Slitherine

skyrider wrote:Just so I'm clear on the process. Russian declares divisions and areas, then German does same. Next Russian assigns Generals to divisions and then German follows. Is this correct?

Close, but not quite.

Soviets declare primary Divisions. Germans declare primary & secondary forces and Generals. Soviets then declare secondary forces and Generals...then the battles begin.

See 'Ordering' in the Campaign Info.

Maybe its just me but seems Russians have an edge there. How about Russians declare primary and secondary force commitments. Germans do the same. The second step is what I'm proposing. Russian declares commanders but sends list only to you, German does same. As soon as they both have declared you post the new battles and off we go!

skyrider wrote:As soon as they both have declared you post the new battles

This would compromise my position as a player. I would prefer to keep things out in the open. We could alternate turns on how the orders are issued. So next turn, the sequence would be reversed?

This game calls for the honor system , but I can understand your hesitation. Yes I think that would help! I think at the tourney start you said the Russians setting up might not be a good thing, has that changed?

Here are the German forces and commanders for the next battles.

Updated secondary 2 to be C4.

N2 - SS - Totenkopf LVI Corps - General Erling
C2 - 131st Inf DIV XXXXIII Corps - General Collier4
C4 - 12th Panzer LVII Corps - General Random27
Stalingrad - SS - Wiking XIV Corps - General JCB989

Secondary 1 - C2 - 28th Inf Div VIII Corps - FM Morge4
Secondary 2 - C4- 31st Inf DIV XII Corps - General Skyrider

Thanks for your orders sir!

Quick note in case you didn't notice though...German forces must win with both the primary and secondary attacks to take an objective city (like Stalingrad). You may wish to assign a secondary elsewhere instead to avoid having to do that...but it does then rely on having the primary only carry the victory.

Let me know if there are any questions.

Brummbar44 wrote:Quick note in case you didn't notice though...German forces must win with both the primary and secondary attacks to take an objective city (like Stalingrad).

Ok, then let me rethink this for a little bit. If I revise I will get it to you ASAP. And even if I don't...

morge4 wrote:

Brummbar44 wrote:Quick note in case you didn't notice though...German forces must win with both the primary and secondary attacks to take an objective city (like Stalingrad).

Ok, then let me rethink this for a little bit. If I revise I will get it to you ASAP. And even if I don't...

While we are on the subject, keep in mind with the ordering swap that kicks in next turn (ie. the Soviets will post secondaries instead of the Germans) the Soviet could force a secondary at an objective city like Stalingrad. Hope this isn't getting too complicated!

Brummbar44 wrote:

morge4 wrote:

Brummbar44 wrote:Quick note in case you didn't notice though...German forces must win with both the primary and secondary attacks to take an objective city (like Stalingrad).

Ok, then let me rethink this for a little bit. If I revise I will get it to you ASAP. And even if I don't...

While we are on the subject, keep in mind with the ordering swap that kicks in next turn (ie. the Soviets will post secondaries instead of the Germans) the Soviet could force a secondary at an objective city like Stalingrad. Hope this isn't getting too complicated!

On the plus side, we'll have this all ironed out for the next campaign

Battles updated in my original post, secondary 2 is now C4 instead of Stalingrad. Same commander.

morge4 wrote:Battles updated in my original post, secondary 2 is now C4 instead of Stalingrad. Same commander.

Thank you. Map and orders updated. Over to the Soviet FM...

N2- Glen
C2- Lobo
C4-Cavehobbit
Stalingrad- Real+100

Secondary C2- Gibrinskii (Rifle Division)
Secondary C4- MacD2013 (remaining Armoured)

Thank you sir, battle map and situation updated.

The die is cast gentlemen, you may commence your battles...best of luck!

Here is the Turn 3 summary...

General Gibrinskii, our battle is set! See you in the City!

morge4 wrote:General Gibrinskii, our battle is set! See you in the City!

Challenge accepted! Have a good time!

Gen. Gibrinskii

OORAH

Battle created for Gen Lobo. Good luck comrade.

Then my game is ready. Looking forward to this. Glenghischcan will you see if everything is done correctly?

collier4 wrote:Battle created for Gen Lobo. Good luck comrade.

Roger that Gen Collier! Engaging - Good luck Herr Gen!