Slitherine

Aetius39 wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 4:03 am First of all, great job getting this together!

Second, this might be somewhere but I can't find it, so asking this: does the attacker lose their province if they are defeated by the defenders, or just the defender keeps their province and only attackers gain?

Thanks!
Aetius

As Karvon says. It's in the Effects of battle outcome part of the rules (second post of this thread).

Are we waiting until all attacks are announced before defenders set up the games? Presumably defenders should PM their opponent when the game is set up?

rbodleyscott wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 6:51 am Are we waiting until all attacks are announced before defenders set up the games?

Yes, let's do that. Now it's only three left: deeter, Blagrot, and Aetius39, who can announce attacks. Then we're off to the battlefields.

rbodleyscott wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 6:51 am Presumably defenders should PM their opponent when the game is set up?

Good idea, thanks! Added to the rules:

• When the challenge has been created, the defender, for information, sends PM to attacker and posts in tournament thread.
  

Just a suggestion, but maybe instead of each player having a full day to make an attack, once a player makes his declared attack the next one in order can immediately do it? Probably would cut the declaration time several days (and get to the good part; the battling )

Aetius39 wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 1:40 pm Just a suggestion, but maybe instead of each player having a full day to make an attack, once a player makes his declared attack the next one in order can immediately do it? Probably would cut the declaration time several days (and get to the good part; the battling )

True, that's how we do it (from the PM to you guys):

Once a player above has announced an attack, then player next in line is free to announce attack, up to his/her deadline.


Next in line is deeter: you can announce attack already now.

Deeter attacks Aetius39 in Armenia from Atropatene.

Attacker stakes Atropatene
Defender stakes Armenia

Good luck.

Deeter

Blagrot attacks Karvon in Kilika from Phrygia using the army of Phrygia with Greek 460-281 BC allies

Attacker stakes Phrygia

Defender stakes Kilika

Good luck and have fun

Blagrot

Aetius39 wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 1:40 pm Just a suggestion, but maybe instead of each player having a full day to make an attack, once a player makes his declared attack the next one in order can immediately do it? Probably would cut the declaration time several days (and get to the good part; the battling )

NOW it's you, Aetius! And then the battling is due...!

deeter wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 7:02 pm Deeter attacks Aetius39 in Armenia from Atropatene.

Attacker stakes Atropatene
Defender stakes Armenia

Good luck.

Deeter

I take it that you then also use the army of Atropatene in your attack? And no allies? (You've got Georgian 331 BC - 252 AD allies available to you, through your control of Atropatene.)

No. No Georgians. They bring nothing new to the table.

Deeter

batesmotel wrote: ↑Sun Sep 13, 2020 3:24 pm Round 1

batesmotel attacks TomoeGozen, using the army of Persis.
Attacker stakes: Karmania
Defender stakes: Hyrkania

Chris

I've just noticed that Chris has staked a satrapy that is not adjoining Hyrkania. Is that correct?
thanks,
Dave.

TomoeGozen wrote: ↑Mon Sep 14, 2020 8:06 pm

batesmotel wrote: ↑Sun Sep 13, 2020 3:24 pm Round 1

batesmotel attacks TomoeGozen, using the army of Persis.
Attacker stakes: Karmania
Defender stakes: Hyrkania

Chris

I've just noticed that Chris has staked a satrapy that is not adjoining Hyrkania. Is that correct?
thanks,
Dave.

Very observant, Dave! No, it's not correct: Chris/batesmotel must stake a satrapy that is adjacent to the one he's attacking. Which results in Parthyaia. Ok, batesmotel?

Sorry, missed that detail. Parthaiya it is.

Chris

Defense of Kilikia - Med-Agri

Blagrot attacking with Phygian and Greek allies.
Karvon defending with local Kilikian and Kyrene Greek allies.

pw karvon

PM sent

Karvon wrote: ↑Tue Sep 15, 2020 12:12 am Defense of Kilikia - Med-Agri...

Thanks, Karvon, for speedy challenge!

TomoeGozen wrote: ↑Fri Sep 11, 2020 9:12 pm TomoeGozen attacks Kronenblatt, using the army of Hyrkania with Skythian allies.
Attacker stakes: Baktriane
Defender stakes: Sogdiane

Defense of Sogdiane - steppe
TomoeGozen attacking with army of Hyrkania and Skythian allies.
kronenblatt defending with local army of Sogdiane and Indian allies.

password: DiSp
PM sent

rbodleyscott wrote: ↑Sat Sep 12, 2020 12:15 pm rbodleyscott attacks kronenblatt, using the army of Gedrosia.
Attacker stakes: Arachosia
Defender stakes: Indike

Defense of Indike - tropical
rbodleyscott attacking with army of Gedrosia, no allies.
kronenblatt defending with local army of Indike and Indian allies.

password: DiSp
PM sent


Oh, and to all eight of you: ensure that you have the latest version (v2) of Dividing the Spoils installed. (For next round, we will need to update it, since I saw some errors still on the allies side wrt available allies, but not for this round, ok?)

Defense 1 setup:

Aetius (Mesopotamia) vs. Karvon (Aegyptus/Arab allies) Mideast-agricultural/large map

Defense 2 setup:

Aetius (Armenia/Georgian allies) vs. Deeter (Atropatene) Mideastern-hills/large map

Pw for both games is korea

Also, I don't think I can attack this turn, as two of my satrapies are attacked and the remaining one can only attack Phrygia, which is already attacking.

So there isn't anything else I can do, right? If so, let the battles commence!

batesmotel wrote: ↑Sun Sep 13, 2020 3:24 pm Round 1

batesmotel attacks TomoeGozen, using the army of Persis.
Attacker stakes: Karmania
Defender stakes: Hyrkania

Chris

Game created and PM sent.
Good luck and have a good game.

Aetius39 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 15, 2020 6:22 am Also, I don't think I can attack this turn, as two of my satrapies are attacked and the remaining one can only attack Phrygia, which is already attacking.

So there isn't anything else I can do, right? If so, let the battles commence!

Yes, that seems to be correct.

Kronenblatt defeats TomoeGozen 45-19% and takes control over Baktriane.

How did you find the two opposing army lists, TomoeGozen? For example; were they sufficiently different with local variation?