

pantherboy 7780
274 89
552 181
0 44

iandavidsmith 1.8
pantherboy 6.0

Result

iandavidsmith (Scots Covenanter) 4.3 pts
vs
ggarynorman (New Model Army) pts 1.3 pts

iandavidsmith (Scots Covenanter)

foot 651= 651
horse 61x 2 = 122
deserted 50/ 2 =25
cannon 0 x 50 =0
total men = 6166
score = (651+ 122+ 25+ 0) /6166= 0.129 x 10 =1.3


cavehobbit(French)

foot 1133= 1133
horse 166 x 2 = 332
deserted 1000/ 2 =500
cannon 0 x 50 =0
total men = 4505
score = (1133+ 332+ 500+ 0) /4505= .436 x 10 = 4.3

Thanks for the game ,
Ian

Result

fogman (Imperial 19-32) 3.0 pts
vs
iandavidsmith (Protestant 18-31) 5.6 pts


fogman (Imperial 19-32)
foot 2483= 2483
horse 565 x 2 = 1130
deserted 2236/ 2 =1118
cannon 8 x 50 =400
total men = 9065
score = (2483 + 1130 + 1118 + 400) /9065= 0.566 x 10 =5.6


iandavidsmith (Protestant 18-31)
foot 1458= 1458
horse 382 x 2 = 764
deserted 154 / 2 =77
cannon 8 x 50 =400
total men = 9023
score = (1458 + 764 + 77 + 400) /9023= .299 x 10 = 3.0

Great game,
Ian

Results

jomni = 8.2 ---> 6.0
vs
iandavidsmith = 3.1

jomni
foot 671= 671
horse 538 x 2 = 1076
deserted 81/ 2 =40.5
cannon 2 x 50 =100
total men = 5984
score = (671 + 1076 + 40.5 + 100) /5984= 0.31 x 10 =3.1

iandavidsmith
foot 1895= 1895
horse 378 x 2 = 756
deserted 1405 / 2 =702.5
cannon 28 x 50 =1400
total men = 5780
score = (1895 + 756 + 702.5 + 1400) /5780 = .82 x 10 = 8.2

Gun losses seem to be a bit excessive. Did I calculate the points correclty?

Results

jomni = 1.9
vs
pantherboy = 5.3

jomni
foot 886= 886
horse 260 x 2 = 520
deserted 1082/ 2 =541
cannon 10 x 50 =500
total men = 4610
score = (886 + 520 + 541 + 500) /4610= 0.53 x 10 = 5.3

pantherboy
foot 613= 613
horse 86 x 2 = 172
deserted 59 / 2 =29.5
cannon 0 x 50 =0
total men = 5641
score = (613 + 172 + 29.5 + 0) /5641 = .19 x 10 = 1.9

Results

jomni = 2.4
vs
fogman = 4.1

jomni
foot 1017= 1017
horse 302 x 2 = 604
deserted 1505/ 2 =752.5
cannon 0 x 50 =0
total men = 5756
score = (1017 + 604 + 752.5 + 0) /5756= 0.41 x 10 = 4.1

fogman
foot 911= 911
horse 89 x 2 = 178
deserted 52 / 2 =26
cannon 0 x 50 =0
total men = 4506
score = (911 + 178 + 26 + 0) /4506 = .24 x 10 = 2.4