Slitherine

Hmm, my understanding was that either player could reject a map within three turns but only twice for a match. The third map had to be played regardless.

Division E

phlewis Sarmatian 25-375 AD with Germanic Horse Tribes 260-492 AD allies (1600)
Challenges
GeneralKostas Armenian 253-476 AD with Roman 313-378 AD allies (1600)

Password: armenia

Division C

GDod Andalusian 1050-1154 (with Berber (Murabit) Allies 1039-1086) beat Kroche German (South East) 1200-1319AD 44-2

An unfortunate swamp in the middle mean't the Andalusians had the opportunity to withdraw the entire wing and "swamp" the enemies left flank.


GDod Andalusian 1050-1154 (with Berber (Murabit) Allies 1039-1086) beat random27 Indian (Hindu North) 1050-1300 AD (with Indian (Rajput)) 1050-1339 AD 43-17

Retiring to a forest wasn't enough to stop the advance on the Andalusian right while the centre and left was tied down and beaten back. Contagious Indian morale drops didn't help.

Thanks to both players for the challenge.

Division B

joggy (Germanic/Gothic Horse Tribes 260-492 AD with Dacian (Carpi) 107-380 AD allies) beat IMC (Jewish Revolt 66-135 AD) 65-42

Division E

olddog52 -Chinese (Jin) victory over gort7078-Chinese 3 Kingdoms (Wu) 52-18

I owe this victory to my cavalry with support from my archers, Wu Inf pushed my right flank back but Jin cavalry moved like a bolt from heaven breaking the Wu right.

olddog52-Chinese 3 Kingdoms (Wu) victory over gort7078- Chinese (Jin) 63-40

Terrain and arrows won this battle. Thank you Don for 2 well-played games.

Right well I shall bear that in mind for next season then

Division F

Vadim 84(Germanic/Gothic Horse Tribes 260-492 AD with Dacian (Carpi) 107-380 AD allies) beat mh5064 (Roman) 51-25
thanks for the game

mh5064 wrote: ↑Sat Oct 23, 2021 8:08 pm Hi,

player Lunarfoxx in Classical Antiquity, Division F invoking rule 4 has arbitrarily canceled the battle because it is unfavorable to him.("Rule 4 Match Players may agree to re-start a match within the first three turns if they believe the terrain is likely to produce a sterile match or a draw. The maximum number of re-starts permitted for a single match is two.")
Without having agreed on the thing and without having responded positively. I quote his exact words "I don't known about this terrain. I might wanna redo this" and then "I'll set up the new match. gonna redo it within the 3 turns cuz of terrain".
But the ground was fine for me and certainly would not have produced a drawn or sterile game.
He also benefits from having seen the composition of my army.
I wanted to ask a question about this:
Is this kind of attitude regular?
Thanks

Cheers

I hope it is not, because it is against the rule. Rule 4 is quite clear . . .

"Players may agree to re-start a match within the first three turns if they believe the terrain is likely to produce a sterile match or a draw. The maximum number of re-starts permitted for a single match is two."

The key word here is "agree". What I can do is pass the match to our adjudication panel, if you so wish. Please let me know.

Badger73 wrote: ↑Sat Oct 23, 2021 9:14 pm Hmm, my understanding was that either player could reject a map within three turns but only twice for a match. The third map had to be played regardless.

No, that is wrong. There has to be agreement between the two players.

obsolete

Division A

tyronec (Carthaginian) defeats Stew101 (Persian) 61-50

Thanks for the game.

(3-1)

In an unheard of development I actually understood the rules correctly then

Weekly round-up
Still very slow in Division A where tyronec (Syracusan) is taking full advantage by posting his fourth straight win this week to establish a clear lead of 10 points. Things have tightened at the top of Division B where dim30 (Syracusan) has closed the gap to 3 points on leader desertedfox (Kyrenean Greek). Both players have 3 matches left. batesmotel (Roman) has started with 2 narrow victories and may present a challenge. Division C is also quiet where ray552 (Graeco-Bactrian) is still the leader. Both DanZanzibar (Samnite) and BobGanoush (Bithynian) look well-placed to challenge him in the next few weeks. A good week for Bodhran (Bosporan) has seen him extend his lead to 7 points over second-placed ulysisgrunt (Gallic) with unbeaten Kroche (Carthaginian) and DocVanNostrand (Thracian) currently sitting back in the pack with 2 wins each. Rob123 (Achaemenid) is in deep relegation trouble after losing his first 5 matches. markleslie (Antigonid) has extended his lead in Division E to 9 points after posting his sixth win from 7 starts, but there are still 4 players who could challenge him for the top spot. Holien (Hannibal in Africa) and sivispacem (Sertorius) are best-placed currently and both players still have 100% records. Hari72 (Macedonian) is facing the drop after registering only 1 win in his first 7 matches. Rosedelio (Kyrenean Greek) duly won his eighth consecutive match to secure promotion from Division F this week, while mh5064 (Macedonian) is now challenging for second place after narrowly beating the present incumbent olddog52 (Spartan).

