Slitherine

Looks like you're in a minority of one Dave.

Why not give in gracefully?

Pete

Don't think Dave has ever done anything gracefully

I have done lot's of things gracefully. Just giving in isn't one of them.

I am fine with the intent of the rule - I would like something in the rulebook or FAQs to back it up though.

I don't want to be faced with this in a game in the future to say "close combat means about to throw dice in the next combat phase" only to be asked "where is that in the rules then?"...

we all like to avoid that dreaded question alright...

dave_r wrote:A lucky American scribed:

Yes and you've both lost to me so you are total disasters.

That was only because the dust storm started. Without it you were minutes from a crushing defeat

Allah told me to expect it. It was all planned.

terrys wrote: But if you need an answer to this......
Any unit that would get a combat dice when the next combat phase comes around is clearly 'in combat'.

So if i am in overlap on a unit that has another BG impacting into it, i am in close combat during the initial (first) impact phase. Even though i get no dice? i could see it either eay but from your answer presume yes?

hazelbark wrote:

terrys wrote: But if you need an answer to this......
Any unit that would get a combat dice when the next combat phase comes around is clearly 'in combat'.

So if i am in overlap on a unit that has another BG impacting into it, i am in close combat during the initial (first) impact phase. Even though i get no dice? i could see it either eay but from your answer presume yes?

That you are but if you BG is only in close combat as an overlap it is allowed to evade which was the issue at the start of this whole thread.