Page 2 of 5
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Mon Dec 29, 2014 7:42 am
by jomni
Sorry. Just saw this now will play out my turns soon.
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Mon Dec 29, 2014 1:17 pm
by pantherboy
cavehobbit (Royalists) 1.1pts (actually 1.14 before rounding to the nearest) vs pantherboy (Parliamentarian) 6.0pts (actually 5.97 before rounding to the nearest)
Royalists (5084)
Killed 596/133
Wounded 739/167
Captured/Deserted 955/223
Guns Lost 8
Parliamentarians (5662)
Killed 135/39
Wounded 273/79
Captured/Deserted 0
Guns Lost 0
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Mon Dec 29, 2014 2:08 pm
by krieg63
fogman wrote:SMALL RULE CHANGE
Ok, since i tested the matchups with solo skirmish, I didn't know that for some esoteric reason, the mp option would be different. it seems now that 16 units would be a more efficient limit. therefore:
1. if you have started your games and were able to build an army with less than 20 point unused, contitnue.
2. if you have started your games and were not able to build an army with less than 20 points unused, resign the game, and restart.
guillaume, you send me a new challenge for catholic 32-38 vs swedes 30-34.
moving forward, all new challenges are now understood to be for games with a 16 unit limit.
Also, in the event of an unplayable game due to the random map, for instance huge amount of woods, if both sides agree, the game may restart.
but 16 unit is still short. some challenge are already impossible but if you are oblige to leave point or to take heavy but bad units that doesn't make sense.
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Mon Dec 29, 2014 3:06 pm
by krieg63
and by the way, if you change the rules, all games must restart
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Mon Dec 29, 2014 3:42 pm
by fogman
guillaume wrote:
but 16 unit is still short. some challenge are already impossible but if you are oblige to leave point or to take heavy but bad units that doesn't make sense.
16 unit limit is good enough to build an army without wasting over 20 points. it makes sense that a commander doesn't get to hand pick his army. historical commanders don't have that luxury.
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Mon Dec 29, 2014 3:43 pm
by fogman
guillaume wrote:and by the way, if you change the rules, all games must restart
you take it too seriously. just play and enjoy the games.
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Mon Dec 29, 2014 3:48 pm
by krieg63
so it will be without me
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Mon Dec 29, 2014 4:08 pm
by pantherboy
Everyone is laboring under the same conditions so it shouldn't sway the results either way. Everyone will have the same tough and easy matchups so everyone will enjoy equal access to scoring. But I wouldn't change the tournament rules as the games in both rounds should be resolved under the initial conditions. If anything just allow the Catholics fighting the Swedes to have 16 units (though I'm fine with playing at 90 points short).
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Mon Dec 29, 2014 4:37 pm
by fogman
guillaume wrote:so it will be without me
OK.
I'll contact iandavidsmith to pick up guillaume's games.
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Mon Dec 29, 2014 4:41 pm
by fogman
pantherboy wrote:Everyone is laboring under the same conditions so it shouldn't sway the results either way. Everyone will have the same tough and easy matchups so everyone will enjoy equal access to scoring. But I wouldn't change the tournament rules as the games in both rounds should be resolved under the initial conditions. If anything just allow the Catholics fighting the Swedes to have 16 units (though I'm fine with playing at 90 points short).
doesn't make a difference either way. i don't understand why people get worked up over such things. this is meant to be hobby, relaxation time.
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Mon Dec 29, 2014 5:30 pm
by krieg63
fogman wrote:pantherboy wrote:Everyone is laboring under the same conditions so it shouldn't sway the results either way. Everyone will have the same tough and easy matchups so everyone will enjoy equal access to scoring. But I wouldn't change the tournament rules as the games in both rounds should be resolved under the initial conditions. If anything just allow the Catholics fighting the Swedes to have 16 units (though I'm fine with playing at 90 points short).
doesn't make a difference either way. i don't understand why people get worked up over such things. this is meant to be hobby, relaxation time.
sorry if I don't understand rigid rules and sorry If I have no pleasure to have to follow your decision...
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Tue Dec 30, 2014 12:33 am
by jomni
Should I be fighting ggarynorman? I joined a battle with him. But in the table, I'm up against pantherboy.
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Tue Dec 30, 2014 2:41 am
by fogman
jomni wrote:Should I be fighting ggarynorman? I joined a battle with him. But in the table, I'm up against pantherboy.
yes. you have to challenge me and pantherboy but if you look vertically from your name ggarynorman is one of the 3 players who are challenging you.
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Tue Dec 30, 2014 4:57 am
by iandavidsmith
Hi ,
I have taken over guillaume's position and games.
If anyone has started playing some games with him please restart
and send challenges to me , or let me know the password if games
have already been set up but not picked up.
My challenges to the following have been posted ....
jomni
fogman
cavehobbit
password = username (lower case as above)
Good Luck
Ian
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Tue Dec 30, 2014 12:37 pm
by ggarynorman
Hi Ian
Challenge posted Pw your name in lower case
Good luck
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Fri Jan 02, 2015 10:03 am
by cavehobbit
cavehobbit (Parliamentarian) 6.0 pts vs fogman (Scots) 2.0 pts
Parliamentarians (5109)
Killed 299/12
Wounded 600/26
Captured/Deserted 82/0
Guns Lost 0
Scots (5512)
Killed 763/118
Wounded 940/151
Captured/Deserted 1156/244
Guns Lost 8
Fogman, would you please check my calculations.
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Fri Jan 02, 2015 2:52 pm
by cavehobbit
cavehobbit (Protestant) 5.1 pts vs ggarynorman (Catholic) 2.6 pts
Catholic (8037)
Killed 499/96
Wounded 1002/195
Captured/Deserted 0/13
Guns Lost 0
Protestant (9554)
Killed 996/262
Wounded 1230/325
Captured/Deserted 1801/337
Guns Lost 8
Gary, please check my calculations.
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Sun Jan 04, 2015 3:03 am
by Asterix_von_TWC
Is there still space? I am highly interested
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Sun Jan 04, 2015 5:18 am
by pantherboy
I've posted the challenge for jomni vs. pantherboy
password: jomni
Cheers,
Steve
Re: LORDS OF PIKE & SHOT 1
Posted: Sun Jan 04, 2015 5:50 am
by jomni
Attn fogman.
I have created the challenge.
Password: fogman