Page 11 of 12
Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting
Posted: Wed Sep 26, 2012 8:52 am
by rkr1958
spillblood wrote:Playing beta 2.10 as the Allies. I can't attack subs in the Atlantic with my destroyer squadrons except with some battleships. Is this a bug or is it some advantage given to the AI in this version? Or is it related to the fact I haven't researched ASW enough (haven't reached level 1 as GB yet). BTW, AI improvement is noticeable. The AI pulled off some pretty unexpected moves, like invading southern Caucasus via the Black Sea in 1941 (with masses of transports). It managed to invade France and Russia pretty well, could capture Yugoslavia in one turn, hasn't imvaded Greece though. I love the new map graphics with country names etc. Install went smoothly (I have Military History Europe CEAW).
You have to start the turn adjacent to a sub in order to attack it; except for CVs and air units. And, CVs can only attack subs before moving; except for subs hidden in a port.
Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting
Posted: Wed Sep 26, 2012 12:35 pm
by spillblood
Thanks. I think I have to read the full GS 2.1 manual one time. Didn't know this. I mostly played Axis before, it's my first time playing Allies. But as I said before, I didn't notice any bugs, the current installer seems pretty finished. I'll report back if I encounter any problems. I'll finish the game I started. Hehe, stopped yesterday because it was 4 a.m. in the morning when I saved.
Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting
Posted: Thu Sep 27, 2012 11:12 am
by rkr1958
spillblood wrote:Hehe, stopped yesterday because it was 4 a.m. in the morning when I saved.
I know the feeling.

Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting
Posted: Thu Sep 27, 2012 1:26 pm
by Morris
rkr1958 wrote:spillblood wrote:Hehe, stopped yesterday because it was 4 a.m. in the morning when I saved.
I know the feeling.

Me too . Once I played Allies by pbem after midnight ,I was so sleepy that after move UK & USA ,I forgot move USSR at all & just finish the turn . It was in 1942 .Heavy bloc fight in Russia , after this mistake my red army was defeated by a unexceptable circle ,then I lost the war ! Since this is a strategy game , never play it when you feel sleepy !

Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting
Posted: Thu Sep 27, 2012 5:33 pm
by Plaid
Well, not really a bug, but a glitch.
Italian "fortress" units (Palermo, Tobrul, whatever) can't be renamed, game consider them "SS" somehow.

Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting
Posted: Fri Sep 28, 2012 12:18 am
by Peter Stauffenberg
It's because the code is searching for "SS " or " SS" to find out that a unit is an SS unit. We are aware of this glitch, but figured we didn't want to fix it because GS v2.1 is frozen.
Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting
Posted: Fri Sep 28, 2012 11:24 am
by spillblood
Stauffenberg wrote:It's because the code is searching for "SS " or " SS" to find out that a unit is an SS unit. We are aware of this glitch, but figured we didn't want to fix it because GS v2.1 is frozen.
What does that mean, it's frozen?
Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting
Posted: Fri Sep 28, 2012 11:26 am
by spillblood
Morris wrote:rkr1958 wrote:spillblood wrote:Hehe, stopped yesterday because it was 4 a.m. in the morning when I saved.
I know the feeling.

Me too . Once I played Allies by pbem after midnight ,I was so sleepy that after move UK & USA ,I forgot move USSR at all & just finish the turn . It was in 1942 .Heavy bloc fight in Russia , after this mistake my red army was defeated by a unexceptable circle ,then I lost the war !)
I hope in Commander The Great War some kind of unit cycle button or unit list which shows moved/unmoved units is implemented. It's quite easy to overlook some units and not move them. I always find myself scanning the whole map for units which are still blinking before I end a turn, which is kinda annoying.
Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting
Posted: Fri Sep 28, 2012 12:25 pm
by Plaid
I hope in Commander The Great War some kind of unit cycle button or unit list which shows moved/unmoved units is implemented. It's quite easy to overlook some units and not move them. I always find myself scanning the whole map for units which are still blinking before I end a turn, which is kinda annoying.
This button already exists, page up and page down buttons do it in GS. If you want, you can also put non-active units (like city garrisons in rear areas) on sentry mode (s), so cycle will ignore them.
Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting
Posted: Fri Sep 28, 2012 12:36 pm
by Morris
Plaid wrote:I hope in Commander The Great War some kind of unit cycle button or unit list which shows moved/unmoved units is implemented. It's quite easy to overlook some units and not move them. I always find myself scanning the whole map for units which are still blinking before I end a turn, which is kinda annoying.
This button already exists, page up and page down buttons do it in GS. If you want, you can also put non-active units (like city garrisons in rear areas) on sentry mode (s), so cycle will ignore them.
It is quite useful ! but when you feel sleepy , you will be blind at the blinking!

Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 5:09 pm
by rkr1958
spillblood wrote:Stauffenberg wrote:It's because the code is searching for "SS " or " SS" to find out that a unit is an SS unit. We are aware of this glitch, but figured we didn't want to fix it because GS v2.1 is frozen.
What does that mean, it's frozen?
No more changes.
Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting
Posted: Mon Oct 01, 2012 3:04 pm
by spillblood
rkr1958 wrote:spillblood wrote:Stauffenberg wrote:It's because the code is searching for "SS " or " SS" to find out that a unit is an SS unit. We are aware of this glitch, but figured we didn't want to fix it because GS v2.1 is frozen.
What does that mean, it's frozen?
No more changes.
Until the GS 2.1 installer is released, or has mod development ended completely?
Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting
Posted: Wed Oct 03, 2012 8:27 am
by Plaid
Railroar glitch
Basically this corps in Milan is not connected to major germany railroad network (see hexes marked with red crosses), since moutains considered hexes without rail.
Still I can rail it to say Berlin, as you can see. Probably it is bug here.
Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting -- 2.1 messaging bug
Posted: Fri Oct 05, 2012 5:14 pm
by JimR
In a 2.1 game where I am the Axis, the Allies attacked Belgium in fall 1939 and got the expected message about American unhappiness, reduced convoys, no LL destroyer. In the spring, the Axis attacked neutral Holland and got a message about how the ALLIED attack on Holland has angered the Americans, thus reducing convoys and canceling the LL destroyer. In my Allied opponent's subsequent turn he got the same message (about Holland). These erroneous messages appear to have no effect on gameplay, since the Allies already were being penalized for their Belgium aggression. But the erroneous messaging is confusing, and it ought to be diagnosed and fixed.
Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting -- 2.1 messaging bug
Posted: Sat Oct 06, 2012 3:04 am
by Morris
JimR wrote:In a 2.1 game where I am the Axis, the Allies attacked Belgium in fall 1939 and got the expected message about American unhappiness, reduced convoys, no LL destroyer. In the spring, the Axis attacked neutral Holland and got a message about how the ALLIED attack on Holland has angered the Americans, thus reducing convoys and canceling the LL destroyer. In my Allied opponent's subsequent turn he got the same message (about Holland). These erroneous messages appear to have no effect on gameplay, since the Allies already were being penalized for their Belgium aggression. But the erroneous messaging is confusing, and it ought to be diagnosed and fixed.
I have experienced this too . It is a small problem which won't effect the game going . It just because they did not imagine that allies will Dow Belgium in 1939 in practice .

Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting
Posted: Sat Oct 06, 2012 6:18 pm
by spillblood
I'm having a problem that AI turn resolution hangs at the moment, can't finish the game I've written about here earlier. I'd like to send in a savegame (because the error occurs each time I reload that savegame and end the turn). Where do I have to send it to?
Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting
Posted: Mon Oct 15, 2012 12:15 am
by BuddyGrant
spillblood wrote:I'm having a problem that AI turn resolution hangs at the moment, can't finish the game I've written about here earlier. I'd like to send in a savegame (because the error occurs each time I reload that savegame and end the turn). Where do I have to send it to?
This usually happens to me if I 'trap' AI naval units, and there is no open hex for the AI naval unit to move to. The AI units will move 1 space away if it gets blocked, but if all the neighbouring hexes have units in them the game will hang, sometimes with a java error message in the DOS command box. Usually there are subs involved when this happens so if you have a lot of allied subs in play that might be the cause. The workaround solution to continue the game in this kind of error scenario is to replay the previous turn and moving your naval units (subs especially) a few hexes away from the AI units.
Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting
Posted: Mon Oct 15, 2012 5:14 am
by avoran
I just had the program hang because of a tricky situation with subs.
Was moving a bunch of UK DD's to surround a convoy on the west coast of Ireland. Turned out the last empty space had a uboat it in. After the attack on the uboat my DD was bounded *to the same hex as the convoy* - probably because there were no empty adjacent hexes. After that the program hung.
Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting
Posted: Mon Oct 15, 2012 10:55 am
by spillblood
BuddyGrant wrote:spillblood wrote:I'm having a problem that AI turn resolution hangs at the moment, can't finish the game I've written about here earlier. I'd like to send in a savegame (because the error occurs each time I reload that savegame and end the turn). Where do I have to send it to?
This usually happens to me if I 'trap' AI naval units, and there is no open hex for the AI naval unit to move to. The AI units will move 1 space away if it gets blocked, but if all the neighbouring hexes have units in them the game will hang, sometimes with a java error message in the DOS command box. Usually there are subs involved when this happens so if you have a lot of allied subs in play that might be the cause. The workaround solution to continue the game in this kind of error scenario is to replay the previous turn and moving your naval units (subs especially) a few hexes away from the AI units.
Yes, I think this is exactly what happened. I built a blob of naval units in Southern Atlantic to prevent the AI's subs from attacking my American transports carrying troops to North Africa. Seems some of them can't move which causes the game to hang.
Re: GS Beta Bug Reporting
Posted: Mon Dec 03, 2012 11:19 pm
by joerock22
Crazyg and I found a bug in our game. Axis player had rejected the French armistice and captured Brest manually. He had then moved a sub into that port. When the southern convoy came up, it ran into the sub in the port at Brest and was ambushed, losing 6 steps or so.
My explanation was that their radio died and they hadn't heard that Brest was lost.