Unbeaten runs of 3 matches or more
tyronec (Division A) 4 matches
ray552 (Division C) 3 matches
Badger73 (Division E) 3 matches
Holien (Division E) 4 matches
markleslie (Division E) 3 matches
sivispacem (Division E) 3 matches
mh5064 (Division F) 4 matches
Rosedelio (Division F) 8 matches

Match completion rate (45 matches in total to be played in each division)
Division A - 8 out of 45 matches completed
Division B - 19 out of 45 matches completed
Division C -14 out of 45 matches completed
Division D - 20 out of 45 matches completed
Division E - 24 out of 45 matches completed
Division F - 32 out of 45 matches completed

Division A is slow, but otherwise these are good match completion rates.

Player of the Week: mh5064 (Division F) with 4 wins this week.

Division B

IMC - Viking (Ireland) 900-1049 AD with Scots 851-1051 AD allies has beaten (just) Nijis - Armenian 885-1045 AD with Byzantine 963-987 AD allies 61% v 58%

A rare win for IMC

Thanks for the game.
Ian

(3-1)

Weekly round-up
Very much a 2-horse race in Division A now between Nosy_Rat (Lombard) and Questar17 (Bosporan) with both players extending their 100% records this week. At the bottom both Morbio (Roman) and SpeedyCM (Jewish Revolt) are stuck on zero points after 5 matches. In Division B the current score is joggy 32, everyone else 20. joggy only has 1 match left though while everyone else has 31 matches to overtake him. Warg1 (Arab City) still has a commanding 9 point lead in Division C, where Delbruck (Roman) has moved into second place with his third win. Giacofa93 (Pictish) has started with a win in his first match. Blagrot (Jewish Revolt) is the new leader in Division D after his third win from 3 starts, but 4 other players also still have 100% records. Both Barrold713 (Soissons) and Doyley50 (Palmyran) are already in relegation trouble
though and uregently need to pick up some points. Very interesting situation now in a well-progressed Division E where Badger73 (Palmyran) now has 6 wins from 8 starts, putting him 6 points ahead of Lynx57 (Roman) who has 2 games in hand. It looks to be between these 2 players now, although Darkwater247 (Germanic Horse Tribes) has started with 2 wins from 3. In Division F Hari72 (Sassanid) has strengthened his position at the top with 3 more wins and he has also been helped by the first defeats for challengers heidipie (Jewish Revolt) and shane30 (Palmyran). Meroka37 (Dacian) desperately needs points now to avoid the wooden spoon position.

Unbeaten runs of 3 matches or more
Nosy_Rat (Division A) 5 matches
Questar17 (Division A) 4 matches
joggy (Division B) 8 matches
Delbruck (Division C) 3 matches
Warg1 (Division C) 5 matches
Blagrot (Division D) 3 matches
Badger73 (Division E) 6 matches
Lynx57 (Division E) 3 matches
Hari72 (Division F) 7 matches

Match completion rate (45 matches in total to be played in each division)
Division A - 18 out of 45 matches completed
Division B - 13 out of 45 matches completed
Division C - 15 out of 45 matches completed
Division D - 13 out of 45 matches completed
Division E - 24 out of 45 matches completed
Division F - 28 out of 45 matches completed

These are good match completion rates.

Player of the Week: Hari72 (Division F) who has extended his unbeaten run to 7 matches.

stockwellpete wrote: ↑Sun Oct 24, 2021 7:52 am

mh5064 wrote: ↑Sat Oct 23, 2021 8:08 pm Hi,

player Lunarfoxx in Classical Antiquity, Division F invoking rule 4 has arbitrarily canceled the battle because it is unfavorable to him.("Rule 4 Match Players may agree to re-start a match within the first three turns if they believe the terrain is likely to produce a sterile match or a draw. The maximum number of re-starts permitted for a single match is two.")
Without having agreed on the thing and without having responded positively. I quote his exact words "I don't known about this terrain. I might wanna redo this" and then "I'll set up the new match. gonna redo it within the 3 turns cuz of terrain".
But the ground was fine for me and certainly would not have produced a drawn or sterile game.
He also benefits from having seen the composition of my army.
I wanted to ask a question about this:
Is this kind of attitude regular?
Thanks

Cheers

I hope it is not, because it is against the rule. Rule 4 is quite clear . . .

"Players may agree to re-start a match within the first three turns if they believe the terrain is likely to produce a sterile match or a draw. The maximum number of re-starts permitted for a single match is two."

The key word here is "agree". What I can do is pass the match to our adjudication panel, if you so wish. Please let me know.

Maybe English is not his native language and it is too nuanced?

Perhaps if they had been able to chat about it?

Division D

devoncop - Khorasanian 821-1003 AD with Ghaznavid 962-1187 AD allies (1200) challenges Garokan Spanish 900-1049 AD with Andalusian 756-1049 AD allies

Password : devoncop1

PM sent